WEBVTT

NOTE
This file was generated by Descript <www.descript.com>

00:00:13.464 --> 00:00:14.094
Thank you very much.

00:00:14.134 --> 00:00:15.364
It's a great pleasure

00:00:16.614 --> 00:00:18.384
to speak to you here.

00:00:18.584 --> 00:00:19.084
Thank you for

00:00:19.084 --> 00:00:19.874
the invitation.

00:00:20.624 --> 00:00:21.374
I'm delighted

00:00:21.794 --> 00:00:22.584
to join you.

00:00:23.343 --> 00:00:24.793
And I just want

00:00:24.794 --> 00:00:26.984
to  get going and

00:00:26.984 --> 00:00:28.864
start talking about

00:00:31.144 --> 00:00:33.404
a topic that when

00:00:33.404 --> 00:00:34.824
you study economics,

00:00:34.833 --> 00:00:36.073
surprisingly, is not

00:00:36.073 --> 00:00:36.894
actually mentioned

00:00:36.894 --> 00:00:39.673
very often  even

00:00:39.673 --> 00:00:40.173
though when you

00:00:40.184 --> 00:00:40.704
think about the

00:00:40.704 --> 00:00:42.073
economy, most people

00:00:42.083 --> 00:00:43.063
immediately think

00:00:43.063 --> 00:00:44.144
about, and that is

00:00:44.144 --> 00:00:46.384
the topic of money.

00:00:47.294 --> 00:00:50.954
Now  I, I heard that

00:00:51.393 --> 00:00:54.843
you were at  the Dom

00:00:55.463 --> 00:00:57.344
in Milan yesterday,

00:00:58.474 --> 00:01:00.274
and  some of you

00:01:00.274 --> 00:01:01.324
were quite impressed

00:01:01.364 --> 00:01:03.544
by the incredible

00:01:03.593 --> 00:01:04.514
edifice that was

00:01:04.524 --> 00:01:05.843
built there over,

00:01:06.434 --> 00:01:07.573
over centuries.

00:01:08.314 --> 00:01:09.114
Let's start out

00:01:09.114 --> 00:01:09.684
talking about

00:01:09.713 --> 00:01:10.643
cathedrals.

00:01:11.923 --> 00:01:13.204
Now, there was

00:01:13.204 --> 00:01:14.643
a, a small,

00:01:17.423 --> 00:01:17.944
At the time, a

00:01:17.944 --> 00:01:18.844
small country

00:01:20.994 --> 00:01:22.103
that had a very

00:01:22.104 --> 00:01:22.983
well-organized

00:01:22.983 --> 00:01:25.764
economy, and they

00:01:25.764 --> 00:01:26.973
loved cathedrals.

00:01:27.693 --> 00:01:29.194
They built cathedrals

00:01:29.244 --> 00:01:30.324
as part of the

00:01:33.053 --> 00:01:33.753
essentially

00:01:34.963 --> 00:01:35.804
their beliefs.

00:01:35.804 --> 00:01:36.743
They were Christian.

00:01:37.543 --> 00:01:39.564
The leaders felt they

00:01:39.564 --> 00:01:41.203
were called by God

00:01:41.274 --> 00:01:43.564
to lead the nation,

00:01:44.713 --> 00:01:46.143
and of course, they

00:01:46.143 --> 00:01:48.973
also wanted to  to

00:01:48.973 --> 00:01:50.323
have edifices that

00:01:50.323 --> 00:01:51.943
would be visible

00:01:52.413 --> 00:01:53.783
for centuries and

00:01:53.783 --> 00:01:55.044
would impress even a

00:01:55.044 --> 00:01:56.323
thousand years later.

00:01:58.053 --> 00:01:58.734
And so they built

00:01:58.763 --> 00:02:00.363
cathedrals, but

00:02:00.363 --> 00:02:01.033
not over six

00:02:01.033 --> 00:02:02.043
hundred years, no.

00:02:02.723 --> 00:02:03.453
The fastest was

00:02:03.454 --> 00:02:04.513
less than ten years,

00:02:05.333 --> 00:02:06.783
and the longest

00:02:06.843 --> 00:02:08.133
was forty years.

00:02:08.674 --> 00:02:09.663
So in the world of

00:02:09.693 --> 00:02:10.803
cathedral building,

00:02:10.833 --> 00:02:11.973
it's absolutely

00:02:11.983 --> 00:02:12.773
staggering.

00:02:12.923 --> 00:02:13.644
It's completely

00:02:13.653 --> 00:02:14.473
off the scale.

00:02:15.053 --> 00:02:16.373
And they built more

00:02:16.373 --> 00:02:17.603
than a dozen of those

00:02:19.732 --> 00:02:20.312
Now, what am I

00:02:20.312 --> 00:02:21.062
talking about?

00:02:21.492 --> 00:02:22.352
Does anyone know?

00:02:22.842 --> 00:02:23.822
Who loved cathedrals

00:02:23.822 --> 00:02:24.512
and kept building

00:02:24.732 --> 00:02:24.742
cathedrals.

00:02:24.792 --> 00:02:25.232
Of course, there's

00:02:25.232 --> 00:02:28.002
also major  abbeys

00:02:28.402 --> 00:02:29.492
and minsters.

00:02:30.962 --> 00:02:32.141
And actually a lot

00:02:32.141 --> 00:02:33.091
of the cathedrals

00:02:35.061 --> 00:02:36.081
they built in places

00:02:36.082 --> 00:02:36.741
of where there

00:02:36.742 --> 00:02:37.742
were already quite

00:02:37.742 --> 00:02:39.051
impressive houses

00:02:39.051 --> 00:02:40.042
of God and houses

00:02:40.042 --> 00:02:41.992
of worship, but they

00:02:41.992 --> 00:02:42.491
felt they weren't

00:02:42.492 --> 00:02:43.272
impressive enough.

00:02:43.621 --> 00:02:44.432
They tore them down.

00:02:46.721 --> 00:02:47.551
So where a lot of

00:02:47.561 --> 00:02:49.242
the Saxon minsters

00:02:49.262 --> 00:02:51.541
were, they then

00:02:51.641 --> 00:02:52.542
built cathedrals.

00:02:52.612 --> 00:02:53.221
I'm talking about

00:02:53.221 --> 00:02:54.041
the Normans.

00:02:55.452 --> 00:02:55.862
So we're talking

00:02:55.862 --> 00:02:56.551
about 1,000

00:02:56.561 --> 00:02:57.251
years ago.

00:02:58.362 --> 00:02:59.031
Now, how on earth

00:02:59.072 --> 00:03:00.031
did they do this?

00:03:00.461 --> 00:03:00.881
And building

00:03:00.881 --> 00:03:01.331
cathedrals

00:03:01.351 --> 00:03:02.192
was one thing.

00:03:04.851 --> 00:03:05.332
And there's this

00:03:05.332 --> 00:03:06.741
sort of 15 major

00:03:06.741 --> 00:03:07.441
cathedrals, and

00:03:07.441 --> 00:03:08.601
then you have also

00:03:09.772 --> 00:03:12.331
dozens of other large

00:03:13.781 --> 00:03:15.132
houses of worship

00:03:15.741 --> 00:03:17.082
of various names.

00:03:18.441 --> 00:03:20.951
But they built, of

00:03:20.951 --> 00:03:22.202
course, initially

00:03:22.811 --> 00:03:24.181
fortifications,

00:03:25.002 --> 00:03:29.111
keeps, castles  and

00:03:29.112 --> 00:03:30.351
the number of those

00:03:30.371 --> 00:03:32.591
is around 1,000.

00:03:32.591 --> 00:03:33.082
And we're talking

00:03:33.082 --> 00:03:33.501
about a very

00:03:33.502 --> 00:03:34.672
short time period,

00:03:35.451 --> 00:03:36.092
essentially the

00:03:36.092 --> 00:03:38.411
first fi-  first

00:03:38.601 --> 00:03:41.111
five  Norman

00:03:41.112 --> 00:03:42.231
kings of England

00:03:45.166 --> 00:03:45.986
The time period is

00:03:45.986 --> 00:03:48.616
quite short when they

00:03:48.616 --> 00:03:49.416
achieved all this.

00:03:49.426 --> 00:03:50.876
How did they do this?

00:03:51.936 --> 00:03:52.466
It's all about

00:03:52.526 --> 00:03:54.176
organizing society

00:03:56.184 --> 00:03:57.384
motivating people

00:03:59.254 --> 00:04:00.584
and knowing how

00:04:03.674 --> 00:04:04.684
how to do things

00:04:04.724 --> 00:04:05.824
effectively and

00:04:05.824 --> 00:04:06.584
efficiently.

00:04:07.933 --> 00:04:08.963
Now, when you build

00:04:08.994 --> 00:04:10.204
a cathedral or a

00:04:10.204 --> 00:04:11.103
major castle, a

00:04:11.103 --> 00:04:11.753
major fortification

00:04:15.016 --> 00:04:15.905
Today the costs

00:04:15.926 --> 00:04:17.146
are totally off the

00:04:17.146 --> 00:04:18.176
scale because  we

00:04:18.176 --> 00:04:19.776
cannot do it, which

00:04:19.776 --> 00:04:20.856
is  mind-boggling

00:04:20.875 --> 00:04:21.255
because, of course,

00:04:21.255 --> 00:04:22.046
we've got much better

00:04:22.046 --> 00:04:23.436
technology, but we

00:04:23.436 --> 00:04:24.706
could not replicate

00:04:24.706 --> 00:04:26.166
these because the

00:04:26.166 --> 00:04:27.065
costs would be

00:04:27.066 --> 00:04:28.476
so prohibitive.

00:04:30.075 --> 00:04:30.635
If you looked into

00:04:30.646 --> 00:04:31.646
architecture, you

00:04:32.075 --> 00:04:32.875
… Some of you may be

00:04:32.875 --> 00:04:35.155
aware that    each

00:04:35.186 --> 00:04:37.175
era has its own way

00:04:37.176 --> 00:04:39.315
of building, and it

00:04:39.315 --> 00:04:40.926
turns out that thanks

00:04:40.936 --> 00:04:42.126
to economic progress,

00:04:42.436 --> 00:04:44.155
the previous ways

00:04:44.176 --> 00:04:46.265
of building become

00:04:46.285 --> 00:04:47.556
ever more expensive

00:04:47.556 --> 00:04:49.135
in the new era,

00:04:49.496 --> 00:04:50.755
thanks to technology.

00:04:52.665 --> 00:04:53.235
So how did

00:04:53.235 --> 00:04:53.945
they do this?

00:04:54.716 --> 00:04:55.555
Of course, buildings

00:04:55.556 --> 00:04:57.055
that  now have

00:04:57.056 --> 00:04:58.895
been around  for

00:04:58.895 --> 00:05:01.675
a millennium, and

00:05:02.115 --> 00:05:04.025
hopefully and likely

00:05:04.025 --> 00:05:06.455
will be around  for

00:05:06.455 --> 00:05:07.725
many more centuries.

00:05:09.226 --> 00:05:09.775
When you've got to

00:05:09.836 --> 00:05:11.805
mobilize big parts of

00:05:11.805 --> 00:05:13.486
society to do this,

00:05:14.215 --> 00:05:15.666
mobilize resources

00:05:19.245 --> 00:05:20.635
money is important.

00:05:21.655 --> 00:05:23.395
And they did this

00:05:23.395 --> 00:05:24.566
thanks to pieces

00:05:24.626 --> 00:05:26.475
of hazelwood.

00:05:27.825 --> 00:05:28.835
Here's an example.

00:05:31.645 --> 00:05:32.836
This is known as,

00:05:32.876 --> 00:05:34.835
as tally sticks,

00:05:34.836 --> 00:05:36.096
the split tally.

00:05:36.736 --> 00:05:37.775
Split into two

00:05:40.573 --> 00:05:41.294
and essentially

00:05:41.294 --> 00:05:42.943
it was a form of

00:05:42.943 --> 00:05:45.084
money, government

00:05:45.084 --> 00:05:46.714
money, but there

00:05:46.714 --> 00:05:47.474
were also private

00:05:47.474 --> 00:05:48.554
versions of it.

00:05:49.914 --> 00:05:50.613
And the system was

00:05:50.614 --> 00:05:52.133
very well organized

00:05:52.763 --> 00:05:54.433
by the Normans

00:05:54.433 --> 00:05:55.393
wherever they went.

00:05:56.753 --> 00:05:57.433
You may know

00:05:57.433 --> 00:06:00.414
that Sicily also

00:06:00.414 --> 00:06:01.244
experienced an

00:06:01.253 --> 00:06:02.483
era of great

00:06:02.513 --> 00:06:05.133
prosperity under

00:06:06.844 --> 00:06:07.883
the Norman kings.

00:06:09.023 --> 00:06:10.294
And they exchanged

00:06:10.553 --> 00:06:13.803
staff   there is a

00:06:15.554 --> 00:06:16.834
a Saxon treasurer

00:06:16.834 --> 00:06:17.653
who had worked

00:06:17.703 --> 00:06:19.453
in the exchequer

00:06:20.693 --> 00:06:22.514
of the Normans in

00:06:22.514 --> 00:06:24.083
England, working

00:06:24.083 --> 00:06:24.883
with tally sticks

00:06:24.883 --> 00:06:25.843
and their accounting

00:06:25.843 --> 00:06:27.863
system, and he

00:06:27.863 --> 00:06:28.983
then transferred,

00:06:30.354 --> 00:06:31.283
probably considered a

00:06:31.284 --> 00:06:32.503
promotion, and became

00:06:33.293 --> 00:06:33.873
the head of the

00:06:33.873 --> 00:06:35.513
treasury in Sicily

00:06:37.518 --> 00:06:37.878
But of course,

00:06:37.878 --> 00:06:39.378
the story is not

00:06:40.188 --> 00:06:41.777
direct  as you might

00:06:41.787 --> 00:06:43.297
think, because of

00:06:43.297 --> 00:06:44.368
course, the Sicilian

00:06:44.847 --> 00:06:46.448
royal line was a

00:06:46.448 --> 00:06:47.647
much younger one

00:06:48.178 --> 00:06:49.147
and considered by

00:06:49.157 --> 00:06:51.777
the  the Duke of

00:06:51.777 --> 00:06:52.607
Normandy and King

00:06:52.607 --> 00:06:54.767
of England pretty

00:06:54.768 --> 00:06:56.037
much low ranking.

00:06:56.518 --> 00:06:57.887
That's low country

00:06:57.887 --> 00:06:59.477
bumpkin aristocracy.

00:07:00.118 --> 00:07:01.037
But they managed to

00:07:01.928 --> 00:07:02.967
get onto the track

00:07:02.967 --> 00:07:04.068
to become kings of

00:07:04.068 --> 00:07:05.217
Sicily quite early

00:07:05.217 --> 00:07:06.257
on, which actually

00:07:06.258 --> 00:07:07.087
is likely to have

00:07:07.087 --> 00:07:09.628
inspired William

00:07:13.190 --> 00:07:13.979
William the

00:07:13.979 --> 00:07:14.560
Conqueror, as

00:07:14.560 --> 00:07:15.599
he later was

00:07:15.599 --> 00:07:17.240
called, because

00:07:17.240 --> 00:07:17.789
he thought, "What?

00:07:17.849 --> 00:07:20.640
That guy, son of

00:07:21.770 --> 00:07:22.729
Hauteville from

00:07:22.729 --> 00:07:25.140
that low-ranking

00:07:25.270 --> 00:07:26.849
country aristocracy

00:07:27.729 --> 00:07:28.560
is now gonna be

00:07:28.560 --> 00:07:29.969
duke and then on

00:07:30.009 --> 00:07:31.099
track to become

00:07:31.099 --> 00:07:32.439
king of Sicily?

00:07:33.139 --> 00:07:33.589
How is that

00:07:33.589 --> 00:07:35.009
possible?" Oh  the

00:07:35.020 --> 00:07:36.999
pope anointed him.

00:07:38.680 --> 00:07:40.370
He was on the

00:07:40.370 --> 00:07:41.469
First Crusade.

00:07:42.200 --> 00:07:42.939
It was a crusade.

00:07:43.079 --> 00:07:44.089
The first crusades

00:07:44.089 --> 00:07:44.780
were in Europe,

00:07:44.819 --> 00:07:45.580
inside Europe.

00:07:46.099 --> 00:07:47.229
It was the crusade

00:07:47.289 --> 00:07:49.770
to Christianize

00:07:49.889 --> 00:07:53.619
Sicily, drive out the

00:07:53.619 --> 00:07:55.489
non-Christian rulers

00:07:57.440 --> 00:07:59.789
And the Pope made,

00:07:59.830 --> 00:08:00.960
had already become

00:08:00.960 --> 00:08:02.180
acquainted with  and

00:08:02.180 --> 00:08:03.120
made good use of

00:08:04.070 --> 00:08:05.729
the Norman fighters.

00:08:06.210 --> 00:08:07.409
The Norman fighters,

00:08:07.719 --> 00:08:10.509
mercenaries were

00:08:10.510 --> 00:08:11.930
popular by rulers

00:08:11.949 --> 00:08:12.789
all over Europe

00:08:13.380 --> 00:08:13.969
because they were

00:08:13.969 --> 00:08:14.839
good fighters.

00:08:15.039 --> 00:08:15.739
Who were they?

00:08:15.979 --> 00:08:17.050
They were the younger

00:08:17.089 --> 00:08:19.319
sons of the families

00:08:19.320 --> 00:08:21.189
because in, in  Salic

00:08:21.199 --> 00:08:23.360
law, which the

00:08:23.890 --> 00:08:27.009
Normans also  adhered

00:08:27.019 --> 00:08:28.809
to, everything

00:08:28.810 --> 00:08:29.719
is inherited by

00:08:29.719 --> 00:08:30.810
the eldest son.

00:08:31.029 --> 00:08:32.839
Nothing for

00:08:33.599 --> 00:08:34.340
everyone else.

00:08:34.379 --> 00:08:34.849
Almost.

00:08:35.069 --> 00:08:35.379
There's some

00:08:35.379 --> 00:08:35.869
exceptions.

00:08:36.020 --> 00:08:37.509
We can carve some,

00:08:37.640 --> 00:08:38.440
some things out,

00:08:38.440 --> 00:08:39.999
but the principle

00:08:40.009 --> 00:08:41.529
is essentially

00:08:41.559 --> 00:08:42.360
everything goes

00:08:42.360 --> 00:08:43.799
to  the oldest son.

00:08:43.799 --> 00:08:44.530
So what do the

00:08:44.539 --> 00:08:47.040
other children do?

00:08:48.129 --> 00:08:49.340
And of course, some

00:08:50.410 --> 00:08:52.520
joined the church,

00:08:52.529 --> 00:08:53.849
and many Normans did.

00:08:54.399 --> 00:08:57.409
Many bishops  in

00:08:57.419 --> 00:08:58.909
many places in Europe

00:08:59.149 --> 00:09:00.379
hailed from Normandy.

00:09:01.249 --> 00:09:01.940
Certainly of course,

00:09:01.940 --> 00:09:03.490
in England after the

00:09:03.490 --> 00:09:06.159
conquest  essentially

00:09:06.159 --> 00:09:07.510
all the bishops were

00:09:07.510 --> 00:09:09.609
Norman, and often

00:09:11.970 --> 00:09:12.940
from high-ranking

00:09:12.949 --> 00:09:15.159
families  not the

00:09:15.169 --> 00:09:16.379
eldest son, the

00:09:16.379 --> 00:09:17.590
second, third son.

00:09:18.169 --> 00:09:19.329
But others, maybe

00:09:19.329 --> 00:09:20.569
lower down the ranks

00:09:21.979 --> 00:09:23.389
in the order of being

00:09:23.390 --> 00:09:24.780
born in the family,

00:09:25.739 --> 00:09:26.679
became mercenaries,

00:09:27.199 --> 00:09:29.339
and  they moved

00:09:29.569 --> 00:09:30.640
across Europe.

00:09:31.890 --> 00:09:33.000
And in this process,

00:09:33.000 --> 00:09:34.139
the Pope had already

00:09:34.819 --> 00:09:35.909
found that  they're

00:09:35.909 --> 00:09:36.769
really good fighters.

00:09:36.769 --> 00:09:37.609
He could use them

00:09:38.079 --> 00:09:39.480
in what later came

00:09:39.480 --> 00:09:40.519
to be called Italy.

00:09:40.519 --> 00:09:41.109
Italy, of course,

00:09:41.110 --> 00:09:42.090
didn't exist.

00:09:42.750 --> 00:09:44.279
The, this area was

00:09:44.279 --> 00:09:45.209
part of Germany.

00:09:46.099 --> 00:09:47.859
My land has been, had

00:09:47.860 --> 00:09:48.829
been part of Germany

00:09:48.829 --> 00:09:51.559
for  many centuries,

00:09:51.559 --> 00:09:52.469
basically since the

00:09:52.569 --> 00:09:54.689
sort of  eighth,

00:09:54.919 --> 00:09:55.979
ninth century.

00:09:56.439 --> 00:09:57.199
At one stage, part

00:09:57.199 --> 00:09:58.599
of Bavaria, where

00:09:59.500 --> 00:10:00.749
Austria  Switzerland

00:10:00.750 --> 00:10:01.439
didn't exist.

00:10:02.569 --> 00:10:04.409
These were parts

00:10:04.419 --> 00:10:05.529
of the southern

00:10:06.179 --> 00:10:07.150
regions of the

00:10:07.150 --> 00:10:08.129
Holy Roman Empire

00:10:08.129 --> 00:10:09.029
of German Nation.

00:10:10.470 --> 00:10:12.069
And the, the German

00:10:12.069 --> 00:10:14.139
kings  they were

00:10:15.779 --> 00:10:16.979
they elected among

00:10:16.989 --> 00:10:18.770
themselves an

00:10:18.779 --> 00:10:20.409
emperor who then

00:10:22.179 --> 00:10:23.030
felt the need to be

00:10:23.030 --> 00:10:24.460
anointed by the Pope.

00:10:25.039 --> 00:10:25.560
That's why the

00:10:25.569 --> 00:10:27.069
Holy Roman Empire.

00:10:28.550 --> 00:10:29.089
And of course, that

00:10:29.089 --> 00:10:29.989
gave the Pope certain

00:10:29.989 --> 00:10:31.470
powers, and  there

00:10:31.470 --> 00:10:31.940
were, there was

00:10:31.949 --> 00:10:33.170
various conflicts

00:10:33.259 --> 00:10:34.339
between the emperors

00:10:34.360 --> 00:10:35.689
and the Pope, but

00:10:35.690 --> 00:10:36.449
that was the setup.

00:10:36.449 --> 00:10:37.190
And essentially,

00:10:37.449 --> 00:10:39.719
their empire went

00:10:40.179 --> 00:10:41.739
just north  of

00:10:41.739 --> 00:10:43.877
Rome Which is

00:10:43.877 --> 00:10:44.657
why today even

00:10:44.958 --> 00:10:45.867
Southern Italians

00:10:45.867 --> 00:10:46.657
call about the,

00:10:47.068 --> 00:10:47.848
call the Northern

00:10:47.858 --> 00:10:49.617
Italians  Tedeschi.

00:10:51.767 --> 00:10:52.448
Which historically

00:10:52.458 --> 00:10:53.137
is true because it

00:10:53.137 --> 00:10:54.017
was the Lombards,

00:10:54.038 --> 00:10:55.147
the long beards,

00:10:55.348 --> 00:10:56.298
a Germanic tribe

00:10:56.308 --> 00:10:57.228
that settled there.

00:10:58.088 --> 00:10:59.137
And in fact, it

00:10:59.147 --> 00:11:01.758
was in the Lombard

00:11:01.957 --> 00:11:04.737
law, which was

00:11:04.737 --> 00:11:07.108
written in the 5th

00:11:07.117 --> 00:11:09.127
century, 6th century

00:11:11.407 --> 00:11:12.187
that these tally

00:11:12.188 --> 00:11:13.147
sticks were first

00:11:13.147 --> 00:11:14.737
mentioned in legal

00:11:14.737 --> 00:11:15.887
texts, in Germanic

00:11:15.897 --> 00:11:16.818
legal texts.

00:11:18.037 --> 00:11:18.668
So there is a

00:11:18.668 --> 00:11:19.797
connection  to

00:11:19.817 --> 00:11:20.307
Lombardy.

00:11:22.367 --> 00:11:22.688
Lombardy later

00:11:22.688 --> 00:11:23.507
becoming famous

00:11:23.507 --> 00:11:24.727
also for banking,

00:11:25.067 --> 00:11:25.687
the Lombard

00:11:25.727 --> 00:11:26.817
bankers, Lombard

00:11:26.817 --> 00:11:28.687
Street  in London.

00:11:30.997 --> 00:11:31.588
But yeah, so

00:11:31.588 --> 00:11:32.117
the Normans.

00:11:32.387 --> 00:11:33.237
Who are the Normans?

00:11:34.257 --> 00:11:35.647
The Normans were

00:11:35.717 --> 00:11:37.538
North Men, Nor

00:11:37.538 --> 00:11:38.728
Men, North Men,

00:11:39.987 --> 00:11:42.177
and  they hailed

00:11:42.188 --> 00:11:42.968
from what today

00:11:42.968 --> 00:11:44.197
would be Denmark,

00:11:45.067 --> 00:11:47.047
Norway, parts of

00:11:47.047 --> 00:11:48.947
Sweden, Scandinavia

00:11:52.718 --> 00:11:53.127
and of course

00:11:53.127 --> 00:11:53.517
they had their

00:11:53.517 --> 00:11:54.627
own history of

00:11:57.017 --> 00:11:58.978
able-bodied men in

00:11:58.978 --> 00:12:01.958
boats going out to

00:12:02.767 --> 00:12:03.898
bring in some money,

00:12:04.188 --> 00:12:05.917
bring in food, earn

00:12:05.918 --> 00:12:07.687
some money, raid some

00:12:08.257 --> 00:12:09.407
foreign villages,

00:12:09.507 --> 00:12:10.328
the Vikings.

00:12:11.147 --> 00:12:12.088
And the Vikings

00:12:12.137 --> 00:12:13.967
raided northern

00:12:13.977 --> 00:12:15.767
France so frequently

00:12:17.468 --> 00:12:18.317
because  the, the

00:12:18.317 --> 00:12:20.627
Seine was basically

00:12:20.627 --> 00:12:21.918
provided easy access.

00:12:21.918 --> 00:12:22.517
You go up the

00:12:22.517 --> 00:12:23.438
Seine in the Norman

00:12:23.438 --> 00:12:24.667
boats, and there's

00:12:24.697 --> 00:12:25.858
Paris, one of the

00:12:25.858 --> 00:12:26.607
biggest cities

00:12:26.607 --> 00:12:28.198
in Europe, rich.

00:12:28.587 --> 00:12:29.517
They raided Paris

00:12:29.517 --> 00:12:30.387
so often that if you

00:12:30.387 --> 00:12:31.578
go to Paris today,

00:12:32.298 --> 00:12:34.227
the crest, the city

00:12:34.287 --> 00:12:35.817
emblem of Paris is

00:12:35.818 --> 00:12:38.117
a Norman  a Viking

00:12:38.117 --> 00:12:38.817
boat we should say.

00:12:39.967 --> 00:12:40.277
The Normans didn't

00:12:40.278 --> 00:12:41.257
quite yet exist.

00:12:42.087 --> 00:12:42.517
So how did the

00:12:42.517 --> 00:12:43.467
Normans come about?

00:12:45.097 --> 00:12:48.497
The French king got

00:12:48.497 --> 00:12:49.387
a bit tired of these

00:12:49.438 --> 00:12:51.308
constant raids by

00:12:51.308 --> 00:12:53.247
the Vikings of Paris.

00:12:55.157 --> 00:12:56.268
And he thought,

00:12:56.268 --> 00:12:56.908
"Okay, we've gotta

00:12:56.908 --> 00:12:57.767
change this."

00:12:58.708 --> 00:12:59.347
perhaps a little bit

00:12:59.347 --> 00:13:01.137
like, like Donald

00:13:01.147 --> 00:13:01.958
Trump, he said,

00:13:02.377 --> 00:13:03.337
"  let's make a deal.

00:13:03.887 --> 00:13:04.788
We can make a deal.

00:13:04.858 --> 00:13:05.637
We can make a deal.

00:13:05.987 --> 00:13:07.787
So the next bunch

00:13:07.797 --> 00:13:08.617
of Vikings, when

00:13:08.617 --> 00:13:09.597
they arrive, guys,

00:13:09.928 --> 00:13:10.777
send them to me.

00:13:10.778 --> 00:13:11.198
Send their

00:13:11.198 --> 00:13:12.017
leader to me.

00:13:12.167 --> 00:13:12.837
We're gonna talk.

00:13:12.877 --> 00:13:13.367
We're gonna make

00:13:13.367 --> 00:13:15.347
a deal." That's

00:13:15.347 --> 00:13:15.857
what happens. And

00:13:15.858 --> 00:13:16.237
of course, the

00:13:16.237 --> 00:13:16.957
Vikings weren't

00:13:16.958 --> 00:13:17.497
afraid of anyone.

00:13:17.517 --> 00:13:18.467
"The king of France

00:13:18.467 --> 00:13:19.267
wants to see me.

00:13:20.748 --> 00:13:21.537
I'm Rollo, the

00:13:21.537 --> 00:13:22.357
leader." It was

00:13:22.367 --> 00:13:24.997
Rollo who then met

00:13:25.047 --> 00:13:25.697
the king of France.

00:13:25.697 --> 00:13:26.717
Yeah  we'll see them.

00:13:26.837 --> 00:13:28.747
So imagine the

00:13:28.748 --> 00:13:29.708
Viking leader

00:13:30.267 --> 00:13:31.777
Rollo with his men

00:13:33.818 --> 00:13:36.688
rolling up at the  at

00:13:36.688 --> 00:13:37.797
the meeting place in

00:13:37.797 --> 00:13:39.258
Paris where they met

00:13:39.877 --> 00:13:41.047
the king of France.

00:13:41.678 --> 00:13:42.128
And the king of

00:13:42.128 --> 00:13:43.617
France presumably

00:13:43.717 --> 00:13:44.537
first started with

00:13:44.537 --> 00:13:45.538
some small talk.

00:13:47.468 --> 00:13:49.757
So welcome to

00:13:49.757 --> 00:13:50.457
our country.

00:13:51.087 --> 00:13:51.857
Not so welcome

00:13:51.857 --> 00:13:52.417
really, but you

00:13:52.417 --> 00:13:54.427
know as things are.

00:13:54.847 --> 00:13:55.727
So here you are.

00:13:57.427 --> 00:13:59.417
Did you look at

00:13:59.417 --> 00:14:00.217
the country as

00:14:00.228 --> 00:14:01.357
you traveled up

00:14:01.387 --> 00:14:03.118
the Seine?" "Yes."

00:14:03.967 --> 00:14:05.578
"Did you see good

00:14:05.587 --> 00:14:07.237
land?" "Yes, very

00:14:07.237 --> 00:14:08.737
good land." "Did

00:14:08.737 --> 00:14:10.497
you see  the trees?

00:14:10.508 --> 00:14:10.947
We've got lots

00:14:10.947 --> 00:14:11.827
of apple trees."

00:14:11.827 --> 00:14:12.867
"Oh, very nice.

00:14:12.928 --> 00:14:14.608
Apple  we turn

00:14:14.608 --> 00:14:16.397
it into cider

00:14:16.428 --> 00:14:19.137
and yes." "Okay.

00:14:21.947 --> 00:14:22.537
Did you see the

00:14:22.538 --> 00:14:23.408
animals?" "Yes.

00:14:23.447 --> 00:14:24.858
Good, big animals,

00:14:24.887 --> 00:14:25.978
healthy animals."

00:14:27.097 --> 00:14:28.408
"So it's good land,

00:14:28.408 --> 00:14:29.297
isn't it?" "Yes, good

00:14:29.297 --> 00:14:30.177
land." "Did you see

00:14:30.178 --> 00:14:32.078
our women?" "Yes,

00:14:32.857 --> 00:14:34.408
good women." "Okay.

00:14:34.807 --> 00:14:35.267
So-"

00:14:37.400 --> 00:14:38.360
Here's the deal.

00:14:39.750 --> 00:14:41.090
Rollo, you're the

00:14:41.090 --> 00:14:42.130
leader of your men.

00:14:43.939 --> 00:14:44.930
I offer you to

00:14:44.960 --> 00:14:47.490
become the ruler

00:14:47.510 --> 00:14:48.240
of this land.

00:14:48.310 --> 00:14:49.189
All the land you

00:14:49.189 --> 00:14:51.170
saw from entering

00:14:51.510 --> 00:14:53.490
the Seine close

00:14:53.519 --> 00:14:55.759
up to Paris will

00:14:55.759 --> 00:14:56.659
make your land.

00:14:56.990 --> 00:14:58.040
You'll be the leader.

00:14:58.179 --> 00:14:59.060
You'll become the

00:14:59.069 --> 00:15:00.600
duke of this land,

00:15:01.550 --> 00:15:02.120
which then will be

00:15:02.120 --> 00:15:03.339
named after you guys.

00:15:03.529 --> 00:15:04.290
That probably wasn't

00:15:04.290 --> 00:15:04.880
even part of the

00:15:04.880 --> 00:15:05.600
deal, but that's

00:15:05.600 --> 00:15:06.239
what happened.

00:15:06.249 --> 00:15:07.710
It didn't used to

00:15:07.720 --> 00:15:09.999
be called Normandy.

00:15:11.289 --> 00:15:12.370
It had its own name.

00:15:13.569 --> 00:15:15.430
But once Rollo-- And

00:15:15.430 --> 00:15:16.099
Rollo, of course, his

00:15:16.099 --> 00:15:16.969
response will have

00:15:16.969 --> 00:15:18.499
for sure been, " I

00:15:18.539 --> 00:15:19.659
can't decide this.

00:15:20.009 --> 00:15:21.039
We're democratic,

00:15:21.210 --> 00:15:22.150
so I'm gonna ask

00:15:22.150 --> 00:15:23.599
my men." Everything

00:15:23.599 --> 00:15:25.890
was  was voted on

00:15:26.259 --> 00:15:27.510
in open discussion

00:15:30.092 --> 00:15:30.712
And I'm sure it

00:15:30.712 --> 00:15:31.382
was a sort of

00:15:31.422 --> 00:15:32.352
tricky decision.

00:15:32.662 --> 00:15:33.452
What about all our

00:15:33.452 --> 00:15:34.462
women back home?

00:15:34.702 --> 00:15:35.082
We're supposed to

00:15:35.092 --> 00:15:36.912
come back with loot

00:15:36.942 --> 00:15:38.362
and money and gold

00:15:39.392 --> 00:15:40.581
and provisions.

00:15:41.972 --> 00:15:42.811
We just know that

00:15:42.812 --> 00:15:44.152
the outcome was

00:15:44.192 --> 00:15:45.421
that Rollo and

00:15:45.422 --> 00:15:46.642
his men accepted,

00:15:47.632 --> 00:15:48.442
and they stayed.

00:15:49.181 --> 00:15:49.892
Now, there's a

00:15:49.892 --> 00:15:52.821
reason why the first

00:15:52.822 --> 00:15:53.702
language is called

00:15:53.702 --> 00:15:55.132
the  mother tongue.

00:15:56.851 --> 00:15:57.272
The Normans

00:15:57.292 --> 00:15:58.012
were mainly…

00:15:58.851 --> 00:15:59.782
These Vikings were

00:15:59.782 --> 00:16:02.381
mainly men, so they

00:16:02.382 --> 00:16:03.512
married locally,

00:16:04.361 --> 00:16:05.951
and already two

00:16:05.951 --> 00:16:07.251
generations down,

00:16:08.542 --> 00:16:10.131
there was no Nordic

00:16:10.132 --> 00:16:11.182
language left.

00:16:11.871 --> 00:16:12.512
They, of

00:16:12.512 --> 00:16:13.401
course, became

00:16:13.431 --> 00:16:14.282
French-speaking

00:16:16.843 --> 00:16:18.414
And this is how the

00:16:18.524 --> 00:16:20.233
Normans came to be.

00:16:20.363 --> 00:16:21.384
But they did, of

00:16:21.384 --> 00:16:22.223
course, keep in

00:16:22.223 --> 00:16:24.714
touch with    the

00:16:24.714 --> 00:16:26.103
Scandinavian nations,

00:16:26.733 --> 00:16:29.963
and they were in

00:16:29.964 --> 00:16:30.524
touch with the

00:16:30.524 --> 00:16:33.154
Saxon nations and

00:16:33.154 --> 00:16:34.004
also the various

00:16:34.004 --> 00:16:36.683
Germanic  traditions,

00:16:37.443 --> 00:16:40.643
including the  the

00:16:40.644 --> 00:16:41.914
tally stick system.

00:16:42.794 --> 00:16:44.704
So when William

00:16:44.704 --> 00:16:46.913
the Conqueror and

00:16:46.913 --> 00:16:48.263
his men conquered

00:16:48.723 --> 00:16:50.493
England in 1066,

00:16:52.863 --> 00:16:53.124
they were

00:16:53.134 --> 00:16:54.824
French-speaking, and

00:16:54.824 --> 00:16:55.424
that, by the way,

00:16:55.424 --> 00:16:56.753
is how the English

00:16:56.753 --> 00:16:57.893
language came about

00:16:58.003 --> 00:16:58.943
because before

00:16:58.943 --> 00:16:59.673
William the Conqueror

00:16:59.674 --> 00:17:00.483
arrived in England in

00:17:00.483 --> 00:17:02.153
1066, the country was

00:17:02.154 --> 00:17:04.403
German-speaking, the,

00:17:04.404 --> 00:17:05.373
in the main areas.

00:17:05.384 --> 00:17:07.233
Of course, the  the

00:17:07.233 --> 00:17:08.634
Celtic indigenous

00:17:08.634 --> 00:17:10.573
population was

00:17:10.573 --> 00:17:11.513
Celtic-speaking,

00:17:12.313 --> 00:17:13.023
Welsh,

00:17:13.134 --> 00:17:15.434
Cornish  Gaelic

00:17:17.548 --> 00:17:18.438
And they were

00:17:18.438 --> 00:17:19.938
driven evermore to

00:17:19.938 --> 00:17:21.188
the west, to the

00:17:21.188 --> 00:17:22.518
north, to the west,

00:17:23.018 --> 00:17:24.198
across to Ireland.

00:17:26.168 --> 00:17:26.768
Originally the

00:17:26.768 --> 00:17:28.018
Celts were the main

00:17:28.028 --> 00:17:29.348
European population.

00:17:29.348 --> 00:17:29.767
The whole of

00:17:29.768 --> 00:17:31.197
Europe  Celts

00:17:31.197 --> 00:17:31.847
were everywhere.

00:17:31.867 --> 00:17:32.728
Celts were here.

00:17:33.117 --> 00:17:34.637
Celts were in what

00:17:34.637 --> 00:17:35.807
is today Germany.

00:17:36.457 --> 00:17:37.528
But they got driven

00:17:37.627 --> 00:17:39.018
f- essentially

00:17:39.348 --> 00:17:40.158
constantly over

00:17:40.158 --> 00:17:40.848
the centuries

00:17:40.858 --> 00:17:41.627
further west.

00:17:41.948 --> 00:17:42.478
There's a great

00:17:42.487 --> 00:17:44.208
pocket of Celts

00:17:45.178 --> 00:17:47.487
in  little Brittany

00:17:50.198 --> 00:17:51.897
in little Britain.

00:17:52.687 --> 00:17:53.387
It's called Great

00:17:53.387 --> 00:17:54.188
Britain because

00:17:54.188 --> 00:17:54.688
there's a little

00:17:54.688 --> 00:17:55.428
Britain, and little

00:17:55.428 --> 00:17:56.647
Britain is Bretagne.

00:17:57.827 --> 00:17:58.447
I was a student

00:17:58.487 --> 00:17:59.657
my first year at

00:17:59.657 --> 00:18:01.478
university  before

00:18:01.487 --> 00:18:02.027
I went to the London

00:18:02.027 --> 00:18:02.807
School of Economics,

00:18:02.807 --> 00:18:03.787
I was for one year at

00:18:03.858 --> 00:18:04.717
Cardiff University,

00:18:04.727 --> 00:18:06.037
capital of Wales, and

00:18:06.887 --> 00:18:07.977
the volleyball club.

00:18:08.448 --> 00:18:10.707
We had  some exchange

00:18:10.707 --> 00:18:12.407
students from Nantes,

00:18:14.038 --> 00:18:15.117
and we had some

00:18:15.117 --> 00:18:17.317
Welsh  students in

00:18:17.338 --> 00:18:18.347
our club as well.

00:18:18.737 --> 00:18:19.007
And it was just

00:18:19.007 --> 00:18:19.927
astonishing to me

00:18:19.928 --> 00:18:21.337
how they could 100%

00:18:21.367 --> 00:18:22.168
communicate with

00:18:22.168 --> 00:18:23.638
each other in Welsh.

00:18:23.907 --> 00:18:24.797
Of course, you'd

00:18:24.797 --> 00:18:26.228
say Breton  in

00:18:26.238 --> 00:18:27.367
France, but it's

00:18:27.367 --> 00:18:28.257
the same language,

00:18:28.887 --> 00:18:29.858
the Celtic language.

00:18:30.738 --> 00:18:31.818
Anyway, but as

00:18:31.818 --> 00:18:33.767
the  the Saxons had

00:18:33.768 --> 00:18:34.657
arrived, the Angles

00:18:34.657 --> 00:18:36.237
and Saxons  they

00:18:36.238 --> 00:18:37.018
were driven further

00:18:37.018 --> 00:18:37.877
and further west.

00:18:38.577 --> 00:18:40.177
And now with the

00:18:40.177 --> 00:18:41.298
Normans arriving,

00:18:41.298 --> 00:18:42.247
speaking French,

00:18:42.247 --> 00:18:42.927
you had this

00:18:45.027 --> 00:18:46.017
development where

00:18:46.088 --> 00:18:46.967
the elite and the

00:18:46.967 --> 00:18:47.727
Normans were only

00:18:48.797 --> 00:18:49.838
in the thousands,

00:18:50.637 --> 00:18:51.447
not hundreds

00:18:51.448 --> 00:18:52.148
of thousands.

00:18:52.207 --> 00:18:52.517
No.

00:18:53.217 --> 00:18:53.407
There were

00:18:53.407 --> 00:18:54.187
never that many.

00:18:54.607 --> 00:18:55.487
So it was a small

00:18:55.488 --> 00:18:57.927
elite that came to

00:18:58.007 --> 00:18:59.087
own all the land

00:19:01.948 --> 00:19:03.388
hence the stories,

00:19:03.408 --> 00:19:04.588
as  of Robin Hood,

00:19:04.838 --> 00:19:05.928
the basically

00:19:06.378 --> 00:19:07.988
expropriated previous

00:19:07.988 --> 00:19:09.238
Saxon landowners

00:19:09.238 --> 00:19:10.398
and aristocrats.

00:19:12.228 --> 00:19:12.618
That was, of

00:19:12.618 --> 00:19:13.648
course  pretty

00:19:13.648 --> 00:19:14.257
tough for them.

00:19:14.648 --> 00:19:15.157
But the Normans

00:19:15.178 --> 00:19:15.538
became the

00:19:15.538 --> 00:19:16.237
landowners, the

00:19:16.247 --> 00:19:17.588
lords of the manors.

00:19:18.778 --> 00:19:19.727
And William

00:19:19.727 --> 00:19:20.097
the Conqueror

00:19:20.098 --> 00:19:21.248
introduced a tax.

00:19:22.657 --> 00:19:23.247
There was only one

00:19:23.247 --> 00:19:24.627
tax, a land tax.

00:19:25.028 --> 00:19:25.658
Nobody else had

00:19:25.667 --> 00:19:26.947
to pay taxes.

00:19:26.987 --> 00:19:27.367
There was no

00:19:27.368 --> 00:19:28.257
income tax.

00:19:29.417 --> 00:19:30.598
In the past, in fact,

00:19:30.647 --> 00:19:32.038
in, in most of the

00:19:32.038 --> 00:19:33.137
world, but certainly

00:19:33.137 --> 00:19:35.158
in Europe  taxes

00:19:35.158 --> 00:19:36.167
were always low.

00:19:36.847 --> 00:19:37.917
We live in the era

00:19:37.917 --> 00:19:39.188
of the highest taxes

00:19:39.198 --> 00:19:41.287
in history, and the

00:19:41.288 --> 00:19:42.217
further you go back,

00:19:42.218 --> 00:19:43.658
the lower taxes were.

00:19:44.538 --> 00:19:45.377
So there's this land

00:19:45.378 --> 00:19:46.157
tax, and William

00:19:46.157 --> 00:19:47.038
the Conqueror had

00:19:47.047 --> 00:19:48.958
his surveyors go out

00:19:49.038 --> 00:19:50.688
and assess the land.

00:19:51.198 --> 00:19:51.647
Of course, the

00:19:51.648 --> 00:19:52.477
landowners, he

00:19:52.477 --> 00:19:53.248
had put all these

00:19:53.248 --> 00:19:54.167
people in place that

00:19:54.167 --> 00:19:55.138
supported him in his

00:19:55.138 --> 00:19:59.257
campaign, and  they

00:19:59.257 --> 00:20:00.408
had to pay this tax

00:20:00.428 --> 00:20:01.517
to him based on the

00:20:01.518 --> 00:20:02.328
land, the size of

00:20:02.328 --> 00:20:02.887
the land, which is

00:20:02.887 --> 00:20:03.578
written down in the

00:20:03.587 --> 00:20:04.888
Doomsday,  Doomsday

00:20:04.888 --> 00:20:05.427
Books because they

00:20:05.427 --> 00:20:06.927
were huge, gigantic

00:20:06.927 --> 00:20:08.048
books, very detailed.

00:20:08.357 --> 00:20:09.128
That was already

00:20:09.407 --> 00:20:10.197
almost a thousand

00:20:10.208 --> 00:20:11.528
years ago when

00:20:11.528 --> 00:20:12.737
they were drawn up.

00:20:13.867 --> 00:20:14.507
And how was this

00:20:14.528 --> 00:20:15.497
tax collected?

00:20:16.317 --> 00:20:17.047
You had

00:20:19.357 --> 00:20:21.377
you had  the reeves.

00:20:22.628 --> 00:20:23.527
The Germanic word

00:20:23.528 --> 00:20:25.477
is Graf, and if you

00:20:25.477 --> 00:20:26.557
have a very soft G,

00:20:26.558 --> 00:20:27.897
then the  falls away.

00:20:27.957 --> 00:20:28.567
Reeves,

00:20:28.567 --> 00:20:29.137
Greaves, Reeves.

00:20:30.268 --> 00:20:30.707
The reeves

00:20:30.707 --> 00:20:31.537
of the shire

00:20:31.577 --> 00:20:32.958
collected the tax.

00:20:33.717 --> 00:20:34.267
The reeves of

00:20:34.268 --> 00:20:35.028
the shire, also

00:20:35.028 --> 00:20:35.947
known as the shire

00:20:35.948 --> 00:20:37.927
reeves or sheriffs.

00:20:38.937 --> 00:20:39.847
And the sheriffs

00:20:39.867 --> 00:20:42.108
were summoned twice

00:20:42.108 --> 00:20:44.307
a year to the High

00:20:44.308 --> 00:20:45.737
Court of Equity known

00:20:45.738 --> 00:20:46.767
as the Exchequer.

00:20:47.477 --> 00:20:48.397
It was a court,

00:20:48.817 --> 00:20:51.007
a high court, and

00:20:51.007 --> 00:20:52.067
the sheriffs were

00:20:52.077 --> 00:20:53.177
summoned as the

00:20:53.177 --> 00:20:55.747
accused, and that

00:20:55.747 --> 00:20:57.147
was not anything

00:20:57.147 --> 00:20:57.838
to mess with.

00:20:57.867 --> 00:20:58.457
They were the

00:20:58.488 --> 00:21:00.008
accused in this court

00:21:02.222 --> 00:21:03.922
They were  charged

00:21:03.922 --> 00:21:05.062
with a tax that

00:21:05.072 --> 00:21:07.882
had to be paid at

00:21:07.882 --> 00:21:09.322
the exchequer to

00:21:09.322 --> 00:21:10.152
the government,

00:21:10.212 --> 00:21:10.902
to the king

00:21:12.972 --> 00:21:13.831
twice a year.

00:21:14.132 --> 00:21:14.672
So the year was

00:21:14.672 --> 00:21:15.312
divided into

00:21:15.312 --> 00:21:15.642
two halves.

00:21:18.111 --> 00:21:18.961
Michaelmas

00:21:19.372 --> 00:21:20.671
and Easter.

00:21:22.091 --> 00:21:23.462
Michaelmas around

00:21:24.011 --> 00:21:25.071
late September,

00:21:25.331 --> 00:21:26.292
and then Easter,

00:21:26.351 --> 00:21:27.042
whenever Easter

00:21:27.042 --> 00:21:30.041
fell, so roughly  two

00:21:30.042 --> 00:21:31.241
six-month periods.

00:21:32.411 --> 00:21:33.691
And in the first

00:21:34.202 --> 00:21:35.211
gathering at

00:21:35.211 --> 00:21:36.542
Michaelmas, you

00:21:36.542 --> 00:21:37.402
roughly only had to

00:21:37.402 --> 00:21:38.752
pay half the tax,

00:21:40.361 --> 00:21:41.711
and then a record

00:21:41.771 --> 00:21:43.172
was issued, a tax

00:21:43.172 --> 00:21:43.711
recei- receipt, and

00:21:44.332 --> 00:21:45.192
this is what this is.

00:21:45.202 --> 00:21:46.012
These are tax

00:21:46.012 --> 00:21:46.731
receipts, these

00:21:46.731 --> 00:21:47.622
tally sticks.

00:21:49.902 --> 00:21:50.311
So how does

00:21:50.312 --> 00:21:50.961
this work?

00:21:51.161 --> 00:21:53.641
Basically, hazelwood.

00:21:53.872 --> 00:21:55.731
Hazel is almost a  a

00:21:55.742 --> 00:21:57.602
weed  grows anywhere,

00:21:57.671 --> 00:21:58.391
doesn't really have

00:21:58.391 --> 00:22:00.911
much of a value  so

00:22:00.911 --> 00:22:01.641
nothing special,

00:22:01.641 --> 00:22:02.451
and  that's a good

00:22:02.452 --> 00:22:03.952
thing, so no resource

00:22:03.952 --> 00:22:05.742
costs and you just

00:22:05.742 --> 00:22:07.781
need a  branch

00:22:07.881 --> 00:22:08.631
thick enough and

00:22:08.631 --> 00:22:10.581
you cut your tally

00:22:10.582 --> 00:22:11.661
stick out of it.

00:22:11.762 --> 00:22:13.191
Initially, just  a

00:22:13.531 --> 00:22:15.692
rectangular  stick,

00:22:16.411 --> 00:22:17.481
but then you carve

00:22:17.491 --> 00:22:18.711
the numbers in.

00:22:19.521 --> 00:22:20.651
This particular one

00:22:20.711 --> 00:22:23.491
is 2,000 pounds.

00:22:23.501 --> 00:22:24.931
2,000, so that's

00:22:24.942 --> 00:22:25.951
on the back, very

00:22:25.951 --> 00:22:28.101
large notches, bigger

00:22:28.101 --> 00:22:28.871
than your thumb.

00:22:29.391 --> 00:22:30.302
These are the 1,000

00:22:30.302 --> 00:22:31.241
pounds, which they

00:22:31.241 --> 00:22:32.831
would be close to

00:22:32.832 --> 00:22:33.471
a million, so two,

00:22:33.481 --> 00:22:34.881
two million perhaps.

00:22:34.891 --> 00:22:36.822
2,000 pound… This

00:22:36.832 --> 00:22:37.821
is inflation, right?

00:22:37.832 --> 00:22:39.381
2,000 pounds.

00:22:39.981 --> 00:22:41.351
And here we have

00:22:42.571 --> 00:22:43.131
on the upper

00:22:43.131 --> 00:22:44.262
side, so the, your

00:22:44.271 --> 00:22:45.921
index finger size

00:22:46.262 --> 00:22:47.261
is the hundreds.

00:22:48.181 --> 00:22:50.871
So we had 2,100, then

00:22:50.871 --> 00:22:52.562
come the, this is

00:22:54.402 --> 00:22:55.961
23 pounds, getting

00:22:55.961 --> 00:22:56.882
ever smaller, so

00:22:56.882 --> 00:22:57.781
your little finger

00:22:57.801 --> 00:23:01.041
side  is the single

00:23:01.051 --> 00:23:02.321
digit pound unit.

00:23:02.741 --> 00:23:03.561
And then you had,

00:23:03.582 --> 00:23:04.371
in this case, we've

00:23:04.371 --> 00:23:06.591
got  four shillings

00:23:06.641 --> 00:23:08.022
and five pence, and

00:23:08.161 --> 00:23:09.141
pence, pennies are

00:23:09.751 --> 00:23:11.251
very thin lines here.

00:23:12.082 --> 00:23:13.102
And then this was

00:23:13.111 --> 00:23:14.991
split, and that

00:23:14.992 --> 00:23:16.811
created a forgery

00:23:16.832 --> 00:23:18.532
pr- proof instrument,

00:23:18.601 --> 00:23:19.831
financial instrument,

00:23:20.692 --> 00:23:21.601
as it turned out.

00:23:21.832 --> 00:23:22.301
Initially it was

00:23:22.302 --> 00:23:23.542
just a tax receipt.

00:23:24.272 --> 00:23:24.981
Forgery proof

00:23:24.992 --> 00:23:26.441
because it's like

00:23:26.442 --> 00:23:27.172
your fingerprint.

00:23:27.172 --> 00:23:28.111
It's a unique

00:23:29.811 --> 00:23:30.461
pattern.

00:23:31.781 --> 00:23:33.631
The longer one

00:23:35.384 --> 00:23:37.234
Would be  they've

00:23:37.234 --> 00:23:37.994
made a hole here

00:23:37.994 --> 00:23:38.984
and hang it up in

00:23:38.984 --> 00:23:40.354
the Royal Treasury.

00:23:40.514 --> 00:23:40.954
The Exchequer

00:23:40.954 --> 00:23:41.694
was inside the

00:23:41.704 --> 00:23:43.684
Royal Treasury  so

00:23:43.684 --> 00:23:44.354
originally in the

00:23:44.354 --> 00:23:45.664
capital city of

00:23:45.664 --> 00:23:46.454
England when William

00:23:46.464 --> 00:23:47.133
the Conqueror

00:23:47.723 --> 00:23:48.484
came over, which

00:23:48.484 --> 00:23:49.473
was Winchester.

00:23:50.683 --> 00:23:51.704
So in the Royal

00:23:51.704 --> 00:23:52.164
Treasury in

00:23:52.164 --> 00:23:53.393
Winchester, which

00:23:53.394 --> 00:23:54.934
is inside the Royal

00:23:54.964 --> 00:23:56.224
Palace, they'd

00:23:56.224 --> 00:23:58.734
hang up  the longer

00:23:58.734 --> 00:23:59.394
bit, which was

00:23:59.394 --> 00:24:00.584
known as the foil.

00:24:01.823 --> 00:24:02.744
The shorter one

00:24:03.263 --> 00:24:04.534
was handed out and

00:24:04.534 --> 00:24:05.253
essentially could

00:24:05.253 --> 00:24:06.484
then circulate.

00:24:07.313 --> 00:24:08.293
If ever there was

00:24:08.293 --> 00:24:09.393
a concern, you

00:24:09.394 --> 00:24:10.123
could always check

00:24:10.133 --> 00:24:11.263
whether they fit.

00:24:11.863 --> 00:24:12.653
This is of course

00:24:12.653 --> 00:24:15.764
what the idea in  in

00:24:15.804 --> 00:24:17.874
Bitcoin of a public

00:24:17.883 --> 00:24:18.763
key and a private

00:24:18.763 --> 00:24:19.884
key was based on.

00:24:19.923 --> 00:24:20.654
So we've got the

00:24:20.654 --> 00:24:21.963
public key, we've

00:24:21.964 --> 00:24:23.123
got the private key

00:24:24.034 --> 00:24:25.014
and you can check

00:24:25.503 --> 00:24:26.644
whether they match.

00:24:27.753 --> 00:24:28.264
Now when they

00:24:28.264 --> 00:24:29.903
match, they tally.

00:24:30.323 --> 00:24:31.313
That's the expression

00:24:32.113 --> 00:24:33.003
for, oh, the,

00:24:33.013 --> 00:24:33.853
that tallies.

00:24:33.863 --> 00:24:35.203
It tallies comes from

00:24:35.223 --> 00:24:36.183
because the split

00:24:36.203 --> 00:24:37.364
tally fit together.

00:24:37.833 --> 00:24:38.943
If it doesn't fit,

00:24:39.063 --> 00:24:40.313
you've been foiled.

00:24:40.763 --> 00:24:42.003
Some fraudulent

00:24:42.033 --> 00:24:42.914
attempt has been

00:24:42.914 --> 00:24:44.373
foiled because the

00:24:44.374 --> 00:24:45.584
foil didn't fit

00:24:48.270 --> 00:24:48.800
In fact, a lot

00:24:48.800 --> 00:24:49.910
of financial and

00:24:49.910 --> 00:24:51.690
accounting f-  words

00:24:51.690 --> 00:24:52.440
come from this

00:24:52.440 --> 00:24:54.879
royal exchequer.

00:24:55.040 --> 00:24:55.520
The word for

00:24:55.520 --> 00:24:56.190
check, as you

00:24:56.190 --> 00:24:57.020
may have guessed.

00:24:58.180 --> 00:24:59.030
Why check?

00:24:59.060 --> 00:25:01.040
Because the tax

00:25:01.040 --> 00:25:01.730
calculations

00:25:01.730 --> 00:25:03.189
were made, as

00:25:03.199 --> 00:25:04.179
always in sort of

00:25:04.180 --> 00:25:05.389
Germanic systems,

00:25:05.600 --> 00:25:06.840
publicly, visibly,

00:25:06.840 --> 00:25:07.680
transparently

00:25:07.889 --> 00:25:09.210
on a big table.

00:25:09.809 --> 00:25:11.320
And when you have a

00:25:11.809 --> 00:25:13.410
writing system like

00:25:13.410 --> 00:25:15.400
the Roman writing,

00:25:15.400 --> 00:25:16.039
which is like the

00:25:16.049 --> 00:25:17.530
Chinese writing  one

00:25:17.530 --> 00:25:18.619
is one dash, two

00:25:18.619 --> 00:25:19.570
is two, three is

00:25:19.570 --> 00:25:20.950
three, and so on,

00:25:21.840 --> 00:25:23.070
you need an abacus.

00:25:23.919 --> 00:25:25.159
We know it  from

00:25:25.169 --> 00:25:26.119
China, Japan,

00:25:26.119 --> 00:25:27.269
where they, until

00:25:27.279 --> 00:25:28.720
recently, certainly

00:25:28.729 --> 00:25:29.440
in my lifetime, were

00:25:29.440 --> 00:25:30.269
still using them.

00:25:30.270 --> 00:25:31.059
You could see people

00:25:31.069 --> 00:25:33.379
use them, and they're

00:25:33.380 --> 00:25:34.370
still commonly used.

00:25:34.630 --> 00:25:35.529
But the Romans,

00:25:35.720 --> 00:25:36.379
of course, also

00:25:36.380 --> 00:25:37.169
had abacuses.

00:25:37.200 --> 00:25:38.010
It was a European

00:25:38.010 --> 00:25:38.730
thing as well

00:25:39.059 --> 00:25:39.999
because the Roman

00:25:40.219 --> 00:25:41.409
numerals aren't

00:25:41.419 --> 00:25:42.430
really useful for

00:25:42.729 --> 00:25:44.260
doing calculations.

00:25:44.840 --> 00:25:45.970
The Arabic numerals

00:25:45.970 --> 00:25:46.609
were much more

00:25:46.610 --> 00:25:47.319
useful for that.

00:25:47.689 --> 00:25:48.569
So they-- That's

00:25:48.569 --> 00:25:48.930
what it was.

00:25:48.930 --> 00:25:49.770
It was an abacus,

00:25:49.790 --> 00:25:50.150
and you were

00:25:50.150 --> 00:25:51.309
moving tokens.

00:25:52.289 --> 00:25:53.019
You could use any

00:25:53.020 --> 00:25:53.729
table, but they

00:25:53.729 --> 00:25:55.499
put  a, a chess

00:25:55.689 --> 00:25:57.909
board cloth over it

00:25:58.679 --> 00:26:01.240
to mark your  rows

00:26:01.240 --> 00:26:02.499
and columns for the

00:26:02.560 --> 00:26:04.169
abacus calculations.

00:26:05.130 --> 00:26:07.900
That was the  the

00:26:07.909 --> 00:26:08.859
exchequer table.

00:26:10.270 --> 00:26:10.980
And so why is it

00:26:10.980 --> 00:26:12.000
called exchequer?

00:26:12.340 --> 00:26:13.869
From French for

00:26:13.869 --> 00:26:15.889
chess, check,

00:26:17.299 --> 00:26:17.959
checkmate.

00:26:18.240 --> 00:26:20.339
This is  because it's

00:26:20.340 --> 00:26:22.210
a chess board that's

00:26:22.210 --> 00:26:23.259
used as the abacus

00:26:23.259 --> 00:26:24.169
for the calculations.

00:26:26.289 --> 00:26:27.889
And the accused--

00:26:27.899 --> 00:26:28.499
So remember, the

00:26:28.499 --> 00:26:29.699
sheriff was accused

00:26:29.700 --> 00:26:30.549
in this court.

00:26:30.929 --> 00:26:31.699
He was charged.

00:26:31.700 --> 00:26:32.559
He was charged.

00:26:34.399 --> 00:26:34.740
And there was

00:26:34.740 --> 00:26:35.590
this very serious

00:26:35.609 --> 00:26:38.904
calculation So you

00:26:38.904 --> 00:26:40.053
had the calculations

00:26:40.063 --> 00:26:41.154
visible for anyone.

00:26:41.603 --> 00:26:42.754
Then you had the

00:26:43.194 --> 00:26:45.974
oral charge and

00:26:46.033 --> 00:26:48.504
discharge  dispute.

00:26:48.504 --> 00:26:49.283
So the sheriff

00:26:49.283 --> 00:26:50.793
had to discharge

00:26:51.103 --> 00:26:52.873
his liabilities.

00:26:52.933 --> 00:26:53.654
That's also where

00:26:53.654 --> 00:26:54.873
this expression comes

00:26:54.873 --> 00:26:56.103
from  to discharge

00:26:56.103 --> 00:26:56.593
one's liabilities.

00:26:57.014 --> 00:26:57.673
Because it was a

00:26:57.703 --> 00:27:00.053
court of equity

00:27:00.053 --> 00:27:02.153
where the accused

00:27:02.154 --> 00:27:03.443
was the sheriff

00:27:03.633 --> 00:27:04.833
who was charged

00:27:04.843 --> 00:27:05.744
with the taxes and

00:27:05.744 --> 00:27:06.974
had to discharge.

00:27:07.514 --> 00:27:09.123
And for that, the

00:27:09.123 --> 00:27:09.873
sheriff could,

00:27:10.053 --> 00:27:10.704
first of all, bring

00:27:10.704 --> 00:27:11.603
all the receipts,

00:27:11.664 --> 00:27:12.563
because when you

00:27:12.563 --> 00:27:13.333
collect taxes,

00:27:13.333 --> 00:27:14.343
you've got costs

00:27:14.914 --> 00:27:17.154
and  the sheriffs

00:27:17.154 --> 00:27:18.123
were allowed to…

00:27:18.803 --> 00:27:19.973
There was reasonable

00:27:19.984 --> 00:27:21.603
management, any

00:27:21.603 --> 00:27:22.704
costs, any staff

00:27:22.704 --> 00:27:23.393
they had to pay,

00:27:23.403 --> 00:27:24.294
horses they had to

00:27:24.294 --> 00:27:25.383
pay for, whatever.

00:27:25.973 --> 00:27:26.544
But the receipts

00:27:26.544 --> 00:27:27.413
had to be there, so

00:27:27.414 --> 00:27:28.403
that was deducted.

00:27:30.524 --> 00:27:32.823
And  otherwise you

00:27:32.823 --> 00:27:33.783
had to bring the tax

00:27:33.793 --> 00:27:34.463
either in the form

00:27:34.463 --> 00:27:35.573
of silver pennies

00:27:35.614 --> 00:27:39.153
or  other forms of

00:27:39.153 --> 00:27:40.483
pay- of payment.

00:27:40.803 --> 00:27:42.063
Gold was rarer but

00:27:42.083 --> 00:27:43.653
was possible, or

00:27:43.654 --> 00:27:45.954
indeed tax receipts

00:27:46.334 --> 00:27:47.394
from the exchequer.

00:27:48.733 --> 00:27:49.924
And that's where this

00:27:49.953 --> 00:27:51.013
turned into money

00:27:54.745 --> 00:27:55.696
incidentally, if

00:27:55.696 --> 00:27:56.356
you know the Tower

00:27:56.356 --> 00:27:58.896
of London  the

00:27:58.906 --> 00:27:59.686
Tower of London is

00:27:59.716 --> 00:28:00.745
outside the City of

00:28:00.745 --> 00:28:03.375
London looking in.

00:28:03.975 --> 00:28:05.056
It was built by,

00:28:05.156 --> 00:28:05.856
under William the

00:28:05.856 --> 00:28:06.965
Conqueror as a

00:28:06.965 --> 00:28:08.845
statement to the

00:28:08.845 --> 00:28:09.755
City of London.

00:28:10.015 --> 00:28:10.476
Why?

00:28:12.855 --> 00:28:13.626
When you conquer

00:28:13.656 --> 00:28:15.735
England, you have

00:28:15.735 --> 00:28:16.775
a lot of costs.

00:28:17.235 --> 00:28:18.225
It was always strange

00:28:18.225 --> 00:28:19.106
that William the

00:28:19.106 --> 00:28:19.596
Conqueror would

00:28:19.596 --> 00:28:20.605
conquer England and

00:28:20.605 --> 00:28:22.025
then proceed and  was

00:28:22.025 --> 00:28:22.936
looking at Ireland,

00:28:22.945 --> 00:28:23.785
looking north

00:28:26.396 --> 00:28:27.346
but would not

00:28:27.405 --> 00:28:28.376
conquer the City

00:28:28.376 --> 00:28:30.346
of London but

00:28:30.346 --> 00:28:31.426
actually declare it

00:28:32.355 --> 00:28:34.916
a tax-free location

00:28:34.965 --> 00:28:36.525
outside his dominion

00:28:38.574 --> 00:28:39.514
Isn't that strange?

00:28:40.434 --> 00:28:41.344
Not really if you

00:28:41.354 --> 00:28:42.234
think about how to

00:28:42.244 --> 00:28:44.004
fund an invasion

00:28:46.446 --> 00:28:47.076
And it gives you some

00:28:47.076 --> 00:28:47.826
idea who may have

00:28:47.826 --> 00:28:48.936
funded the invasion.

00:28:52.285 --> 00:28:53.136
So the Tower of

00:28:53.136 --> 00:28:54.166
London was built as a

00:28:54.166 --> 00:28:55.745
statement by William

00:28:55.745 --> 00:28:56.706
the Conqueror to

00:28:56.706 --> 00:28:57.406
the City of London,

00:28:57.406 --> 00:28:58.706
"Okay, I've given you

00:28:58.976 --> 00:29:01.666
one square mile of

00:29:01.666 --> 00:29:02.476
sovereign territory

00:29:02.476 --> 00:29:03.076
that's not under

00:29:03.076 --> 00:29:05.035
my reign, but just

00:29:05.045 --> 00:29:06.176
one step out of it,

00:29:06.216 --> 00:29:07.216
this is my reign."

00:29:07.225 --> 00:29:09.086
A lot of people

00:29:09.086 --> 00:29:10.346
think the Tower of

00:29:10.346 --> 00:29:10.925
London is part of

00:29:10.926 --> 00:29:11.466
the City of London.

00:29:11.466 --> 00:29:11.826
That's how it's

00:29:11.826 --> 00:29:12.385
usually sold.

00:29:12.385 --> 00:29:12.755
It's not.

00:29:12.755 --> 00:29:13.945
It's outside, just

00:29:13.975 --> 00:29:14.745
outside the City

00:29:14.745 --> 00:29:15.456
of London square

00:29:15.456 --> 00:29:17.145
mile, looking in

00:29:17.235 --> 00:29:18.335
as the statement

00:29:18.515 --> 00:29:20.576
to the burghers in

00:29:20.576 --> 00:29:21.616
the City of London

00:29:23.790 --> 00:29:25.620
that while he's given

00:29:25.620 --> 00:29:27.070
that sovereignty,

00:29:27.080 --> 00:29:28.530
he was  the

00:29:28.530 --> 00:29:30.040
sovereign outside

00:29:30.050 --> 00:29:30.990
the Square Mile

00:29:34.728 --> 00:29:35.428
so this is the

00:29:35.428 --> 00:29:38.258
Norman system and

00:29:40.590 --> 00:29:41.300
So you had these

00:29:41.300 --> 00:29:42.350
gatherings twice a

00:29:42.350 --> 00:29:44.689
year, and of course,

00:29:46.330 --> 00:29:47.070
the accounting

00:29:47.070 --> 00:29:47.620
was written.

00:29:47.629 --> 00:29:48.030
Yes, and we're

00:29:48.030 --> 00:29:48.520
talking about these

00:29:48.520 --> 00:29:49.540
accounting words,

00:29:49.939 --> 00:29:50.780
so the word for

00:29:50.790 --> 00:29:51.820
audit, audire,

00:29:51.879 --> 00:29:52.620
comes from there.

00:29:53.519 --> 00:29:54.489
The word for control

00:29:54.490 --> 00:29:55.320
comes from there.

00:29:56.149 --> 00:29:56.469
Why?

00:29:56.470 --> 00:29:57.129
Because they would

00:29:57.129 --> 00:29:58.360
also then create

00:29:58.360 --> 00:29:59.549
a record on vellum

00:29:59.580 --> 00:30:01.829
cow skin of the

00:30:02.159 --> 00:30:03.589
taxes charged,

00:30:03.600 --> 00:30:06.089
taxes  discharged,

00:30:06.139 --> 00:30:07.409
and  the bottom

00:30:07.409 --> 00:30:09.639
line, and this was

00:30:09.639 --> 00:30:11.199
the contre-rouleau.

00:30:11.199 --> 00:30:12.179
It was rolled up

00:30:12.189 --> 00:30:12.849
because vellum

00:30:12.860 --> 00:30:13.559
is quite thick.

00:30:13.559 --> 00:30:13.999
You had to--

00:30:14.270 --> 00:30:15.220
couldn't fold it.

00:30:15.889 --> 00:30:17.169
You rolled it, so it

00:30:17.169 --> 00:30:18.769
was the counter roll.

00:30:19.700 --> 00:30:20.440
In French,

00:30:20.489 --> 00:30:21.860
contre-rouleau

00:30:21.860 --> 00:30:22.649
is control.

00:30:23.009 --> 00:30:23.729
That's where the word

00:30:23.729 --> 00:30:24.830
control comes from,

00:30:25.309 --> 00:30:26.359
the contre-rouleau

00:30:30.735 --> 00:30:31.735
and the accounting

00:30:31.755 --> 00:30:33.326
was the honest type

00:30:33.326 --> 00:30:34.196
of accounting, which

00:30:34.196 --> 00:30:34.956
is single entry

00:30:34.956 --> 00:30:35.765
accounting, also

00:30:35.765 --> 00:30:36.716
known therefore as

00:30:36.745 --> 00:30:37.706
charge discharge

00:30:37.706 --> 00:30:38.386
accounting.

00:30:38.896 --> 00:30:40.025
And you can't fool

00:30:40.066 --> 00:30:41.035
people with that.

00:30:42.325 --> 00:30:43.226
And we'll see that

00:30:43.265 --> 00:30:45.065
this is why double

00:30:45.065 --> 00:30:45.926
entry accounting

00:30:45.926 --> 00:30:46.805
was developed.

00:30:48.116 --> 00:30:48.745
And people have

00:30:48.745 --> 00:30:49.396
been fooled for

00:30:49.396 --> 00:30:50.425
centuries by double

00:30:50.426 --> 00:30:51.055
entry accounting.

00:30:51.305 --> 00:30:52.126
But the original

00:30:52.145 --> 00:30:53.505
honest accounting is

00:30:53.505 --> 00:30:54.525
just, is essentially

00:30:54.525 --> 00:30:55.495
cash flow accounting,

00:30:55.495 --> 00:30:56.655
money in, money out.

00:30:57.625 --> 00:30:58.365
And  there's no

00:30:58.375 --> 00:30:58.965
messing with it

00:31:03.914 --> 00:31:04.614
So this is the

00:31:04.614 --> 00:31:05.594
system, and this

00:31:05.594 --> 00:31:06.834
is how they paid

00:31:06.834 --> 00:31:09.914
for the building

00:31:10.154 --> 00:31:11.834
of cathedrals,

00:31:12.564 --> 00:31:13.114
the building

00:31:13.114 --> 00:31:14.244
of a thousand

00:31:14.254 --> 00:31:15.644
fortifications

00:31:15.904 --> 00:31:16.684
in just a few

00:31:16.694 --> 00:31:18.024
decades, in a very

00:31:18.024 --> 00:31:19.433
short time period.

00:31:20.684 --> 00:31:21.463
And later, this

00:31:21.493 --> 00:31:23.963
also came to be  the

00:31:23.963 --> 00:31:25.573
core of the, this

00:31:25.614 --> 00:31:27.163
era in Sicily under

00:31:27.163 --> 00:31:29.064
the Normans of

00:31:29.064 --> 00:31:30.373
great prosperity.

00:31:32.213 --> 00:31:32.793
And by the way,

00:31:32.823 --> 00:31:33.473
this- they've been

00:31:33.483 --> 00:31:34.503
around for centuries.

00:31:34.504 --> 00:31:35.434
The Bank of England

00:31:35.514 --> 00:31:37.893
was partly  paid

00:31:38.014 --> 00:31:40.284
when it  invited

00:31:40.284 --> 00:31:42.103
subscribers to its

00:31:42.113 --> 00:31:42.853
stock when it was

00:31:42.854 --> 00:31:43.503
created in s- in

00:31:43.503 --> 00:31:46.243
1694 in tally sticks.

00:31:47.663 --> 00:31:48.803
They were only

00:31:49.323 --> 00:31:50.053
abolished in

00:31:50.054 --> 00:31:53.263
1826 by law

00:31:55.304 --> 00:31:56.123
it's  800

00:31:56.133 --> 00:31:56.913
years later.

00:31:58.093 --> 00:31:59.273
And then they decided

00:31:59.284 --> 00:32:00.083
in the Office of

00:32:00.084 --> 00:32:00.523
the Exchequer,

00:32:00.844 --> 00:32:01.464
"  we don't need

00:32:01.464 --> 00:32:02.154
these anymore.

00:32:02.154 --> 00:32:03.134
Let's burn them."

00:32:03.683 --> 00:32:04.473
But  you've got

00:32:04.493 --> 00:32:05.763
800-year-old, very

00:32:05.784 --> 00:32:07.443
dry wooden sticks.

00:32:07.444 --> 00:32:08.313
They were kept

00:32:09.203 --> 00:32:09.913
in that office

00:32:09.934 --> 00:32:10.454
underneath the

00:32:10.454 --> 00:32:11.603
Parliament building,

00:32:12.604 --> 00:32:13.594
and as they burnt

00:32:13.594 --> 00:32:14.904
them, quickly this

00:32:14.913 --> 00:32:16.263
fire got out of hand,

00:32:16.273 --> 00:32:17.624
and the Parliament

00:32:17.624 --> 00:32:18.253
building was

00:32:18.254 --> 00:32:19.464
destroyed, and that's

00:32:19.473 --> 00:32:20.563
why we have this new

00:32:20.973 --> 00:32:22.003
Houses of Parliament

00:32:22.023 --> 00:32:23.104
we currently see

00:32:25.262 --> 00:32:25.722
So with

00:32:25.752 --> 00:32:26.472
charge-discharge

00:32:26.472 --> 00:32:27.131
accounting on the

00:32:27.142 --> 00:32:27.972
charge side, you've

00:32:28.012 --> 00:32:29.111
got the money that's

00:32:29.111 --> 00:32:30.252
expected to be

00:32:30.752 --> 00:32:31.631
received, and the

00:32:31.631 --> 00:32:34.402
discharge side is  as

00:32:34.402 --> 00:32:35.681
we said, the costs

00:32:35.691 --> 00:32:36.881
that the sheriffs

00:32:36.881 --> 00:32:38.172
were allowed to hold

00:32:38.172 --> 00:32:40.631
against this  and

00:32:40.651 --> 00:32:42.162
any actual taxes

00:32:42.192 --> 00:32:44.071
collected  therefore

00:32:44.071 --> 00:32:44.121
discharging that

00:32:45.172 --> 00:32:46.472
tax obligations

00:32:49.262 --> 00:32:50.631
So as you know from

00:32:50.631 --> 00:32:51.532
Robin Hood, Sheriff

00:32:51.532 --> 00:32:52.162
of Nottingham, these

00:32:52.162 --> 00:32:53.042
sheriffs were the

00:32:53.042 --> 00:32:54.012
tax collectors.

00:32:54.022 --> 00:32:55.222
That was the system.

00:32:56.942 --> 00:32:59.732
And the Normans made

00:32:59.782 --> 00:33:00.841
good use of this

00:33:03.086 --> 00:33:03.496
And of course,

00:33:03.496 --> 00:33:04.176
the government

00:33:04.186 --> 00:33:05.136
could therefore

00:33:05.776 --> 00:33:08.226
also essentially

00:33:08.226 --> 00:33:08.846
print money.

00:33:08.856 --> 00:33:09.536
How did it, how

00:33:09.536 --> 00:33:10.336
do you do that?

00:33:11.236 --> 00:33:11.835
The government could

00:33:11.836 --> 00:33:13.456
spend more than any

00:33:13.456 --> 00:33:16.566
given pre-scheduled

00:33:16.576 --> 00:33:19.515
budget because when

00:33:19.516 --> 00:33:20.716
you then procure

00:33:20.725 --> 00:33:22.126
resources from

00:33:22.126 --> 00:33:23.195
the economy, from

00:33:23.195 --> 00:33:23.825
farmers, you're

00:33:23.856 --> 00:33:24.746
getting cows for

00:33:24.746 --> 00:33:25.505
the household of the

00:33:25.506 --> 00:33:26.946
king or whatever it

00:33:26.986 --> 00:33:29.616
may be, weapons from

00:33:29.616 --> 00:33:30.476
the blacksmiths,

00:33:30.795 --> 00:33:31.605
you could pay

00:33:31.625 --> 00:33:34.216
with tally sticks.

00:33:34.465 --> 00:33:34.895
Why?

00:33:35.626 --> 00:33:36.755
If somebody sells

00:33:36.786 --> 00:33:38.345
to the government,

00:33:39.145 --> 00:33:40.465
then it's the same

00:33:40.466 --> 00:33:41.625
as having paid

00:33:41.665 --> 00:33:43.586
taxes in advance,

00:33:44.016 --> 00:33:44.676
so you deserve

00:33:44.676 --> 00:33:46.185
a tax receipt.

00:33:47.205 --> 00:33:47.885
And these were

00:33:47.895 --> 00:33:48.575
valuable because

00:33:48.615 --> 00:33:49.735
twice a year at the

00:33:49.735 --> 00:33:52.026
High Court of Equity

00:33:52.095 --> 00:33:53.205
of the Exchequer,

00:33:53.805 --> 00:33:55.285
they were accepted as

00:33:55.316 --> 00:33:56.605
if they're pure cash,

00:33:56.606 --> 00:33:57.866
pure gold, silver.

00:33:59.865 --> 00:34:00.585
And that's how

00:34:00.586 --> 00:34:01.506
you could marshal

00:34:01.506 --> 00:34:03.216
resources at ease

00:34:05.772 --> 00:34:07.262
And fool centuries

00:34:07.272 --> 00:34:08.192
of historians who

00:34:08.192 --> 00:34:09.911
didn't see this, that

00:34:09.911 --> 00:34:11.181
this is how it works.

00:34:11.572 --> 00:34:12.581
So that's the first

00:34:12.581 --> 00:34:13.701
form of quantitative

00:34:13.701 --> 00:34:14.601
easing was actually

00:34:14.631 --> 00:34:15.462
tally stick

00:34:16.101 --> 00:34:17.192
credit creation.

00:34:17.362 --> 00:34:17.842
Yes.

00:34:18.701 --> 00:34:19.371
It's a concept

00:34:19.391 --> 00:34:21.811
I  proposed first

00:34:21.812 --> 00:34:23.882
in 1995 in Japan.

00:34:25.551 --> 00:34:27.672
But it's about    a

00:34:27.681 --> 00:34:28.331
clever type of

00:34:28.342 --> 00:34:29.141
money creation, so

00:34:29.152 --> 00:34:29.761
in that sense would

00:34:29.771 --> 00:34:30.672
be quite suitable.

00:34:31.152 --> 00:34:32.001
What do the textbooks

00:34:32.002 --> 00:34:32.951
tell us about money?

00:34:34.941 --> 00:34:35.951
The textbook story

00:34:35.951 --> 00:34:38.912
is Well, first there

00:34:38.912 --> 00:34:40.142
was no money, and

00:34:40.142 --> 00:34:41.032
when there's no money

00:34:41.072 --> 00:34:42.022
but people want to

00:34:42.022 --> 00:34:43.092
trade, you've got

00:34:43.102 --> 00:34:44.402
barter, which is

00:34:44.682 --> 00:34:46.192
non-monetary trade,

00:34:47.012 --> 00:34:48.601
but it's  cumbersome.

00:34:48.812 --> 00:34:50.592
You need the  double

00:34:50.622 --> 00:34:51.662
coincidence of,

00:34:51.672 --> 00:34:52.462
once you have a

00:34:52.462 --> 00:34:53.581
carpenter who's got

00:34:53.582 --> 00:34:55.652
beautiful wardrobes

00:34:55.652 --> 00:34:56.592
and bookshelves,

00:34:56.931 --> 00:34:57.752
but wants to buy

00:34:57.752 --> 00:34:59.621
some sheep's milk

00:35:00.042 --> 00:35:02.211
from the f-  from

00:35:02.212 --> 00:35:02.971
the shepherd, from

00:35:02.972 --> 00:35:04.051
the sheep farmer,

00:35:05.111 --> 00:35:05.991
and has to hope that

00:35:05.991 --> 00:35:06.801
the sheep farmer

00:35:06.821 --> 00:35:07.651
would like some

00:35:08.081 --> 00:35:09.742
wardrobe or similar

00:35:10.111 --> 00:35:11.151
whatever bookshelves.

00:35:11.542 --> 00:35:13.652
So you see  it's

00:35:13.652 --> 00:35:14.441
not ideal.

00:35:16.792 --> 00:35:18.291
That's why we're

00:35:18.301 --> 00:35:19.412
told in the textbook

00:35:19.412 --> 00:35:21.211
story people realized

00:35:21.231 --> 00:35:21.871
it's better to

00:35:21.882 --> 00:35:22.832
have some kind of

00:35:22.902 --> 00:35:24.941
third thing as the

00:35:24.941 --> 00:35:26.092
unit of account.

00:35:28.461 --> 00:35:29.512
Commodity money,

00:35:29.871 --> 00:35:30.611
commodities that

00:35:30.611 --> 00:35:31.402
maybe everyone

00:35:31.472 --> 00:35:32.512
wants to have.

00:35:32.562 --> 00:35:34.521
In Asia, rice, or

00:35:34.542 --> 00:35:35.622
in ancient times,

00:35:35.622 --> 00:35:37.911
grain  or it could

00:35:37.921 --> 00:35:39.161
be any commodity.

00:35:40.031 --> 00:35:41.471
Pecus, pecuniary

00:35:42.552 --> 00:35:44.262
concepts  the

00:35:44.262 --> 00:35:45.041
origin of the word

00:35:45.042 --> 00:35:45.602
is actually the

00:35:45.602 --> 00:35:47.232
cow because in

00:35:47.232 --> 00:35:48.991
the Roman era the

00:35:48.991 --> 00:35:50.131
cow was considered

00:35:50.201 --> 00:35:51.812
a monetary unit.

00:35:52.881 --> 00:35:54.021
So anything could be

00:35:54.341 --> 00:35:55.652
that commodity money.

00:35:56.292 --> 00:35:57.042
But of course, some

00:35:57.042 --> 00:35:58.351
commodities perish,

00:35:59.271 --> 00:36:00.271
and therefore

00:36:01.171 --> 00:36:02.272
that's not ideal.

00:36:02.902 --> 00:36:03.162
So you want

00:36:03.162 --> 00:36:04.361
something that lasts.

00:36:04.722 --> 00:36:05.721
So why not gold

00:36:05.722 --> 00:36:06.331
and silver?

00:36:06.381 --> 00:36:07.962
That seems to last.

00:36:09.321 --> 00:36:10.241
So then you've

00:36:10.271 --> 00:36:11.391
got precious metal

00:36:11.391 --> 00:36:12.441
money, but there

00:36:12.442 --> 00:36:13.251
the trouble is you

00:36:13.251 --> 00:36:14.311
have to constantly

00:36:14.811 --> 00:36:16.831
ascertain  the value,

00:36:16.832 --> 00:36:17.601
the weight, the

00:36:17.611 --> 00:36:19.441
purity, assaying.

00:36:20.402 --> 00:36:21.491
So that's cumbersome.

00:36:21.561 --> 00:36:21.961
Why not

00:36:21.972 --> 00:36:22.792
standardize it?

00:36:22.792 --> 00:36:23.361
And that's where you

00:36:23.361 --> 00:36:24.601
get the coin precious

00:36:24.621 --> 00:36:26.451
metals, standardized

00:36:26.501 --> 00:36:28.281
units people don't

00:36:28.281 --> 00:36:29.151
have to weigh.

00:36:31.031 --> 00:36:33.341
Trouble is soon

00:36:33.351 --> 00:36:34.172
they lose their

00:36:34.172 --> 00:36:36.011
value by people

00:36:36.012 --> 00:36:37.192
extracting the gold.

00:36:37.211 --> 00:36:37.961
It's either people

00:36:37.981 --> 00:36:39.041
clipping the gold.

00:36:40.251 --> 00:36:41.241
The Norman kings

00:36:41.241 --> 00:36:42.261
were pretty severe

00:36:42.262 --> 00:36:42.892
on that one.

00:36:42.951 --> 00:36:44.051
So in Winchester,

00:36:44.681 --> 00:36:47.481
Henry I  son

00:36:47.601 --> 00:36:48.031
of William the

00:36:48.041 --> 00:36:48.901
Conqueror, he was the

00:36:48.901 --> 00:36:50.112
second, was actually

00:36:50.112 --> 00:36:51.012
the youngest son.

00:36:51.371 --> 00:36:52.402
When he became king,

00:36:53.561 --> 00:36:54.481
he introduced this

00:36:55.501 --> 00:36:56.871
law that  if you

00:36:56.871 --> 00:36:57.971
did this clipping,

00:36:58.772 --> 00:36:59.282
then something

00:36:59.282 --> 00:36:59.901
would be clipped

00:36:59.931 --> 00:37:01.761
off your body, and

00:37:01.761 --> 00:37:02.581
it wasn't pleasant.

00:37:04.061 --> 00:37:05.401
It was essentially

00:37:05.871 --> 00:37:06.891
almost a--  it was

00:37:06.891 --> 00:37:08.582
a capital crime to

00:37:08.582 --> 00:37:09.241
do this clipping.

00:37:09.391 --> 00:37:10.731
But likewise  the

00:37:10.731 --> 00:37:12.132
monarchs in charge

00:37:12.132 --> 00:37:14.552
of the  the coinage

00:37:14.561 --> 00:37:16.461
in the royal mints

00:37:17.101 --> 00:37:18.281
would also reduce the

00:37:18.281 --> 00:37:20.551
gold content through

00:37:22.071 --> 00:37:24.121
just  dilution.

00:37:24.974 --> 00:37:25.434
Because of course

00:37:25.454 --> 00:37:26.114
you could expand

00:37:26.274 --> 00:37:27.294
the money supply if

00:37:27.294 --> 00:37:29.564
you have a  smaller

00:37:29.564 --> 00:37:30.634
percentage of gold

00:37:30.644 --> 00:37:31.664
in your coins.

00:37:32.214 --> 00:37:32.954
That's something

00:37:32.994 --> 00:37:34.154
already known in

00:37:34.164 --> 00:37:35.464
ancient times, Roman

00:37:35.474 --> 00:37:36.904
times, expansion of

00:37:36.904 --> 00:37:37.763
the money supply by

00:37:37.764 --> 00:37:38.974
reducing the gold or

00:37:38.983 --> 00:37:40.614
silver value content.

00:37:41.943 --> 00:37:42.664
So then you get these

00:37:42.664 --> 00:37:43.363
debased coins, but

00:37:43.363 --> 00:37:44.103
if you keep doing

00:37:44.103 --> 00:37:45.174
that, ultimately you

00:37:45.174 --> 00:37:45.944
end up with something

00:37:45.984 --> 00:37:47.054
totally debased,

00:37:47.773 --> 00:37:49.954
just tokens like

00:37:49.954 --> 00:37:50.903
we have nowadays,

00:37:50.904 --> 00:37:51.654
these coins.

00:37:51.853 --> 00:37:52.564
The value is

00:37:52.593 --> 00:37:53.313
pretty much

00:37:55.403 --> 00:37:56.463
very little, close

00:37:56.464 --> 00:37:58.304
to nothing, 'cause

00:37:58.514 --> 00:38:00.643
there's no  precious

00:38:00.643 --> 00:38:01.163
metals in there,

00:38:01.163 --> 00:38:02.294
not even copper,

00:38:02.764 --> 00:38:03.904
which nowadays  is

00:38:03.913 --> 00:38:04.703
not that cheap.

00:38:05.334 --> 00:38:05.984
It's just all

00:38:06.014 --> 00:38:07.483
cheap  stuff.

00:38:07.954 --> 00:38:08.863
Why not paper?

00:38:08.884 --> 00:38:10.673
So you end up in this

00:38:11.713 --> 00:38:13.293
logical series here

00:38:13.603 --> 00:38:17.593
with  with  tokens

00:38:17.593 --> 00:38:18.573
that substitute

00:38:18.573 --> 00:38:20.783
for  for money but

00:38:20.794 --> 00:38:22.344
act as money, paper

00:38:22.344 --> 00:38:23.523
money, fiat money.

00:38:24.373 --> 00:38:25.014
And then it's

00:38:25.014 --> 00:38:26.384
argued  we can also

00:38:26.384 --> 00:38:27.853
substitute for any

00:38:28.073 --> 00:38:29.023
government-issued

00:38:29.073 --> 00:38:30.513
paper money or

00:38:30.514 --> 00:38:31.814
fiat money through

00:38:31.913 --> 00:38:33.074
a credit system,

00:38:34.563 --> 00:38:35.123
and that's the

00:38:35.124 --> 00:38:36.483
sequence we're told.

00:38:36.834 --> 00:38:38.703
Now, this is quite

00:38:38.703 --> 00:38:40.504
logical, and there's

00:38:40.504 --> 00:38:41.753
always each step,

00:38:41.753 --> 00:38:42.503
there's a logical

00:38:42.503 --> 00:38:43.484
reason why it makes

00:38:43.484 --> 00:38:44.123
sense to move to

00:38:44.124 --> 00:38:44.864
the next step.

00:38:46.493 --> 00:38:47.764
And  we'll talk

00:38:47.764 --> 00:38:48.763
a bit more about

00:38:48.764 --> 00:38:49.473
that tomorrow

00:38:53.593 --> 00:38:54.213
when the topic

00:38:54.213 --> 00:38:55.193
is deception

00:38:56.093 --> 00:38:57.164
and economics.

00:39:00.743 --> 00:39:01.243
Fundamental

00:39:01.253 --> 00:39:04.123
principle is logic

00:39:04.323 --> 00:39:05.113
is convincing.

00:39:05.203 --> 00:39:06.263
We like logic.

00:39:06.334 --> 00:39:07.123
Men like logic

00:39:07.133 --> 00:39:07.783
in particular.

00:39:08.623 --> 00:39:09.083
But there's a

00:39:09.084 --> 00:39:09.893
problem with this.

00:39:10.373 --> 00:39:11.923
Logic is not truth.

00:39:13.123 --> 00:39:13.663
Just because

00:39:13.663 --> 00:39:14.194
something is

00:39:14.194 --> 00:39:15.753
logical does not

00:39:15.813 --> 00:39:16.973
mean it's true

00:39:19.790 --> 00:39:20.390
It's very important

00:39:20.420 --> 00:39:21.490
to keep that in mind.

00:39:21.779 --> 00:39:22.440
We're never made

00:39:22.440 --> 00:39:23.540
aware of that because

00:39:23.730 --> 00:39:24.820
logic is used a

00:39:24.820 --> 00:39:25.779
lot to convince

00:39:25.779 --> 00:39:26.620
us of something

00:39:29.130 --> 00:39:31.030
Logic is not truth.

00:39:31.300 --> 00:39:31.860
That's a totally

00:39:31.860 --> 00:39:32.890
different dimension.

00:39:33.230 --> 00:39:35.510
Logic tells you about

00:39:35.730 --> 00:39:37.410
possible worlds,

00:39:37.520 --> 00:39:39.020
about possibilities,

00:39:39.560 --> 00:39:39.970
essentially

00:39:39.980 --> 00:39:40.690
theoretical

00:39:40.709 --> 00:39:41.709
possibilities,

00:39:41.789 --> 00:39:42.829
simulations.

00:39:44.760 --> 00:39:45.479
The truth is

00:39:45.480 --> 00:39:46.260
a very simple

00:39:46.289 --> 00:39:48.099
empirical concept,

00:39:48.359 --> 00:39:48.760
and you gotta

00:39:48.769 --> 00:39:49.859
check the facts.

00:39:50.129 --> 00:39:51.010
What is actually

00:39:51.010 --> 00:39:51.339
happening?

00:39:51.339 --> 00:39:52.320
What has actually

00:39:52.320 --> 00:39:52.740
happened?

00:39:55.288 --> 00:39:55.988
And the truth will

00:39:56.127 --> 00:39:56.718
have, have its

00:39:56.718 --> 00:39:58.408
own logic, but the

00:39:58.408 --> 00:39:59.087
logic that's being

00:39:59.087 --> 00:40:00.288
presented may be

00:40:00.288 --> 00:40:01.118
very different.

00:40:02.368 --> 00:40:03.218
And with the truth,

00:40:03.218 --> 00:40:04.017
you only find out

00:40:04.048 --> 00:40:05.158
ex post what was

00:40:05.167 --> 00:40:06.027
really the logic

00:40:06.038 --> 00:40:06.837
of what happened.

00:40:08.298 --> 00:40:09.147
So keep that in mind.

00:40:09.517 --> 00:40:10.218
So just because

00:40:10.227 --> 00:40:10.977
the textbook tell

00:40:10.977 --> 00:40:11.957
us this is what

00:40:11.968 --> 00:40:12.787
happened doesn't

00:40:12.788 --> 00:40:13.558
mean it's true.

00:40:14.348 --> 00:40:14.937
And when you look

00:40:14.937 --> 00:40:15.747
at the history of

00:40:15.747 --> 00:40:16.707
money, you realize

00:40:16.707 --> 00:40:18.457
that there's a

00:40:18.457 --> 00:40:19.347
problem with this

00:40:20.147 --> 00:40:20.987
very logical,

00:40:20.997 --> 00:40:22.167
convincing story

00:40:24.502 --> 00:40:25.422
Let's look at the

00:40:25.632 --> 00:40:27.092
stone money of the

00:40:27.152 --> 00:40:29.942
island of Yap in

00:40:29.942 --> 00:40:32.032
the  South Pacific

00:40:32.192 --> 00:40:35.290
Ocean There's a nice

00:40:35.290 --> 00:40:36.260
description of this

00:40:36.260 --> 00:40:37.780
by an anthropologist

00:40:38.460 --> 00:40:41.070
and also  then later

00:40:41.080 --> 00:40:42.060
Milton Friedman

00:40:42.060 --> 00:40:42.990
wrote about it.

00:40:44.270 --> 00:40:44.689
So there's this

00:40:44.939 --> 00:40:46.220
island where they

00:40:46.220 --> 00:40:48.419
used huge stone

00:40:48.430 --> 00:40:49.619
slabs as money.

00:40:51.400 --> 00:40:52.170
They were carved

00:40:52.180 --> 00:40:53.309
in these circular

00:40:55.270 --> 00:40:56.929
styles with a hole

00:40:57.000 --> 00:40:58.049
in the middle so you

00:40:58.049 --> 00:41:00.270
could get a  a tree

00:41:00.270 --> 00:41:00.990
trunk through in the

00:41:00.990 --> 00:41:01.809
middle, and you need

00:41:01.809 --> 00:41:02.749
a lot of people to

00:41:02.750 --> 00:41:03.809
carry these things.

00:41:04.609 --> 00:41:05.099
So the good

00:41:05.100 --> 00:41:06.039
thing was, this

00:41:06.039 --> 00:41:07.060
is seen  as an

00:41:07.060 --> 00:41:08.220
advantage, you can't

00:41:08.220 --> 00:41:09.059
really move them.

00:41:10.319 --> 00:41:10.950
So the money was

00:41:10.950 --> 00:41:12.839
safe because it

00:41:12.839 --> 00:41:13.699
would never move.

00:41:14.659 --> 00:41:15.229
Nobody would

00:41:15.229 --> 00:41:16.059
steal your money.

00:41:17.359 --> 00:41:18.210
It's too heavy.

00:41:22.179 --> 00:41:23.019
Also you couldn't

00:41:23.049 --> 00:41:23.859
carve them on

00:41:23.859 --> 00:41:24.720
the island of Yap

00:41:24.720 --> 00:41:25.229
because there was

00:41:25.229 --> 00:41:26.780
no quarry on Yap.

00:41:27.100 --> 00:41:27.769
They were actually

00:41:27.769 --> 00:41:29.849
from a remote island

00:41:29.850 --> 00:41:31.059
more than 1,000

00:41:31.059 --> 00:41:33.949
miles away across the

00:41:33.949 --> 00:41:35.230
Pacific Ocean, and

00:41:35.230 --> 00:41:36.179
they were not great

00:41:36.190 --> 00:41:37.749
seafarers apparently,

00:41:38.109 --> 00:41:39.010
so they had very

00:41:39.020 --> 00:41:40.549
simple rafts.

00:41:40.929 --> 00:41:42.070
And carving those

00:41:42.070 --> 00:41:42.989
stones and then

00:41:42.999 --> 00:41:43.979
getting them to Yap

00:41:44.029 --> 00:41:45.569
was quite a risky

00:41:45.569 --> 00:41:47.049
undertaking, so  they

00:41:47.059 --> 00:41:48.109
were very limited.

00:41:48.800 --> 00:41:49.949
One of the wealthiest

00:41:49.949 --> 00:41:50.699
Yap families

00:41:50.730 --> 00:41:51.790
owned a-- the,

00:41:51.800 --> 00:41:53.290
the-- called Fei.

00:41:54.319 --> 00:41:55.139
Owned a Fei that

00:41:55.139 --> 00:41:55.949
no one had seen

00:41:55.949 --> 00:41:56.799
in generations.

00:41:57.050 --> 00:41:58.509
It sank with a raft

00:41:58.519 --> 00:41:59.560
it was being towed

00:41:59.560 --> 00:42:01.029
on when a storm came

00:42:01.029 --> 00:42:02.009
up during moving to

00:42:02.010 --> 00:42:03.199
Yap from its source.

00:42:03.800 --> 00:42:04.849
No one ever doubted

00:42:04.849 --> 00:42:05.879
the truth of the man

00:42:05.879 --> 00:42:06.929
who said he'd cut

00:42:06.929 --> 00:42:08.139
such a huge stone,

00:42:08.639 --> 00:42:09.360
and its purchasing

00:42:09.360 --> 00:42:10.119
power at the bottom

00:42:10.120 --> 00:42:11.139
of the ocean remained

00:42:11.149 --> 00:42:12.289
as valid as that of

00:42:12.289 --> 00:42:13.379
a checking account.

00:42:15.569 --> 00:42:16.259
'Cause what happened

00:42:16.260 --> 00:42:17.899
is that when you have

00:42:17.899 --> 00:42:19.029
these, these stones,

00:42:19.029 --> 00:42:19.679
they usually--

00:42:19.709 --> 00:42:20.829
and  they could be

00:42:20.839 --> 00:42:22.099
anywhere, but often

00:42:22.099 --> 00:42:22.660
they were-- there

00:42:23.010 --> 00:42:23.800
were some places

00:42:23.909 --> 00:42:25.100
they were, or at

00:42:25.100 --> 00:42:26.189
people's houses, but

00:42:26.349 --> 00:42:26.970
doesn't necessarily

00:42:26.970 --> 00:42:27.379
mean that they're

00:42:27.399 --> 00:42:27.910
owned by them.

00:42:27.910 --> 00:42:28.479
So what happened

00:42:28.480 --> 00:42:31.149
is if they change

00:42:31.169 --> 00:42:32.699
ownership, you'd

00:42:32.709 --> 00:42:34.289
gather the village,

00:42:34.979 --> 00:42:35.629
the locals,

00:42:35.629 --> 00:42:36.399
the neighbors

00:42:36.749 --> 00:42:37.759
as witnesses.

00:42:38.330 --> 00:42:38.909
"Okay, we've

00:42:38.919 --> 00:42:40.019
agreed I'm buying

00:42:40.050 --> 00:42:40.880
the plot of land

00:42:40.880 --> 00:42:42.219
from him, and I'm

00:42:42.229 --> 00:42:44.130
paying with my Fei.

00:42:44.399 --> 00:42:45.939
So the Fei here is

00:42:45.980 --> 00:42:46.889
now gonna be his,

00:42:46.909 --> 00:42:47.929
not mine anymore."

00:42:48.840 --> 00:42:50.900
And everyone says,

00:42:50.900 --> 00:42:52.169
"Okay, we  we heard

00:42:52.170 --> 00:42:53.129
it, we'll remember."

00:42:55.379 --> 00:42:56.659
So the question is,

00:42:56.819 --> 00:42:57.969
in this sequence

00:42:58.109 --> 00:42:58.909
of… Oh, and

00:42:58.909 --> 00:42:59.540
perhaps actually

00:42:59.540 --> 00:43:00.500
before we ask this

00:43:00.500 --> 00:43:01.599
question, just one

00:43:01.599 --> 00:43:02.240
more illustration

00:43:02.249 --> 00:43:03.400
how, how-- this

00:43:03.400 --> 00:43:04.029
is on this page.

00:43:04.030 --> 00:43:05.829
How  how well

00:43:05.829 --> 00:43:06.570
this functioned.

00:43:07.329 --> 00:43:09.159
The Germans decided

00:43:10.249 --> 00:43:11.079
just before the First

00:43:11.079 --> 00:43:11.939
World War, we need--

00:43:11.959 --> 00:43:13.199
in fact, Britain told

00:43:13.200 --> 00:43:13.949
them, " you don't

00:43:13.950 --> 00:43:14.850
have any colonies.

00:43:14.870 --> 00:43:15.469
We're not gonna

00:43:15.609 --> 00:43:16.399
take you seriously

00:43:16.399 --> 00:43:17.080
in international

00:43:17.080 --> 00:43:17.999
negotiations.

00:43:18.329 --> 00:43:19.089
You're not a proper

00:43:19.090 --> 00:43:20.079
colonial power."

00:43:20.730 --> 00:43:21.309
So they scrambled,

00:43:21.310 --> 00:43:22.079
"Okay, quickly, we

00:43:22.079 --> 00:43:23.079
need some colonies,"

00:43:27.200 --> 00:43:28.280
and they bought most

00:43:28.280 --> 00:43:29.780
of them from Spain,

00:43:29.780 --> 00:43:30.730
which was in the

00:43:30.730 --> 00:43:32.100
market for-- in the

00:43:32.110 --> 00:43:32.840
real estate market

00:43:32.870 --> 00:43:34.120
for selling colonies.

00:43:35.420 --> 00:43:36.359
Not understanding

00:43:36.360 --> 00:43:36.700
the monetary

00:43:36.700 --> 00:43:37.599
system, obviously,

00:43:37.619 --> 00:43:38.200
thinking that

00:43:38.200 --> 00:43:39.220
they needed money.

00:43:40.810 --> 00:43:41.370
They sold their

00:43:41.370 --> 00:43:43.010
colonies, and Germany

00:43:43.010 --> 00:43:43.850
bought quite a few

00:43:44.099 --> 00:43:45.080
across the globe,

00:43:45.109 --> 00:43:46.659
including these South

00:43:46.689 --> 00:43:48.289
Caroline Islands,

00:43:48.820 --> 00:43:49.459
where the island

00:43:49.470 --> 00:43:51.140
of Yap was also.

00:43:52.640 --> 00:43:54.479
And essentially

00:43:54.709 --> 00:43:55.279
you can imagine

00:43:55.279 --> 00:43:55.759
the story.

00:43:55.759 --> 00:43:56.579
So they sent some

00:43:56.619 --> 00:43:57.529
German colonial

00:43:57.529 --> 00:43:58.059
administrators.

00:43:58.060 --> 00:43:58.659
They created a new

00:43:58.660 --> 00:43:59.739
Ministry of Colonial

00:43:59.740 --> 00:44:00.550
Administration.

00:44:00.760 --> 00:44:01.049
Of course, they

00:44:01.049 --> 00:44:01.329
didn't have

00:44:01.330 --> 00:44:02.039
many people.

00:44:02.229 --> 00:44:03.000
They probably sent

00:44:03.119 --> 00:44:05.489
one or two staff to

00:44:05.490 --> 00:44:07.969
Yap  to take charge

00:44:07.990 --> 00:44:08.669
of the island.

00:44:09.560 --> 00:44:10.090
And

00:44:12.209 --> 00:44:12.869
the first thing they

00:44:12.869 --> 00:44:13.959
did was  we need

00:44:13.959 --> 00:44:15.769
to establish some

00:44:15.769 --> 00:44:16.909
kindergartens and

00:44:16.909 --> 00:44:18.280
primary schools and

00:44:18.280 --> 00:44:19.280
some infrastructure,

00:44:19.280 --> 00:44:20.429
build some roads and

00:44:20.429 --> 00:44:21.770
some public buildings

00:44:24.433 --> 00:44:25.174
so how do we do that?

00:44:26.024 --> 00:44:26.614
The locals will

00:44:26.614 --> 00:44:27.154
have to do it.

00:44:27.163 --> 00:44:28.424
So a decree was

00:44:28.444 --> 00:44:29.323
issued Monday

00:44:29.323 --> 00:44:30.323
morning, 8:00,

00:44:30.334 --> 00:44:31.394
everyone assembles,

00:44:31.424 --> 00:44:32.553
and we're gonna start

00:44:33.303 --> 00:44:34.194
build this road.

00:44:35.053 --> 00:44:35.943
Nobody came.

00:44:37.274 --> 00:44:37.614
Why?

00:44:37.803 --> 00:44:38.313
The weather's

00:44:38.314 --> 00:44:39.263
good in Yap.

00:44:39.823 --> 00:44:40.403
There's beautiful

00:44:40.413 --> 00:44:41.213
beaches.

00:44:41.383 --> 00:44:41.713
There's some

00:44:41.723 --> 00:44:42.423
trees with very

00:44:42.424 --> 00:44:43.533
low-hanging fruit.

00:44:44.563 --> 00:44:45.134
You can just lie

00:44:45.134 --> 00:44:45.754
on the beach all

00:44:45.754 --> 00:44:47.693
day, eat those

00:44:47.713 --> 00:44:48.723
low-hanging fruit.

00:44:49.453 --> 00:44:50.113
These Germans are

00:44:50.114 --> 00:44:50.843
crazy, is what

00:44:50.843 --> 00:44:51.673
they, the locals

00:44:51.674 --> 00:44:52.273
were thinking.

00:44:52.924 --> 00:44:53.513
So nobody was

00:44:53.513 --> 00:44:54.833
motivated to turn up.

00:44:55.053 --> 00:44:55.763
What do you do?

00:44:56.584 --> 00:44:58.314
So this administrator

00:44:58.314 --> 00:44:58.943
studied their

00:44:58.944 --> 00:45:00.373
monetary system and

00:45:00.374 --> 00:45:01.113
was intrigued, and

00:45:01.113 --> 00:45:01.484
then he thought,

00:45:01.484 --> 00:45:02.943
"Okay  I've, I know

00:45:02.944 --> 00:45:04.653
what to do." So he

00:45:04.663 --> 00:45:05.653
sent his assistant

00:45:05.663 --> 00:45:07.153
around with a pot

00:45:07.153 --> 00:45:09.384
of paint and drew

00:45:09.444 --> 00:45:11.493
a, a, a black cross,

00:45:11.523 --> 00:45:13.223
iron cross shape

00:45:13.444 --> 00:45:14.613
on each of those

00:45:14.613 --> 00:45:16.374
stones, and read

00:45:16.374 --> 00:45:17.433
out a little decree.

00:45:18.194 --> 00:45:18.703
"The German

00:45:18.703 --> 00:45:19.533
government has

00:45:19.543 --> 00:45:21.393
herewith confiscated

00:45:21.733 --> 00:45:23.593
your money." So

00:45:23.604 --> 00:45:24.883
all the stones

00:45:24.913 --> 00:45:25.743
were confica-

00:45:25.793 --> 00:45:26.524
confiscated by the

00:45:26.524 --> 00:45:27.673
German government.

00:45:28.394 --> 00:45:28.873
Obviously, they

00:45:28.873 --> 00:45:29.423
were still there

00:45:29.424 --> 00:45:30.343
in the same place.

00:45:31.004 --> 00:45:32.033
So when the decree

00:45:32.033 --> 00:45:32.953
was read out to the

00:45:32.953 --> 00:45:33.743
local population,

00:45:33.743 --> 00:45:34.553
you can imagine

00:45:34.553 --> 00:45:35.533
their reaction,

00:45:36.144 --> 00:45:36.713
'cause the stones

00:45:36.714 --> 00:45:37.534
were still there.

00:45:38.934 --> 00:45:39.614
Namely, when they

00:45:39.614 --> 00:45:40.414
heard that their

00:45:40.414 --> 00:45:41.093
money had been

00:45:41.093 --> 00:45:42.193
confiscated by the

00:45:42.193 --> 00:45:43.053
German government,

00:45:43.063 --> 00:45:44.404
they were absolutely

00:45:45.013 --> 00:45:46.173
devastated.

00:45:46.424 --> 00:45:46.633
They were

00:45:46.644 --> 00:45:47.474
impoverished.

00:45:47.483 --> 00:45:48.123
They'd lost all

00:45:48.123 --> 00:45:48.723
their money.

00:45:49.144 --> 00:45:49.443
All their

00:45:49.443 --> 00:45:50.334
wealth is gone

00:45:54.500 --> 00:45:55.500
And so then he sent

00:45:55.500 --> 00:45:56.770
out another decree

00:45:56.770 --> 00:45:57.820
which said, "Okay,

00:45:57.820 --> 00:45:58.800
next week Monday,

00:45:58.800 --> 00:46:02.160
8:00, all able-bodied

00:46:02.160 --> 00:46:03.820
men from the age of

00:46:04.240 --> 00:46:06.420
16 to 60 gather and

00:46:06.420 --> 00:46:07.220
we'll build some

00:46:07.220 --> 00:46:07.980
roads and build some

00:46:07.980 --> 00:46:09.139
kindergartens." And

00:46:09.140 --> 00:46:10.040
they all turned up

00:46:13.870 --> 00:46:14.710
"This instantly

00:46:14.710 --> 00:46:15.540
worked like a charm.

00:46:15.540 --> 00:46:16.069
The people

00:46:16.069 --> 00:46:17.190
thus dolefully

00:46:17.200 --> 00:46:19.100
impoverished turned

00:46:19.100 --> 00:46:20.020
to and repaired the

00:46:20.020 --> 00:46:21.180
highways to such good

00:46:21.200 --> 00:46:22.359
effect from one end

00:46:22.380 --> 00:46:23.120
of the island to the

00:46:23.120 --> 00:46:24.140
other that they're

00:46:24.140 --> 00:46:25.579
now like park drives.

00:46:25.940 --> 00:46:26.749
Then the government

00:46:26.759 --> 00:46:27.489
dispatched its

00:46:27.520 --> 00:46:28.589
agents and erased

00:46:28.600 --> 00:46:31.709
the crosses." So

00:46:31.729 --> 00:46:32.600
the question here

00:46:32.609 --> 00:46:34.519
is, what is this

00:46:34.529 --> 00:46:35.600
monetary system?

00:46:36.600 --> 00:46:38.159
We're told this is

00:46:38.359 --> 00:46:39.909
the sequence of how

00:46:40.130 --> 00:46:41.329
monetary systems

00:46:41.419 --> 00:46:42.680
evolve over time.

00:46:43.549 --> 00:46:43.970
So where do

00:46:43.989 --> 00:46:44.580
you spot it?

00:46:44.600 --> 00:46:45.380
Where is it?

00:46:46.059 --> 00:46:47.100
Where is the stone

00:46:47.100 --> 00:46:47.939
money of Yap?

00:46:53.344 --> 00:46:55.104
Fiat, paper

00:46:55.104 --> 00:46:56.134
substitute

00:46:59.122 --> 00:46:59.762
Is it bought?

00:46:59.772 --> 00:47:00.482
Is it commodity

00:47:00.482 --> 00:47:00.822
money?

00:47:00.862 --> 00:47:01.212
Richard.

00:47:01.252 --> 00:47:01.982
Is it credit?

00:47:02.022 --> 00:47:02.322
Yes.

00:47:06.022 --> 00:47:06.363
It depends also

00:47:06.363 --> 00:47:07.168
a little bit  of

00:47:07.168 --> 00:47:07.651
how … who orders

00:47:07.651 --> 00:47:08.321
these stones to

00:47:08.322 --> 00:47:09.942
be made, and  how

00:47:09.992 --> 00:47:10.732
does that work?

00:47:10.732 --> 00:47:11.132
Because even

00:47:11.132 --> 00:47:11.732
then it was

00:47:11.732 --> 00:47:12.692
credit  you could

00:47:13.152 --> 00:47:14.152
mine them by going

00:47:14.152 --> 00:47:15.312
to that far-flung

00:47:15.382 --> 00:47:17.042
island Right So that

00:47:17.042 --> 00:47:18.482
was open-ended, like

00:47:18.482 --> 00:47:19.582
mining for gold.

00:47:20.591 --> 00:47:21.471
But yes, what is it?

00:47:21.482 --> 00:47:22.591
What is the system?

00:47:23.062 --> 00:47:23.652
It … You could

00:47:23.661 --> 00:47:24.632
argue, but  it's

00:47:24.632 --> 00:47:25.481
not a commodity

00:47:25.481 --> 00:47:25.941
because there's

00:47:25.941 --> 00:47:27.011
no commodity use

00:47:27.351 --> 00:47:28.361
for those stones.

00:47:29.441 --> 00:47:30.661
Fiat  it was

00:47:30.661 --> 00:47:32.801
actually  a system

00:47:32.801 --> 00:47:33.671
that developed

00:47:34.262 --> 00:47:36.832
in society and

00:47:36.832 --> 00:47:38.142
wasn't a government

00:47:38.152 --> 00:47:39.511
decree, so you could

00:47:39.511 --> 00:47:40.422
argue about that.

00:47:41.922 --> 00:47:42.551
But it is

00:47:42.551 --> 00:47:43.432
actually credit.

00:47:43.902 --> 00:47:44.712
All it is, it's a

00:47:44.712 --> 00:47:45.841
credit system, and

00:47:45.841 --> 00:47:47.232
the stones merely

00:47:47.232 --> 00:47:48.261
serve the function

00:47:48.281 --> 00:47:49.992
of a mnemonic device.

00:47:50.601 --> 00:47:50.842
You know the

00:47:50.842 --> 00:47:51.431
word mnemonics,

00:47:51.431 --> 00:47:54.701
M-N-E-M, mnemonic.

00:47:55.141 --> 00:47:56.662
It's a memory device.

00:47:57.571 --> 00:47:59.181
It's like tying

00:47:59.241 --> 00:48:00.301
a knot into your

00:48:00.341 --> 00:48:01.532
handkerchief to

00:48:01.532 --> 00:48:02.381
remember something.

00:48:03.191 --> 00:48:04.031
"Oh, I've got this

00:48:04.032 --> 00:48:05.131
knot. What the

00:48:05.132 --> 00:48:05.691
heck am I supposed

00:48:05.691 --> 00:48:06.052
to remember?"

00:48:10.254 --> 00:48:11.194
It's a memory

00:48:11.194 --> 00:48:14.364
device to remind

00:48:14.364 --> 00:48:15.114
people of the

00:48:15.114 --> 00:48:16.004
record because they

00:48:16.004 --> 00:48:17.034
didn't have writing.

00:48:18.124 --> 00:48:18.654
And of course, in

00:48:18.683 --> 00:48:19.714
other societies,

00:48:19.734 --> 00:48:20.464
you would write

00:48:20.473 --> 00:48:22.233
down who owns what

00:48:22.274 --> 00:48:23.453
and who transfers

00:48:23.473 --> 00:48:24.573
ownership to who.

00:48:26.223 --> 00:48:26.903
So it's a credit

00:48:26.904 --> 00:48:27.544
system, and it

00:48:27.544 --> 00:48:28.263
turns out if you

00:48:28.324 --> 00:48:29.594
look into history

00:48:31.862 --> 00:48:33.162
Credit came first.

00:48:33.172 --> 00:48:34.142
So the official

00:48:34.142 --> 00:48:34.812
narrative is

00:48:34.812 --> 00:48:35.812
entirely wrong.

00:48:36.582 --> 00:48:37.802
Credit is older

00:48:37.802 --> 00:48:39.312
than the other

00:48:39.312 --> 00:48:40.572
forms of money.

00:48:41.722 --> 00:48:42.632
We have very good

00:48:42.632 --> 00:48:43.282
records on the

00:48:43.291 --> 00:48:44.732
Babylonian economy

00:48:47.062 --> 00:48:48.132
Ancient Babylon

00:48:49.352 --> 00:48:50.991
featured banks,

00:48:51.221 --> 00:48:52.192
proper banks.

00:48:52.261 --> 00:48:52.772
They had all

00:48:52.772 --> 00:48:53.432
functions of

00:48:53.432 --> 00:48:54.372
a modern bank.

00:48:54.971 --> 00:48:55.552
They didn't have

00:48:55.552 --> 00:48:56.272
computers, well,

00:48:56.272 --> 00:48:57.442
but that didn't

00:48:57.442 --> 00:48:58.532
exist 70 years

00:48:58.532 --> 00:48:59.832
ago either, right?

00:49:00.152 --> 00:49:00.852
So they were just

00:49:00.852 --> 00:49:01.672
records, and they

00:49:01.672 --> 00:49:03.941
had records written

00:49:03.952 --> 00:49:04.842
on clay, which is

00:49:04.862 --> 00:49:06.061
why they survived.

00:49:07.752 --> 00:49:09.011
As the clay hardened

00:49:09.011 --> 00:49:09.542
or a building

00:49:09.551 --> 00:49:10.582
got burnt down

00:49:12.772 --> 00:49:14.102
the clay hardened,

00:49:14.252 --> 00:49:14.771
and we have

00:49:14.782 --> 00:49:16.752
thousands of-- tens

00:49:16.752 --> 00:49:17.432
of thousands of

00:49:17.451 --> 00:49:19.931
clay tablets on the

00:49:19.941 --> 00:49:21.131
ancient Babylonian

00:49:21.152 --> 00:49:22.321
monetary system.

00:49:23.002 --> 00:49:23.371
So there were

00:49:23.371 --> 00:49:24.512
banks that took

00:49:24.512 --> 00:49:26.232
deposits, gave loans,

00:49:26.272 --> 00:49:26.922
collateralized,

00:49:26.961 --> 00:49:27.841
uncollateralized,

00:49:27.882 --> 00:49:28.691
did cashless

00:49:28.722 --> 00:49:30.042
money transfers,

00:49:30.671 --> 00:49:31.701
international

00:49:31.722 --> 00:49:33.491
transfers, bill

00:49:33.522 --> 00:49:34.272
discounting,

00:49:34.272 --> 00:49:35.471
foreign exchange.

00:49:37.182 --> 00:49:39.491
In 2007, there

00:49:39.491 --> 00:49:40.792
was a headline

00:49:40.801 --> 00:49:41.531
in the British

00:49:41.542 --> 00:49:42.551
national newspaper,

00:49:42.551 --> 00:49:43.572
Daily Telegraph.

00:49:44.132 --> 00:49:45.071
On the cover page,

00:49:45.071 --> 00:49:45.451
they had this

00:49:45.452 --> 00:49:47.241
photo and this

00:49:47.241 --> 00:49:48.402
story about one of

00:49:48.402 --> 00:49:49.471
these clay tablets

00:49:52.470 --> 00:49:53.240
And I was just

00:49:54.129 --> 00:49:54.960
teaching this

00:49:55.049 --> 00:49:55.819
to my students

00:49:55.819 --> 00:49:56.839
in Southampton.

00:49:59.080 --> 00:50:00.310
So  why was this

00:50:00.350 --> 00:50:02.569
news  newsworthy?

00:50:02.569 --> 00:50:03.100
Why was this on

00:50:03.100 --> 00:50:04.069
the cover page?

00:50:04.629 --> 00:50:05.859
Because Michael

00:50:05.859 --> 00:50:07.609
Jursa, an Austrian

00:50:10.149 --> 00:50:11.099
scholar of

00:50:11.099 --> 00:50:11.149
Assyriology and

00:50:11.149 --> 00:50:13.339
cuneiform writing,

00:50:14.009 --> 00:50:15.660
had spent time in

00:50:16.270 --> 00:50:17.429
the British Museum,

00:50:17.430 --> 00:50:18.310
and most of these

00:50:18.440 --> 00:50:20.069
tablets are in the

00:50:20.080 --> 00:50:20.949
British Museum.

00:50:21.520 --> 00:50:22.410
Number two location

00:50:22.410 --> 00:50:23.609
is Louvre, and number

00:50:23.609 --> 00:50:24.769
three is in Berlin.

00:50:25.439 --> 00:50:26.369
The largest amount

00:50:26.389 --> 00:50:27.970
is in London, British

00:50:27.970 --> 00:50:29.660
Museum, and the vast

00:50:29.660 --> 00:50:30.589
majority still has

00:50:30.589 --> 00:50:32.219
not been translated.

00:50:32.959 --> 00:50:34.469
So if anyone has some

00:50:34.479 --> 00:50:36.460
spare capacity, learn

00:50:36.479 --> 00:50:37.769
ancient cuneiform

00:50:37.770 --> 00:50:39.799
writing and Assyrian

00:50:39.809 --> 00:50:41.229
language, and you

00:50:41.229 --> 00:50:42.269
can join the game.

00:50:42.819 --> 00:50:43.419
Actually, I had a

00:50:43.419 --> 00:50:44.189
colleague when I was

00:50:44.189 --> 00:50:45.289
a chief economist of

00:50:45.290 --> 00:50:45.959
a British investment

00:50:45.969 --> 00:50:46.809
bank in Tokyo.

00:50:47.169 --> 00:50:49.079
My  Hong Kong

00:50:49.419 --> 00:50:51.069
colleague, Catherine

00:50:51.069 --> 00:50:52.279
Chu, she worked

00:50:52.279 --> 00:50:53.329
for-- she was senior

00:50:53.329 --> 00:50:54.410
economist of a Hong

00:50:54.410 --> 00:50:56.139
Kong securities firm.

00:50:56.540 --> 00:50:57.089
My company's

00:50:57.089 --> 00:50:57.650
headquarters was in

00:50:57.650 --> 00:50:58.140
Hong Kong as well.

00:50:58.140 --> 00:50:58.849
I was in Tokyo.

00:50:59.269 --> 00:51:00.549
Anyway, she quit

00:51:00.650 --> 00:51:01.690
her job, and she

00:51:01.699 --> 00:51:02.490
said, "Oh, I'm gonna

00:51:02.500 --> 00:51:03.739
do that." And she

00:51:04.909 --> 00:51:05.570
became a student

00:51:05.570 --> 00:51:06.279
again at University

00:51:06.279 --> 00:51:07.129
of Chicago,

00:51:07.939 --> 00:51:08.839
considered leading

00:51:08.839 --> 00:51:09.490
nowadays, used to

00:51:09.500 --> 00:51:11.629
be Berlin, but  in

00:51:11.629 --> 00:51:12.999
learning cuneiform,

00:51:13.059 --> 00:51:14.569
Assyrian, and she's

00:51:14.569 --> 00:51:15.510
been translating

00:51:15.819 --> 00:51:16.549
clay tablets.

00:51:16.959 --> 00:51:17.429
She knows

00:51:17.430 --> 00:51:18.429
Michael Jursa.

00:51:19.769 --> 00:51:20.469
So he

00:51:21.400 --> 00:51:22.359
translated this.

00:51:23.099 --> 00:51:23.749
And why is it

00:51:23.750 --> 00:51:24.710
newsworthy?

00:51:25.100 --> 00:51:27.120
It says that the

00:51:27.169 --> 00:51:28.939
chief officer of

00:51:29.279 --> 00:51:31.679
King Nebuchadnezzar

00:51:31.679 --> 00:51:32.949
II, king of Babylon,

00:51:33.489 --> 00:51:34.229
his chief officer,

00:51:34.229 --> 00:51:34.870
so now we'd say

00:51:34.889 --> 00:51:35.789
prime minister,

00:51:36.509 --> 00:51:38.429
had deposited the

00:51:38.430 --> 00:51:39.229
equivalent of seven

00:51:39.229 --> 00:51:39.810
hundred and fifty

00:51:39.810 --> 00:51:41.989
grams of gold with

00:51:41.989 --> 00:51:43.680
the temple in Babylon

00:51:46.166 --> 00:51:46.506
Well, why is

00:51:46.506 --> 00:51:47.456
that newsworthy?

00:51:47.946 --> 00:51:48.846
Actually not, that's

00:51:48.846 --> 00:51:49.696
not the reason.

00:51:50.366 --> 00:51:51.276
It's newsworthy

00:51:51.296 --> 00:51:52.666
because the name of

00:51:52.666 --> 00:51:53.536
this chief officer

00:51:53.536 --> 00:51:54.506
was mentioned,

00:51:55.036 --> 00:51:56.366
and the name is

00:51:56.796 --> 00:51:59.215
Nebusazikan, and

00:51:59.225 --> 00:52:00.426
that was a sensation.

00:52:00.435 --> 00:52:00.915
Why?

00:52:01.356 --> 00:52:03.286
Because prior to

00:52:03.286 --> 00:52:05.416
this translation,

00:52:06.136 --> 00:52:07.305
this name had only

00:52:07.306 --> 00:52:08.236
been mentioned in the

00:52:08.236 --> 00:52:09.665
Old Testament as the

00:52:09.675 --> 00:52:12.216
chief officer of King

00:52:12.216 --> 00:52:13.655
Nebuchadnezzar II.

00:52:14.296 --> 00:52:14.705
And of course,

00:52:14.725 --> 00:52:15.146
the historians

00:52:15.146 --> 00:52:16.135
saying, " you can't

00:52:16.136 --> 00:52:16.925
rely on the Bible.

00:52:16.925 --> 00:52:17.626
It's all made-up

00:52:17.626 --> 00:52:21.365
stuff."  actually  a

00:52:21.365 --> 00:52:22.656
fantastic discovery,

00:52:22.656 --> 00:52:23.675
a world-class find.

00:52:23.716 --> 00:52:24.876
If Nebusazikan

00:52:24.876 --> 00:52:26.205
existed, which

00:52:26.225 --> 00:52:27.006
other lesser

00:52:27.006 --> 00:52:27.985
figures in the Old

00:52:27.986 --> 00:52:29.195
Testament existed?

00:52:29.786 --> 00:52:30.065
It's a good

00:52:30.065 --> 00:52:30.636
question, isn't it?

00:52:30.915 --> 00:52:32.115
A throwaway detail

00:52:32.115 --> 00:52:32.856
in the Old Testament

00:52:32.865 --> 00:52:33.506
turns out to be

00:52:33.545 --> 00:52:34.506
accurate and true.

00:52:34.925 --> 00:52:35.685
I think that it means

00:52:35.685 --> 00:52:36.386
that the whole of the

00:52:36.386 --> 00:52:37.856
narrative takes on

00:52:37.856 --> 00:52:39.075
a new kind of power.

00:52:39.905 --> 00:52:40.375
This is in the

00:52:40.376 --> 00:52:41.356
Book of Jeremiah

00:52:43.574 --> 00:52:45.824
Now also, in our

00:52:45.824 --> 00:52:46.854
quest to understand

00:52:46.854 --> 00:52:49.740
money This is an

00:52:49.740 --> 00:52:51.420
important find.

00:52:51.960 --> 00:52:52.640
Here's a quiz

00:52:52.640 --> 00:52:54.780
question for you.

00:52:55.990 --> 00:52:56.770
Why does this

00:52:56.790 --> 00:52:57.680
even exist?

00:52:57.789 --> 00:52:58.580
Why does

00:52:58.580 --> 00:53:00.590
Nebuchadnezzar II,

00:53:00.869 --> 00:53:01.790
King of Babylon,

00:53:02.079 --> 00:53:03.770
or his appointed

00:53:03.770 --> 00:53:04.480
prime minister,

00:53:04.480 --> 00:53:05.970
Nebusarsekim, why

00:53:05.970 --> 00:53:07.049
do they need a

00:53:07.050 --> 00:53:09.170
deposit receipt when

00:53:09.170 --> 00:53:10.540
they deposit gold

00:53:10.540 --> 00:53:11.119
with the temple?

00:53:11.550 --> 00:53:12.330
It's understandable

00:53:12.530 --> 00:53:13.409
if you and me, we

00:53:13.410 --> 00:53:14.160
go to the temple

00:53:14.160 --> 00:53:14.889
in Babylon, we

00:53:14.890 --> 00:53:16.239
deposit gold, we'd

00:53:16.240 --> 00:53:17.180
like a record.

00:53:17.180 --> 00:53:17.490
We'd like

00:53:17.490 --> 00:53:18.199
the evidence.

00:53:18.599 --> 00:53:19.479
Okay, understood.

00:53:20.029 --> 00:53:22.029
But the king or

00:53:22.029 --> 00:53:23.210
his prime minister?

00:53:24.579 --> 00:53:25.849
Imagine the king

00:53:25.849 --> 00:53:26.609
says, "Okay  I'm

00:53:26.610 --> 00:53:27.160
gonna withdraw

00:53:27.160 --> 00:53:27.909
some gold from the

00:53:27.910 --> 00:53:30.759
temple." So now the

00:53:30.759 --> 00:53:32.319
king and his prime

00:53:32.320 --> 00:53:33.199
minister and his

00:53:33.239 --> 00:53:37.090
entourage of  100

00:53:37.590 --> 00:53:39.300
of the core royal

00:53:39.309 --> 00:53:40.879
staff appear at the

00:53:40.879 --> 00:53:42.859
temple, and all the

00:53:42.859 --> 00:53:44.829
high priests, "The

00:53:44.829 --> 00:53:45.480
king is coming.

00:53:45.480 --> 00:53:46.119
The king's coming."

00:53:46.129 --> 00:53:46.889
The whole royal

00:53:46.919 --> 00:53:47.529
palace, all these

00:53:47.529 --> 00:53:48.170
people are coming.

00:53:48.669 --> 00:53:49.720
"Quick, down

00:53:49.849 --> 00:53:50.499
on the ground."

00:53:50.539 --> 00:53:51.560
Everyone had to lie

00:53:51.560 --> 00:53:52.970
down, face down.

00:53:52.980 --> 00:53:53.359
You're not even

00:53:53.399 --> 00:53:54.250
allowed to look

00:53:54.270 --> 00:53:54.960
at the king.

00:53:56.609 --> 00:53:57.290
So all the high

00:53:57.310 --> 00:53:58.399
priests and temple

00:53:58.410 --> 00:53:59.590
staff and servants

00:53:59.639 --> 00:54:00.379
on the ground.

00:54:00.740 --> 00:54:01.669
The king enters

00:54:01.669 --> 00:54:02.389
the temple.

00:54:02.869 --> 00:54:03.900
"I'm gonna withdraw

00:54:03.910 --> 00:54:05.880
750 grams of gold

00:54:06.189 --> 00:54:07.119
from the temple."

00:54:08.060 --> 00:54:09.099
Do you really think

00:54:09.639 --> 00:54:10.840
any of those temple

00:54:10.849 --> 00:54:11.880
officials will say,

00:54:12.179 --> 00:54:13.009
lying gr- on the

00:54:13.009 --> 00:54:14.849
ground, "Sire, hast

00:54:14.859 --> 00:54:15.789
thou brought thy

00:54:15.789 --> 00:54:16.960
deposit receipt?"

00:54:20.259 --> 00:54:20.689
No.

00:54:20.700 --> 00:54:20.720
It

00:54:21.840 --> 00:54:22.459
was so he could

00:54:22.539 --> 00:54:23.279
present proof

00:54:23.279 --> 00:54:24.109
of collateral

00:54:24.109 --> 00:54:25.526
to take out a

00:54:25.526 --> 00:54:26.039
loan.

00:54:26.039 --> 00:54:26.659
That could be

00:54:26.660 --> 00:54:27.459
a, that could be

00:54:27.459 --> 00:54:28.259
an explanation.

00:54:31.569 --> 00:54:31.889
Or

00:54:33.329 --> 00:54:33.509
the temple's golden.

00:54:33.509 --> 00:54:33.859
But- The priests

00:54:33.869 --> 00:54:34.283
are above him.

00:54:34.283 --> 00:54:34.378
The priests are

00:54:34.378 --> 00:54:34.799
a- Above the

00:54:34.799 --> 00:54:35.139
king

00:54:35.139 --> 00:54:36.209
…  above the king.

00:54:37.090 --> 00:54:37.730
Certainly it would

00:54:37.730 --> 00:54:38.239
indicate that.

00:54:38.239 --> 00:54:38.499
Isn't that

00:54:38.499 --> 00:54:39.209
embarrassing?

00:54:39.379 --> 00:54:39.649
Isn't that

00:54:39.649 --> 00:54:40.149
embarrassing?

00:54:41.289 --> 00:54:42.779
So the fact is,

00:54:42.889 --> 00:54:44.039
no, the king didn't

00:54:44.039 --> 00:54:44.899
need this, okay?

00:54:44.899 --> 00:54:45.569
So it served

00:54:45.569 --> 00:54:46.469
another function.

00:54:46.480 --> 00:54:47.309
The question is, what

00:54:47.319 --> 00:54:48.050
is that function?

00:54:48.050 --> 00:54:49.909
But it wasn't the

00:54:49.910 --> 00:54:50.619
function that's

00:54:50.629 --> 00:54:52.250
written on here as

00:54:52.279 --> 00:54:53.489
deposit receipt.

00:54:54.359 --> 00:54:54.939
It served

00:54:54.939 --> 00:54:55.840
another function.

00:54:56.160 --> 00:54:57.079
And to find out

00:54:57.090 --> 00:54:57.860
exactly which

00:54:57.860 --> 00:55:00.669
one it is, let's

00:55:00.670 --> 00:55:01.360
look at another

00:55:01.379 --> 00:55:02.570
episode in history.

00:55:03.259 --> 00:55:04.540
So first on Babylon,

00:55:04.590 --> 00:55:05.869
we can conclude,

00:55:06.539 --> 00:55:07.299
and this is now

00:55:07.340 --> 00:55:08.719
established by

00:55:08.759 --> 00:55:10.079
recent, in the last

00:55:10.200 --> 00:55:12.190
30 years of research,

00:55:12.950 --> 00:55:14.749
by archaeologists,

00:55:14.810 --> 00:55:15.910
anthropologists,

00:55:15.950 --> 00:55:16.690
archaeological

00:55:16.690 --> 00:55:17.709
anthropologists,

00:55:19.509 --> 00:55:20.429
that the sequence

00:55:20.429 --> 00:55:21.059
we're told in the

00:55:21.060 --> 00:55:21.859
economics text was

00:55:21.869 --> 00:55:22.649
entirely wrong.

00:55:23.319 --> 00:55:24.779
Credit comes first,

00:55:24.959 --> 00:55:26.859
and banking preceded

00:55:26.899 --> 00:55:28.889
coinage by well

00:55:28.909 --> 00:55:30.930
over 1,000 years,

00:55:32.239 --> 00:55:33.039
and that changes

00:55:33.039 --> 00:55:33.800
a lot of things.

00:55:34.489 --> 00:55:35.189
The logic was

00:55:35.189 --> 00:55:35.909
very convincing,

00:55:35.909 --> 00:55:36.360
wasn't it?

00:55:36.450 --> 00:55:37.029
And that's how the

00:55:37.030 --> 00:55:38.129
economists like

00:55:38.129 --> 00:55:39.099
to convince you.

00:55:39.459 --> 00:55:40.349
Good logic.

00:55:40.539 --> 00:55:41.279
It's usually very

00:55:41.280 --> 00:55:41.949
consistent, and

00:55:42.499 --> 00:55:43.460
you can't fault

00:55:43.460 --> 00:55:45.469
the logic, except

00:55:46.136 --> 00:55:46.866
Just because it's

00:55:46.886 --> 00:55:48.566
logical does not

00:55:48.606 --> 00:55:49.986
mean it's true.

00:55:50.746 --> 00:55:51.886
It's a possibility.

00:55:52.706 --> 00:55:53.126
Whether it's

00:55:53.126 --> 00:55:53.916
true or not is an

00:55:53.916 --> 00:55:54.956
empirical question.

00:55:55.396 --> 00:55:56.086
You just gotta

00:55:56.086 --> 00:55:57.186
check the facts.

00:55:58.836 --> 00:55:59.336
Of course, the

00:55:59.345 --> 00:55:59.935
Babylonians

00:55:59.946 --> 00:56:00.746
also introduced

00:56:00.765 --> 00:56:01.715
interest first.

00:56:01.725 --> 00:56:02.466
They realized

00:56:02.485 --> 00:56:03.036
that this is a

00:56:03.036 --> 00:56:03.976
mechanism that

00:56:05.546 --> 00:56:07.355
compounds wealth

00:56:07.405 --> 00:56:08.376
and concentrates

00:56:08.376 --> 00:56:09.406
wealth and transfers

00:56:09.406 --> 00:56:09.985
wealth from the

00:56:09.985 --> 00:56:10.926
many to the few.

00:56:11.415 --> 00:56:12.716
Their solution was

00:56:13.235 --> 00:56:14.996
to wipe the clay

00:56:15.005 --> 00:56:17.216
s-  slates clean

00:56:17.235 --> 00:56:18.865
whenever a king died.

00:56:19.946 --> 00:56:20.765
Most of the debt

00:56:20.786 --> 00:56:21.706
was to the king

00:56:22.585 --> 00:56:23.815
via the temple.

00:56:25.245 --> 00:56:28.056
And the debt was

00:56:28.095 --> 00:56:29.406
canceled each time

00:56:29.406 --> 00:56:30.616
a king died, so

00:56:30.616 --> 00:56:32.556
every few decades

00:56:32.565 --> 00:56:33.566
you'd have a total

00:56:33.595 --> 00:56:34.526
cancellation of

00:56:34.526 --> 00:56:35.696
debt, what they

00:56:35.696 --> 00:56:36.765
called a jubilee.

00:56:38.595 --> 00:56:39.685
Of course, we have

00:56:39.696 --> 00:56:40.635
modern banking.

00:56:40.646 --> 00:56:41.866
We have copied

00:56:41.885 --> 00:56:43.315
interest, charging

00:56:43.315 --> 00:56:44.455
interest, but

00:56:44.466 --> 00:56:45.145
we don't have

00:56:45.146 --> 00:56:46.535
this mechanism.

00:56:47.446 --> 00:56:48.165
Seems to be a bit

00:56:48.165 --> 00:56:50.146
of a- an issue.

00:56:51.416 --> 00:56:52.135
The Norman tally

00:56:52.136 --> 00:56:52.836
stick system was

00:56:52.846 --> 00:56:54.336
also a credit system,

00:56:56.295 --> 00:56:57.245
and Babylon had a

00:56:57.245 --> 00:56:57.935
credit system, so

00:56:57.935 --> 00:56:59.136
credit came first.

00:56:59.166 --> 00:57:00.816
Now, let's look at

00:57:00.816 --> 00:57:03.126
another episode, and

00:57:03.126 --> 00:57:05.125
this is from China

00:57:07.480 --> 00:57:08.080
We've got a good

00:57:08.080 --> 00:57:09.790
record from Marco

00:57:09.790 --> 00:57:11.390
Polo and his

00:57:11.390 --> 00:57:13.060
travels to China

00:57:15.728 --> 00:57:16.378
In those days, it

00:57:16.378 --> 00:57:17.248
took a while to

00:57:17.248 --> 00:57:20.708
reach China from  he

00:57:20.708 --> 00:57:21.788
came from Venice

00:57:22.938 --> 00:57:24.208
with his  father

00:57:24.538 --> 00:57:25.218
and his father's

00:57:25.218 --> 00:57:26.148
brother, his uncle.

00:57:26.178 --> 00:57:27.228
They were traders.

00:57:27.978 --> 00:57:28.327
They didn't

00:57:28.328 --> 00:57:29.188
actually plan to go

00:57:29.188 --> 00:57:32.128
to  to China, but

00:57:32.157 --> 00:57:32.997
there were wars.

00:57:33.028 --> 00:57:33.777
There were … As

00:57:33.778 --> 00:57:35.038
they were traveling,

00:57:35.118 --> 00:57:36.107
it turned out better

00:57:36.108 --> 00:57:37.277
to go further east.

00:57:37.278 --> 00:57:37.917
And then at some

00:57:37.918 --> 00:57:39.637
stage they met

00:57:40.157 --> 00:57:41.127
emissaries from

00:57:41.127 --> 00:57:42.467
the court of the

00:57:42.477 --> 00:57:43.888
Great Khan who

00:57:43.888 --> 00:57:44.508
said, "Oh, you

00:57:44.508 --> 00:57:45.827
guys, you're Latins.

00:57:45.858 --> 00:57:46.787
Latins, okay.

00:57:47.418 --> 00:57:48.137
The Great Khan

00:57:48.147 --> 00:57:49.788
loves to meet Latins

00:57:49.837 --> 00:57:50.698
and speak to you.

00:57:51.208 --> 00:57:51.467
And you're

00:57:51.478 --> 00:57:52.198
Christian as well.

00:57:52.307 --> 00:57:53.008
He loves to talk to

00:57:53.017 --> 00:57:55.268
Christians." So  they

00:57:55.268 --> 00:57:55.937
got this message

00:57:55.938 --> 00:57:56.887
several times, and

00:57:56.888 --> 00:57:57.377
they thought, "Okay

00:57:57.548 --> 00:57:58.328
let's go there."

00:57:58.517 --> 00:57:59.957
And so  they went

00:57:59.967 --> 00:58:02.416
to Khanbaliq The

00:58:02.416 --> 00:58:03.526
story was, of course,

00:58:04.066 --> 00:58:04.806
the Great Khan.

00:58:05.036 --> 00:58:05.866
And because that

00:58:05.866 --> 00:58:07.326
took two years  this

00:58:07.336 --> 00:58:08.356
travel further east

00:58:08.356 --> 00:58:09.136
and further east,

00:58:09.136 --> 00:58:10.586
and during that time,

00:58:10.595 --> 00:58:11.616
young Marco Polo,

00:58:11.616 --> 00:58:12.626
sixteen years old,

00:58:12.635 --> 00:58:14.236
he picked up  the

00:58:14.236 --> 00:58:16.066
main language of the

00:58:16.066 --> 00:58:16.946
domain, which was

00:58:17.005 --> 00:58:18.176
Tatar, as he would

00:58:18.176 --> 00:58:19.206
call it, Mongolian,

00:58:19.995 --> 00:58:21.116
because Kublai

00:58:21.175 --> 00:58:23.635
Khan  was the ruler,

00:58:23.636 --> 00:58:24.185
and of course, he

00:58:24.186 --> 00:58:25.735
was the great,  He

00:58:25.735 --> 00:58:26.575
was the grandson

00:58:26.616 --> 00:58:27.815
of Genghis Khan,

00:58:27.815 --> 00:58:28.826
so Mongolian was

00:58:28.845 --> 00:58:30.245
the administrative

00:58:30.245 --> 00:58:30.915
language.

00:58:31.296 --> 00:58:31.915
Because he picked

00:58:31.915 --> 00:58:33.326
it up, it was a

00:58:33.326 --> 00:58:34.115
great meeting.

00:58:34.145 --> 00:58:34.926
Kublai Khan loved

00:58:34.935 --> 00:58:35.895
to talk to him in

00:58:35.896 --> 00:58:37.915
Mongolian, and he

00:58:38.455 --> 00:58:40.045
Marco could translate

00:58:40.045 --> 00:58:40.875
for the others.

00:58:41.725 --> 00:58:42.545
And by the way,

00:58:43.146 --> 00:58:44.256
Kublai Khan gave them

00:58:44.256 --> 00:58:46.296
a mission  Go back to

00:58:46.296 --> 00:58:48.205
your leader and tell

00:58:48.205 --> 00:58:49.045
him," and your leader

00:58:49.056 --> 00:58:50.106
in Rome, right?

00:58:50.335 --> 00:58:50.866
Ah, he means

00:58:50.876 --> 00:58:51.266
the Pope.

00:58:51.455 --> 00:58:51.945
Yes.

00:58:52.845 --> 00:58:54.446
Send back with you…

00:58:54.446 --> 00:58:55.476
Come back with three

00:58:55.476 --> 00:58:56.346
hundred of your top

00:58:56.365 --> 00:58:58.145
theologians, and

00:58:58.155 --> 00:58:59.026
they will debate

00:58:59.405 --> 00:59:01.176
my top theologians,

00:59:01.876 --> 00:59:02.796
Mongolian,

00:59:03.185 --> 00:59:05.756
Chinese  Persian.

00:59:06.705 --> 00:59:08.185
And if you're

00:59:08.186 --> 00:59:09.335
convincing us,

00:59:09.616 --> 00:59:10.195
which I think you

00:59:10.225 --> 00:59:11.186
can, we'll all

00:59:11.186 --> 00:59:11.935
become Christian.

00:59:11.936 --> 00:59:12.816
The Mo- Mongolian

00:59:12.816 --> 00:59:13.706
Empire will become

00:59:13.706 --> 00:59:14.215
Christian." That

00:59:14.216 --> 00:59:14.846
was the deal.

00:59:15.375 --> 00:59:17.245
Sadly, in Europe,

00:59:17.245 --> 00:59:19.095
the situation  was

00:59:19.095 --> 00:59:19.825
such that nobody was

00:59:19.826 --> 00:59:20.765
interested in China.

00:59:20.765 --> 00:59:22.265
There were,  There

00:59:22.265 --> 00:59:23.235
was a counter-pope

00:59:23.235 --> 00:59:23.976
in Avignon.

00:59:24.006 --> 00:59:24.585
There was all sorts

00:59:24.585 --> 00:59:25.435
of problems, and

00:59:26.235 --> 00:59:26.986
they didn't get three

00:59:26.986 --> 00:59:27.946
hundred theologians.

00:59:28.326 --> 00:59:29.545
They got three

00:59:29.975 --> 00:59:32.526
monks, of which

00:59:32.576 --> 00:59:33.965
two deserted on the

00:59:33.966 --> 00:59:34.525
way because it was

00:59:34.525 --> 00:59:35.256
getting dangerous.

00:59:35.256 --> 00:59:36.095
Various battles

00:59:36.095 --> 00:59:36.595
happened.

00:59:37.055 --> 00:59:38.225
So  they came back

00:59:38.245 --> 00:59:39.175
with one monk.

00:59:40.155 --> 00:59:41.085
And then-- and they

00:59:41.085 --> 00:59:41.765
were a bit afraid

00:59:41.775 --> 00:59:42.815
to meet Kublai Khan.

00:59:43.165 --> 00:59:43.915
It's not exactly

00:59:43.925 --> 00:59:44.555
impressive.

00:59:46.345 --> 00:59:47.375
Kublai Khan then

00:59:47.466 --> 00:59:48.575
said, "Never mind,

00:59:48.585 --> 00:59:49.725
but Marco, why don't

00:59:49.725 --> 00:59:50.636
you stay with me

00:59:51.375 --> 00:59:52.415
and work for me?"

00:59:52.415 --> 00:59:53.116
And he became a

00:59:53.125 --> 00:59:54.615
senior official in

00:59:54.615 --> 00:59:55.535
his administration,

00:59:55.655 --> 00:59:57.015
speaking several

00:59:57.015 --> 00:59:58.575
languages, having

00:59:58.576 --> 01:00:01.065
a  good  good

01:00:01.065 --> 01:00:01.935
communication with

01:00:01.935 --> 01:00:02.775
the Great Khan.

01:00:02.775 --> 01:00:04.315
And so in his book

01:00:04.995 --> 01:00:05.585
he had to flee.

01:00:05.795 --> 01:00:06.115
He wasn't

01:00:06.115 --> 01:00:06.855
allowed to leave.

01:00:06.865 --> 01:00:07.865
After twenty years,

01:00:07.865 --> 01:00:08.735
he did wanna come

01:00:08.735 --> 01:00:09.475
back to Europe,

01:00:10.375 --> 01:00:11.936
and he happened to

01:00:11.946 --> 01:00:12.565
be on a mission.

01:00:12.565 --> 01:00:13.085
If you read his

01:00:13.086 --> 01:00:14.245
book, The Travels,

01:00:14.786 --> 01:00:16.545
Il Mondo, The World

01:00:17.125 --> 01:00:17.875
is really what the

01:00:17.875 --> 01:00:18.605
book was called.

01:00:18.605 --> 01:00:19.486
As nowadays  they

01:00:19.486 --> 01:00:20.395
call it The Travels

01:00:20.396 --> 01:00:21.206
by Marco Polo.

01:00:22.976 --> 01:00:23.495
He was given a

01:00:23.495 --> 01:00:24.406
mission in the end,

01:00:24.406 --> 01:00:25.046
after twenty years,

01:00:25.046 --> 01:00:26.795
to  to accompany

01:00:26.806 --> 01:00:28.525
a princess for an

01:00:28.525 --> 01:00:29.365
arranged marriage

01:00:29.366 --> 01:00:30.305
to Indonesia.

01:00:31.982 --> 01:00:32.512
And of course, that's

01:00:32.512 --> 01:00:33.471
where the Portuguese

01:00:33.471 --> 01:00:34.402
ships … And he

01:00:34.402 --> 01:00:35.312
jumped ship and

01:00:35.312 --> 01:00:36.042
then went back with

01:00:36.042 --> 01:00:36.812
the Portuguese.

01:00:36.842 --> 01:00:39.272
And  and sure

01:00:39.272 --> 01:00:40.032
enough, as he came

01:00:40.032 --> 01:00:41.962
close to what today

01:00:41.962 --> 01:00:43.002
is called Italy,

01:00:43.432 --> 01:00:44.142
which was actually

01:00:44.262 --> 01:00:45.492
separate competing

01:00:45.492 --> 01:00:46.901
city-states  and

01:00:48.552 --> 01:00:50.591
different  regions,

01:00:50.721 --> 01:00:52.751
he was found, picked

01:00:52.752 --> 01:00:54.162
up by the Genoese.

01:00:54.721 --> 01:00:55.041
"Where are you

01:00:55.041 --> 01:00:56.232
from?" "Venice."

01:00:56.302 --> 01:00:57.712
"Oh, enemy spy.

01:00:58.052 --> 01:00:58.971
Where have you been?"

01:00:59.331 --> 01:00:59.812
"I've come from

01:00:59.812 --> 01:01:01.361
China." "Liar." Put

01:01:01.361 --> 01:01:02.102
him into prison.

01:01:02.511 --> 01:01:03.151
So he was in

01:01:03.152 --> 01:01:04.412
prison in Genoa

01:01:05.842 --> 01:01:07.012
on his return.

01:01:07.112 --> 01:01:07.761
Didn't quite make

01:01:07.761 --> 01:01:08.511
it to Venice.

01:01:09.502 --> 01:01:10.111
But for us,

01:01:10.111 --> 01:01:10.781
fortunately, he

01:01:10.781 --> 01:01:12.262
was  sharing the

01:01:12.262 --> 01:01:13.002
prison cell with

01:01:13.002 --> 01:01:14.931
a  a novelist.

01:01:15.712 --> 01:01:16.361
We can only guess

01:01:16.381 --> 01:01:16.901
why he was in

01:01:16.901 --> 01:01:17.782
prison, so one of

01:01:17.782 --> 01:01:19.151
his novels may have

01:01:19.151 --> 01:01:20.041
been criticizing the

01:01:20.041 --> 01:01:21.721
government or some

01:01:21.721 --> 01:01:22.991
leading aristocrat.

01:01:23.621 --> 01:01:24.771
But you can imagine

01:01:24.771 --> 01:01:25.892
their conversations

01:01:27.401 --> 01:01:27.941
when you sit in

01:01:27.941 --> 01:01:28.721
the prison cells.

01:01:28.721 --> 01:01:30.051
"Oh  where have you

01:01:30.052 --> 01:01:30.971
been?" "Oh, I've

01:01:30.971 --> 01:01:32.672
been at the court of

01:01:32.681 --> 01:01:33.472
the Khan of Khans,

01:01:33.962 --> 01:01:34.902
the Great Khan, the

01:01:34.931 --> 01:01:35.991
Emperor of China,

01:01:36.022 --> 01:01:37.122
Kublai Khan." "Wow,

01:01:37.871 --> 01:01:39.001
tell me more." "Oh,

01:01:39.001 --> 01:01:39.531
we've got to write

01:01:39.531 --> 01:01:41.031
a book." And so it

01:01:41.031 --> 01:01:41.972
was actually a joint

01:01:41.982 --> 01:01:43.101
venture, this book.

01:01:43.431 --> 01:01:44.201
It may not have

01:01:44.261 --> 01:01:45.322
otherwise happened,

01:01:45.331 --> 01:01:46.872
so fortunate for us.

01:01:46.882 --> 01:01:47.702
So in this book,

01:01:47.702 --> 01:01:48.282
he has a good

01:01:48.282 --> 01:01:49.251
description of the

01:01:49.261 --> 01:01:50.281
monetary system.

01:01:50.761 --> 01:01:51.471
In this city of

01:01:51.482 --> 01:01:53.061
Khanbaliq, which was

01:01:53.062 --> 01:01:54.641
what the northern

01:01:54.641 --> 01:01:56.042
capital Beijing is

01:01:56.042 --> 01:01:58.652
called  in those

01:01:58.652 --> 01:02:00.321
days, the Great

01:02:00.321 --> 01:02:01.641
Khan has his mint.

01:02:01.681 --> 01:02:02.672
Of course, mint being

01:02:02.672 --> 01:02:03.821
the European concept.

01:02:04.482 --> 01:02:05.421
It's so organized

01:02:05.421 --> 01:02:05.921
that you might well

01:02:05.921 --> 01:02:07.342
say that the Great

01:02:07.342 --> 01:02:08.182
Khan has mastered

01:02:08.182 --> 01:02:09.341
the art of alchemy,

01:02:09.641 --> 01:02:10.752
trying to turn base

01:02:10.781 --> 01:02:12.591
metals into gold.

01:02:13.421 --> 01:02:13.982
For which, by

01:02:13.982 --> 01:02:14.581
the way, a lot

01:02:14.581 --> 01:02:15.292
of resources were

01:02:15.292 --> 01:02:16.172
spent in Europe,

01:02:16.491 --> 01:02:17.442
particularly in the

01:02:17.461 --> 01:02:18.231
country that had

01:02:18.241 --> 01:02:19.531
most aristocratic

01:02:19.531 --> 01:02:20.321
families, which

01:02:20.321 --> 01:02:21.051
was Germany.

01:02:21.802 --> 01:02:22.471
At the peak, the

01:02:22.471 --> 01:02:23.191
Holy Roman Empire

01:02:23.191 --> 01:02:23.851
of German Nation had

01:02:23.861 --> 01:02:26.721
355 principalities.

01:02:27.491 --> 01:02:28.921
The only unchanged

01:02:28.931 --> 01:02:29.702
remnant is

01:02:29.702 --> 01:02:31.011
Liechtenstein, super

01:02:31.011 --> 01:02:32.921
tiny little country,

01:02:32.921 --> 01:02:34.491
principality, where

01:02:34.491 --> 01:02:35.311
the prince still has

01:02:35.311 --> 01:02:36.581
absolutist power.

01:02:38.482 --> 01:02:39.532
So the princes

01:02:39.871 --> 01:02:42.301
usually had a  a

01:02:42.301 --> 01:02:43.721
court factor, was

01:02:43.721 --> 01:02:45.042
the, the finance

01:02:45.092 --> 01:02:46.312
advisor or head of

01:02:46.312 --> 01:02:47.282
finance, also known

01:02:47.282 --> 01:02:49.242
as war factor for

01:02:49.252 --> 01:02:49.961
obvious reasons.

01:02:50.282 --> 01:02:51.342
And then you had

01:02:51.691 --> 01:02:52.902
the court alchemist

01:02:55.022 --> 01:02:55.802
So a lot of resources

01:02:55.802 --> 01:02:56.412
were spent on

01:02:56.432 --> 01:02:57.362
alchemy, which is

01:02:57.362 --> 01:02:58.202
why Germany became

01:02:58.202 --> 01:02:59.302
leading in chemistry.

01:02:59.802 --> 01:03:00.502
They didn't quite

01:03:00.502 --> 01:03:01.292
make gold, though.

01:03:03.831 --> 01:03:05.801
But Marco Polo says

01:03:06.092 --> 01:03:07.642
the Great Khan has

01:03:07.642 --> 01:03:08.382
figured out this

01:03:08.411 --> 01:03:09.292
art of alchemy.

01:03:09.581 --> 01:03:10.392
"I will demonstrate

01:03:10.392 --> 01:03:11.231
this to you here now.

01:03:11.231 --> 01:03:11.981
You must know that

01:03:11.981 --> 01:03:13.241
he's made money. His

01:03:13.252 --> 01:03:14.491
money made for him

01:03:14.721 --> 01:03:15.521
out of the bark of

01:03:15.532 --> 01:03:17.072
trees, from mulberry

01:03:17.072 --> 01:03:18.471
trees." And he is

01:03:18.471 --> 01:03:19.511
revealing one of

01:03:19.511 --> 01:03:22.051
those  secrets.

01:03:22.741 --> 01:03:23.371
"The same whose

01:03:23.371 --> 01:03:24.341
leaves furnish food

01:03:24.342 --> 01:03:25.401
for silkworms."

01:03:25.832 --> 01:03:26.491
Where silk came

01:03:26.491 --> 01:03:27.941
from was a secret.

01:03:27.952 --> 01:03:28.481
There was death

01:03:28.481 --> 01:03:29.631
penalty on revealing

01:03:29.632 --> 01:03:31.111
the secret, let

01:03:31.112 --> 01:03:32.361
alone smuggling

01:03:32.362 --> 01:03:34.111
out silk  worms.

01:03:34.151 --> 01:03:35.002
But all that did

01:03:35.002 --> 01:03:35.812
happen, and Marco

01:03:35.812 --> 01:03:36.781
Polo, after his

01:03:36.781 --> 01:03:37.191
twenty years,

01:03:37.191 --> 01:03:37.971
of course, also

01:03:38.481 --> 01:03:39.171
openly wrote

01:03:39.171 --> 01:03:41.092
about this secret.

01:03:42.351 --> 01:03:43.212
"The fine bark

01:03:43.212 --> 01:03:43.882
between the bark and

01:03:43.911 --> 01:03:45.001
the wood is stripped,

01:03:45.281 --> 01:03:46.172
crumbled, pounded,

01:03:46.172 --> 01:03:46.931
flattened with the

01:03:46.932 --> 01:03:48.371
aid of  glue into

01:03:48.371 --> 01:03:49.431
sheets like sheets

01:03:49.432 --> 01:03:50.271
of cotton paper,

01:03:50.272 --> 01:03:51.231
which are all black.

01:03:51.721 --> 01:03:52.381
When made, they're

01:03:52.382 --> 01:03:52.971
cut up into

01:03:53.171 --> 01:03:54.751
rectangles, sealed

01:03:54.752 --> 01:03:55.542
with a seal of

01:03:55.542 --> 01:03:56.181
the Great Khan.

01:03:56.182 --> 01:03:56.731
The procedure

01:03:56.731 --> 01:03:57.502
of issue is as

01:03:57.502 --> 01:03:58.721
formal as and as

01:03:58.752 --> 01:03:59.761
authoritative as if

01:03:59.761 --> 01:04:00.341
they were made of

01:04:00.352 --> 01:04:01.302
pure gold and silver.

01:04:01.721 --> 01:04:02.581
On each piece of

01:04:02.581 --> 01:04:03.351
money, several

01:04:04.102 --> 01:04:05.481
appointed officials

01:04:05.632 --> 01:04:06.802
write their names,

01:04:06.812 --> 01:04:08.322
setting their stamps.

01:04:08.592 --> 01:04:09.152
When completed and

01:04:09.152 --> 01:04:09.951
due formed, the chief

01:04:09.952 --> 01:04:10.552
of the officials

01:04:10.552 --> 01:04:11.522
deputed by the Khan

01:04:12.062 --> 01:04:13.072
dips in cinnabar

01:04:13.081 --> 01:04:14.041
the seal or bull

01:04:14.041 --> 01:04:14.682
assigned to him and

01:04:14.691 --> 01:04:15.491
stamps it on top of

01:04:15.492 --> 01:04:16.221
the piece of money,

01:04:16.852 --> 01:04:17.361
so that the shape of

01:04:17.382 --> 01:04:18.581
the seal in vermilion

01:04:19.001 --> 01:04:20.911
red remains impressed

01:04:20.911 --> 01:04:22.081
upon it, and then the

01:04:22.081 --> 01:04:23.352
money is authentic.

01:04:23.352 --> 01:04:24.092
And if anyone were

01:04:24.092 --> 01:04:25.012
to forge it, he would

01:04:25.012 --> 01:04:26.261
suffer the extreme

01:04:26.272 --> 01:04:27.131
penalty, the death

01:04:27.132 --> 01:04:29.714
penalty." Of this

01:04:29.714 --> 01:04:30.574
money, the khan has

01:04:30.574 --> 01:04:31.504
such a quantity made

01:04:31.504 --> 01:04:32.154
that with it he could

01:04:32.163 --> 01:04:32.964
buy all treasure

01:04:32.973 --> 01:04:33.504
in the world.

01:04:33.594 --> 01:04:34.243
Is this true?

01:04:35.203 --> 01:04:35.594
Basically,

01:04:35.594 --> 01:04:36.304
it was true.

01:04:37.614 --> 01:04:38.354
With this currency,

01:04:38.354 --> 01:04:38.933
he orders all

01:04:38.933 --> 01:04:39.463
payments to be

01:04:39.464 --> 01:04:39.953
made throughout

01:04:39.953 --> 01:04:40.683
every province and

01:04:40.683 --> 01:04:41.504
kingdom and region

01:04:41.504 --> 01:04:42.214
of his empire,

01:04:42.214 --> 01:04:43.124
and no one dares

01:04:43.124 --> 01:04:43.933
refuse it on pain

01:04:43.933 --> 01:04:44.814
of losing his life.

01:04:44.843 --> 01:04:45.513
And I assure you

01:04:45.513 --> 01:04:46.754
that all the peoples

01:04:46.754 --> 01:04:47.543
and populations who

01:04:47.544 --> 01:04:48.304
are subject to his

01:04:48.304 --> 01:04:49.243
rule, which was the

01:04:49.243 --> 01:04:50.843
biggest land empire

01:04:50.853 --> 01:04:52.873
in history, are

01:04:52.874 --> 01:04:54.054
perfectly willing to

01:04:54.054 --> 01:04:55.063
accept these papers

01:04:55.093 --> 01:04:56.084
in payment, since

01:04:56.103 --> 01:04:57.024
wherever they go,

01:04:57.343 --> 01:04:58.294
they pay in the same

01:04:58.294 --> 01:04:59.633
currency, whether for

01:04:59.634 --> 01:05:00.774
goods or for pearls

01:05:00.774 --> 01:05:01.423
or precious stones

01:05:01.424 --> 01:05:02.123
or gold or silver.

01:05:02.353 --> 01:05:02.924
With these pieces of

01:05:02.924 --> 01:05:03.793
paper, they can buy

01:05:03.794 --> 01:05:04.823
anything and pay for

01:05:04.823 --> 01:05:05.913
anything, and the

01:05:05.924 --> 01:05:07.433
army was paid in the

01:05:07.433 --> 01:05:08.733
same money as well.

01:05:09.114 --> 01:05:10.513
And the first open

01:05:10.573 --> 01:05:11.694
market operations

01:05:11.723 --> 01:05:12.573
were conducted.

01:05:12.864 --> 01:05:13.793
This is Kublai Khan.

01:05:13.803 --> 01:05:15.413
That is the paper

01:05:15.413 --> 01:05:18.473
money of  that era,

01:05:18.483 --> 01:05:20.113
and yes, it is black.

01:05:20.913 --> 01:05:21.783
And there's  the

01:05:21.783 --> 01:05:23.964
red  seals on it.

01:05:24.743 --> 01:05:25.133
These were the

01:05:25.134 --> 01:05:25.843
first open market

01:05:25.843 --> 01:05:26.343
operations.

01:05:26.353 --> 01:05:26.953
Several times a

01:05:26.953 --> 01:05:28.574
year, traders arrives

01:05:28.574 --> 01:05:29.133
with pearls and

01:05:29.134 --> 01:05:30.163
precious stones.

01:05:31.053 --> 01:05:31.713
And then you've got a

01:05:31.743 --> 01:05:33.814
procedure of experts

01:05:33.843 --> 01:05:34.763
evaluating the

01:05:34.764 --> 01:05:36.264
value, and then they

01:05:36.264 --> 01:05:37.303
receive paper money.

01:05:37.593 --> 01:05:38.033
The trade is

01:05:38.033 --> 01:05:39.114
accepted willingly

01:05:39.154 --> 01:05:39.703
because they can

01:05:39.703 --> 01:05:40.703
spend it afterwards

01:05:41.044 --> 01:05:41.563
on the various

01:05:41.563 --> 01:05:42.154
goods they buy.

01:05:42.353 --> 01:05:42.723
But there was

01:05:42.733 --> 01:05:44.643
also a fiat.

01:05:44.893 --> 01:05:45.673
Several times a year,

01:05:45.973 --> 01:05:46.743
a fiat goes forth

01:05:46.753 --> 01:05:47.513
through the towns

01:05:47.794 --> 01:05:48.523
that all those who

01:05:48.523 --> 01:05:50.274
have gold, silver,

01:05:50.283 --> 01:05:51.673
gems, pearls must

01:05:51.673 --> 01:05:52.303
bring them to the

01:05:52.303 --> 01:05:54.293
Great Khan's mint.

01:05:54.294 --> 01:05:55.014
You had to hand

01:05:55.023 --> 01:05:55.884
over your gold.

01:05:56.764 --> 01:05:57.574
This they do in such

01:05:57.574 --> 01:05:58.643
abundance, it's past

01:05:58.654 --> 01:05:59.513
all reckoning, and

01:05:59.514 --> 01:06:00.013
they're all paid

01:06:00.014 --> 01:06:00.893
in paper money.

01:06:01.643 --> 01:06:02.323
By this means, the

01:06:02.323 --> 01:06:03.103
Great Khan acquires

01:06:03.123 --> 01:06:03.683
all the gold and

01:06:03.683 --> 01:06:04.273
silver and pearls and

01:06:04.273 --> 01:06:04.973
precious stones of

01:06:05.033 --> 01:06:06.133
all his territories,

01:06:06.133 --> 01:06:06.864
and all the khan's

01:06:06.904 --> 01:06:07.723
armies are paid with

01:06:07.733 --> 01:06:08.493
this sort of money.

01:06:09.123 --> 01:06:09.963
I've now told you

01:06:09.963 --> 01:06:10.643
how it comes about

01:06:10.643 --> 01:06:11.693
that Great Khan must

01:06:11.693 --> 01:06:12.563
have, as indeed he

01:06:12.563 --> 01:06:13.553
has, more treasure

01:06:13.573 --> 01:06:14.923
than anyone else in

01:06:14.923 --> 01:06:17.538
the world Now this

01:06:17.598 --> 01:06:20.218
so impressed  some of

01:06:20.248 --> 01:06:21.278
the readers of Marco

01:06:21.278 --> 01:06:23.468
Polo's book that they

01:06:23.468 --> 01:06:24.598
thought, "We have to

01:06:24.598 --> 01:06:25.958
do this. We have to

01:06:25.958 --> 01:06:27.827
copy this."  you'd

01:06:27.838 --> 01:06:28.848
think, oh, okay,

01:06:28.848 --> 01:06:29.617
the Great Khan, the

01:06:29.618 --> 01:06:30.438
Kublai Khan, the Khan

01:06:30.438 --> 01:06:31.297
of Khans could do

01:06:31.297 --> 01:06:32.258
this in China, but

01:06:32.698 --> 01:06:33.538
nowadays you couldn't

01:06:33.538 --> 01:06:34.358
do these things.

01:06:38.788 --> 01:06:40.667
1st of May 1933,

01:06:41.227 --> 01:06:41.977
presidential

01:06:41.977 --> 01:06:43.117
executive order

01:06:43.188 --> 01:06:44.188
issued in the United

01:06:44.188 --> 01:06:45.287
States of America…

01:06:45.938 --> 01:06:46.718
Actually, 5th of

01:06:46.718 --> 01:06:48.048
April, and that was

01:06:48.048 --> 01:06:49.848
the deadline, May 1.

01:06:50.788 --> 01:06:51.478
So issued on the

01:06:51.488 --> 01:06:52.477
5th of April.

01:06:53.617 --> 01:06:55.897
Everyone resident in

01:06:55.898 --> 01:06:57.887
America, foreigners,

01:06:57.898 --> 01:06:59.808
firms, individuals

01:07:00.328 --> 01:07:01.617
who owned gold coin

01:07:01.628 --> 01:07:03.417
or gold bullion had

01:07:03.507 --> 01:07:04.547
to hand it over to

01:07:04.547 --> 01:07:05.528
the privately owned

01:07:05.528 --> 01:07:06.738
Federal Reserve banks

01:07:08.038 --> 01:07:12.607
at a fixed low  price

01:07:12.628 --> 01:07:15.348
of $20 per ounce.

01:07:16.257 --> 01:07:17.407
And where are we now?

01:07:18.788 --> 01:07:20.048
More than 20

01:07:20.048 --> 01:07:21.038
times more.

01:07:21.118 --> 01:07:21.448
Yeah.

01:07:21.907 --> 01:07:23.978
Four-    we're

01:07:23.978 --> 01:07:27.168
at 4,400, so wow.

01:07:28.227 --> 01:07:28.997
And at the threat of

01:07:29.027 --> 01:07:29.948
10 years in prison.

01:07:30.407 --> 01:07:31.337
So yeah, more

01:07:31.337 --> 01:07:32.697
than 200 times.

01:07:34.977 --> 01:07:35.847
And of course, soon

01:07:35.898 --> 01:07:38.657
after, the gold

01:07:38.657 --> 01:07:39.867
price was raised just

01:07:40.618 --> 01:07:41.327
actually the end of

01:07:41.328 --> 01:07:44.337
the same year to 34.

01:07:44.377 --> 01:07:45.018
That's what?

01:07:45.018 --> 01:07:47.387
65% increase.

01:07:47.777 --> 01:07:48.317
And of course

01:07:48.328 --> 01:07:50.367
now, yeah, 4,500.

01:07:50.367 --> 01:07:51.137
So it wasn't a

01:07:51.137 --> 01:07:52.057
good deal for those

01:07:52.097 --> 01:07:53.608
who followed this

01:07:53.627 --> 01:07:55.227
executive order, but

01:07:55.227 --> 01:07:56.267
you had to follow it.

01:07:57.938 --> 01:07:58.407
That's in the

01:07:58.407 --> 01:07:59.337
land of the free.

01:08:02.847 --> 01:08:03.457
So yes, it

01:08:03.457 --> 01:08:03.927
can happen.

01:08:03.937 --> 01:08:04.727
It does happen.

01:08:05.987 --> 01:08:07.037
Now this paper money,

01:08:07.038 --> 01:08:07.758
of course, was a

01:08:07.767 --> 01:08:08.687
clever invention.

01:08:10.108 --> 01:08:10.858
It wasn't invented

01:08:10.858 --> 01:08:11.388
by the Mongols.

01:08:11.388 --> 01:08:11.867
The Mongols were

01:08:11.867 --> 01:08:12.997
very good at seeing

01:08:13.038 --> 01:08:14.177
interesting ideas and

01:08:14.177 --> 01:08:15.177
technology and always

01:08:15.187 --> 01:08:17.517
utilizing it  putting

01:08:17.517 --> 01:08:18.427
it to good purpose.

01:08:18.858 --> 01:08:19.637
It came about

01:08:19.637 --> 01:08:20.697
first in the Song

01:08:20.697 --> 01:08:22.167
Dynasty in the 10th

01:08:22.167 --> 01:08:23.557
century, possibly

01:08:23.557 --> 01:08:24.637
ninth century Tang

01:08:24.637 --> 01:08:26.287
Dynasty, but we have

01:08:26.368 --> 01:08:27.507
worse records there.

01:08:28.398 --> 01:08:29.537
And of course, later,

01:08:30.308 --> 01:08:31.457
Chinese paper money.

01:08:32.957 --> 01:08:34.238
By the way, under

01:08:34.238 --> 01:08:35.568
the Chinese paper

01:08:35.568 --> 01:08:36.307
money system, say

01:08:36.308 --> 01:08:37.337
under Kublai Khan,

01:08:37.577 --> 01:08:38.307
what do you think was

01:08:38.308 --> 01:08:39.517
the national debt?

01:08:41.652 --> 01:08:43.932
Of the Mongol/Chinese

01:08:43.932 --> 01:08:44.652
Empire?

01:08:45.762 --> 01:08:45.902
Zero.

01:08:47.102 --> 01:08:47.652
Zero.

01:08:48.552 --> 01:08:49.322
If you work for

01:08:49.322 --> 01:08:50.032
Goldman Sachs

01:08:50.032 --> 01:08:50.642
and they sent you

01:08:50.642 --> 01:08:51.852
to Kublai Khan

01:08:52.272 --> 01:08:53.122
to do some debt

01:08:53.132 --> 01:08:54.742
origination- … it

01:08:54.742 --> 01:08:55.641
would be a very

01:08:55.641 --> 01:08:56.422
tough sale.

01:08:57.842 --> 01:08:58.481
Very tough sale.

01:09:00.272 --> 01:09:00.882
My recommendation

01:09:00.882 --> 01:09:01.651
would be make sure

01:09:01.652 --> 01:09:02.592
you meet the Great

01:09:02.592 --> 01:09:03.831
Khan after lunch.

01:09:04.842 --> 01:09:05.872
Not before lunch.

01:09:06.382 --> 01:09:07.072
Before lunch, he

01:09:07.072 --> 01:09:07.722
could be a bit

01:09:08.201 --> 01:09:10.102
hypoglycemic and-  a

01:09:10.102 --> 01:09:11.141
bit short-tempered,

01:09:12.041 --> 01:09:12.772
which could be

01:09:13.002 --> 01:09:13.861
life-threatening.

01:09:14.471 --> 01:09:15.101
After lunch,

01:09:15.102 --> 01:09:15.592
he's usually

01:09:15.592 --> 01:09:16.321
in a good mood.

01:09:17.312 --> 01:09:18.301
He enjoyed his lunch.

01:09:18.861 --> 01:09:19.661
And so if you then

01:09:19.681 --> 01:09:20.551
pitch to him after

01:09:20.551 --> 01:09:21.501
lunch and say,

01:09:22.681 --> 01:09:24.021
" Great Khan, thank

01:09:24.021 --> 01:09:24.681
you for seeing me

01:09:25.391 --> 01:09:26.252
from Goldman Sachs.

01:09:26.512 --> 01:09:28.582
We'll help you  raise

01:09:28.591 --> 01:09:30.752
some money." " oh,

01:09:30.832 --> 01:09:31.582
tell me more.

01:09:33.012 --> 01:09:33.762
Raise some money.

01:09:33.762 --> 01:09:34.691
What do you mean?"

01:09:35.521 --> 01:09:37.491
"  we'll  we'll issue

01:09:37.492 --> 01:09:38.571
some bonds for you.

01:09:39.021 --> 01:09:39.671
They'll be issued

01:09:39.672 --> 01:09:40.681
by your government,

01:09:42.152 --> 01:09:43.112
and this way you

01:09:43.112 --> 01:09:43.962
get lots of money."

01:09:45.601 --> 01:09:46.622
" actually, I've

01:09:46.622 --> 01:09:47.561
got lots of money.

01:09:50.041 --> 01:09:50.661
Why do you need

01:09:50.662 --> 01:09:51.831
this?" " with this

01:09:51.832 --> 01:09:52.752
money, you can go

01:09:52.752 --> 01:09:54.082
and spend, and buy,

01:09:54.391 --> 01:09:55.412
and raise armies

01:09:55.412 --> 01:09:56.892
and…" "I'm doing

01:09:56.892 --> 01:09:57.701
all that already."

01:09:58.212 --> 01:09:58.761
" But also it would

01:09:58.781 --> 01:10:00.111
be  very cheap."

01:10:00.721 --> 01:10:01.371
" wh- what do you

01:10:01.372 --> 01:10:02.651
mean cheap?" " we

01:10:02.652 --> 01:10:03.681
can get the best

01:10:03.692 --> 01:10:04.471
interest rate for

01:10:04.471 --> 01:10:05.961
you." "Interest rate?

01:10:06.192 --> 01:10:06.782
What do you mean?"

01:10:09.381 --> 01:10:10.232
"    obviously, when you

01:10:10.302 --> 01:10:11.191
issue these bonds

01:10:11.192 --> 01:10:11.901
and you're borrowing

01:10:11.902 --> 01:10:12.341
money from…"

01:10:12.721 --> 01:10:14.061
"Borrowing money?

01:10:15.841 --> 01:10:16.541
This is where it gets

01:10:16.541 --> 01:10:17.341
slightly critical.

01:10:17.741 --> 01:10:19.081
Are you suggesting

01:10:19.711 --> 01:10:20.901
that I, the Khan

01:10:20.902 --> 01:10:21.761
of Khans, the Great

01:10:21.762 --> 01:10:23.152
Khan, should borrow

01:10:23.152 --> 01:10:24.721
from anyone else?"

01:10:26.111 --> 01:10:28.291
"   Great Khan     it's

01:10:28.291 --> 01:10:28.961
gonna be such a

01:10:28.961 --> 01:10:29.762
low interest rate."

01:10:30.211 --> 01:10:30.851
"What is this thing

01:10:30.861 --> 01:10:31.582
about interest

01:10:31.582 --> 01:10:32.981
rate?" "   you have

01:10:32.981 --> 01:10:35.181
to pa-" "Have to pay?

01:10:35.421 --> 01:10:36.611
The Great Khan

01:10:36.872 --> 01:10:38.181
would have to pay

01:10:38.181 --> 01:10:39.581
somebody, borrow

01:10:39.582 --> 01:10:40.261
from some…" This

01:10:40.262 --> 01:10:41.042
is where it helps

01:10:41.042 --> 01:10:42.232
that he's had lunch,

01:10:42.252 --> 01:10:44.552
and he breaks out

01:10:44.552 --> 01:10:45.461
into great laughter.

01:10:46.391 --> 01:10:47.232
Appoint him

01:10:47.271 --> 01:10:49.071
court jester.

01:10:49.891 --> 01:10:50.711
I've never heard

01:10:50.711 --> 01:10:51.591
such a great

01:10:52.412 --> 01:10:55.172
joke ever before.

01:10:55.172 --> 01:10:56.101
The Great Khan

01:10:56.132 --> 01:10:57.352
borrows money from

01:10:57.371 --> 01:10:58.212
others and pays

01:10:58.212 --> 01:11:01.316
interest Totally

01:11:02.326 --> 01:11:03.616
ludicrous idea.

01:11:04.986 --> 01:11:05.675
But of course, if

01:11:05.675 --> 01:11:06.175
he's not in such

01:11:06.175 --> 01:11:06.925
a great mood,

01:11:06.925 --> 01:11:07.566
then you leave

01:11:07.566 --> 01:11:08.255
without your head.

01:11:08.255 --> 01:11:09.196
So it was a

01:11:09.196 --> 01:11:09.606
hard sell.

01:11:09.956 --> 01:11:10.496
There was no

01:11:10.496 --> 01:11:11.326
national debt.

01:11:11.995 --> 01:11:13.056
Why should there be?

01:11:13.385 --> 01:11:14.115
Why should there

01:11:14.115 --> 01:11:14.915
be national debt?

01:11:15.686 --> 01:11:16.366
But of course, now

01:11:16.366 --> 01:11:17.216
if you look at the,

01:11:17.266 --> 01:11:18.285
the debt clock,

01:11:18.555 --> 01:11:19.535
this was already

01:11:19.536 --> 01:11:20.315
quite a while ago.

01:11:20.315 --> 01:11:20.905
We only had

01:11:20.905 --> 01:11:22.235
33 trillion.

01:11:23.255 --> 01:11:26.005
We're way up at 36

01:11:26.016 --> 01:11:26.715
trillion, but going

01:11:26.715 --> 01:11:28.505
to 30…  Heading

01:11:28.505 --> 01:11:29.656
to 40 trillion.

01:11:30.175 --> 01:11:30.775
Not far.

01:11:30.965 --> 01:11:31.885
And actually, the

01:11:31.895 --> 01:11:32.935
time it takes now

01:11:32.936 --> 01:11:33.476
to add another

01:11:33.476 --> 01:11:35.435
trillion, it  used

01:11:35.436 --> 01:11:37.325
to be decades, then

01:11:37.325 --> 01:11:38.566
it became years.

01:11:39.055 --> 01:11:40.206
It's now months.

01:11:40.555 --> 01:11:41.115
But soon it will

01:11:41.125 --> 01:11:42.486
be weeks, and then

01:11:42.486 --> 01:11:43.475
it will be days.

01:11:43.535 --> 01:11:45.596
We are on this very

01:11:46.386 --> 01:11:47.936
vertical exponential

01:11:47.936 --> 01:11:48.675
trajectory.

01:11:51.715 --> 01:11:52.215
Which is very

01:11:52.215 --> 01:11:52.975
strange, isn't it?

01:11:53.075 --> 01:11:53.775
Compared to, in

01:11:53.776 --> 01:11:56.045
contrast to  the

01:11:56.046 --> 01:11:56.936
Mongol Chinese

01:11:56.936 --> 01:11:57.855
system, where there's

01:11:57.855 --> 01:11:58.755
no government debt.

01:11:58.765 --> 01:11:59.425
The government

01:11:59.545 --> 01:12:01.135
was in charge,

01:12:01.295 --> 01:12:02.095
and if you manage

01:12:02.096 --> 01:12:03.026
the system well

01:12:05.105 --> 01:12:06.625
you'd have no fiscal

01:12:06.625 --> 01:12:08.415
deficit, and low

01:12:08.415 --> 01:12:09.885
taxes, and high

01:12:09.885 --> 01:12:10.685
economic growth.

01:12:10.686 --> 01:12:11.675
It's all possible.

01:12:13.086 --> 01:12:13.956
But before we

01:12:13.995 --> 01:12:14.485
talk about this

01:12:14.485 --> 01:12:14.925
possibility, and

01:12:14.936 --> 01:12:15.845
we'll talk more about

01:12:15.845 --> 01:12:18.945
that  tomorrow, let's

01:12:18.945 --> 01:12:20.736
now accompany Marco

01:12:20.736 --> 01:12:22.105
Polo back to Europe.

01:12:22.105 --> 01:12:22.835
So  he's made

01:12:22.836 --> 01:12:24.625
it back, and he

01:12:24.625 --> 01:12:25.405
arrives in Europe.

01:12:25.406 --> 01:12:26.025
He gets out of

01:12:26.025 --> 01:12:26.936
prison in Genoa.

01:12:26.945 --> 01:12:27.875
He comes back to

01:12:27.875 --> 01:12:31.193
Venice And he thinks

01:12:31.193 --> 01:12:31.834
a bit about the

01:12:31.844 --> 01:12:32.714
monetary system.

01:12:32.714 --> 01:12:33.994
He was a, a trader,

01:12:34.023 --> 01:12:35.204
so he… And in his

01:12:35.204 --> 01:12:36.063
book, it's clear

01:12:36.063 --> 01:12:36.624
what's written

01:12:36.624 --> 01:12:37.754
by the novelist.

01:12:37.773 --> 01:12:39.063
When the sun rises

01:12:41.053 --> 01:12:41.834
coloring this-

01:12:41.864 --> 01:12:43.054
the city skyline

01:12:43.063 --> 01:12:45.193
in, in, in red.

01:12:46.114 --> 01:12:46.834
But he would always

01:12:46.834 --> 01:12:47.703
be very factual.

01:12:47.913 --> 01:12:48.693
In this town,

01:12:48.703 --> 01:12:49.463
they would import

01:12:49.463 --> 01:12:50.204
this, they would

01:12:50.434 --> 01:12:51.114
manufacture

01:12:51.114 --> 01:12:51.523
this, they would

01:12:51.523 --> 01:12:52.563
export this.

01:12:54.404 --> 01:12:55.013
So he would be

01:12:55.014 --> 01:12:55.874
thinking about these

01:12:55.874 --> 01:12:57.264
things, and what

01:12:57.264 --> 01:12:58.523
was money in Europe?

01:12:58.523 --> 01:12:59.023
Of course, in

01:12:59.023 --> 01:13:00.993
Europe, the rulers

01:13:01.004 --> 01:13:02.123
thought gold and

01:13:02.123 --> 01:13:03.203
silver is money.

01:13:05.684 --> 01:13:06.313
And that's why they

01:13:06.313 --> 01:13:07.434
spent these resources

01:13:07.434 --> 01:13:08.713
on alchemy, trying to

01:13:09.213 --> 01:13:11.244
make gold, which was

01:13:12.074 --> 01:13:13.663
ultimately a failure.

01:13:13.673 --> 01:13:14.693
Although, for some

01:13:14.693 --> 01:13:15.223
strange reason,

01:13:15.223 --> 01:13:15.833
the alchemists

01:13:15.864 --> 01:13:17.653
concluded we can turn

01:13:17.653 --> 01:13:18.603
mercury into gold.

01:13:18.614 --> 01:13:19.173
They just didn't

01:13:19.173 --> 01:13:19.884
quite succeed.

01:13:20.364 --> 01:13:21.303
We can now do it,

01:13:21.303 --> 01:13:22.204
and they were right.

01:13:22.483 --> 01:13:23.483
In nuclear physics,

01:13:23.493 --> 01:13:24.154
it can be done.

01:13:24.563 --> 01:13:25.213
Mercury can be

01:13:25.213 --> 01:13:25.714
turned to gold.

01:13:25.733 --> 01:13:27.323
It's just expensive

01:13:27.893 --> 01:13:29.273
and still not

01:13:29.283 --> 01:13:30.093
quite worth it.

01:13:30.094 --> 01:13:31.063
It may soon become

01:13:31.063 --> 01:13:32.653
worth it, but it's

01:13:32.653 --> 01:13:33.363
not yet worth it.

01:13:34.603 --> 01:13:37.724
So what happened?

01:13:38.483 --> 01:13:39.364
You'd think, okay,

01:13:39.364 --> 01:13:39.943
then nobody's

01:13:39.943 --> 01:13:40.513
in charge of the

01:13:40.513 --> 01:13:41.213
money supply.

01:13:41.213 --> 01:13:42.314
It's whatever gold

01:13:42.314 --> 01:13:43.383
is being extracted

01:13:43.384 --> 01:13:44.174
from some mine,

01:13:44.174 --> 01:13:44.873
who g- whoever

01:13:44.873 --> 01:13:45.923
gets lucky and owns

01:13:45.923 --> 01:13:46.613
the land, and so

01:13:46.623 --> 01:13:47.453
on, or government

01:13:47.454 --> 01:13:48.084
concession.

01:13:48.553 --> 01:13:48.903
Government

01:13:48.903 --> 01:13:49.533
gets a share.

01:13:50.503 --> 01:13:51.363
Is that how it works?

01:13:51.363 --> 01:13:52.143
Is that how the money

01:13:52.143 --> 01:13:53.143
supply is determined?

01:13:53.564 --> 01:13:54.084
No.

01:13:54.583 --> 01:13:55.103
That's not

01:13:55.103 --> 01:13:55.703
what happened.

01:13:56.653 --> 01:13:58.883
First of all, people

01:13:58.893 --> 01:13:59.983
didn't wanna carry

01:13:59.983 --> 01:14:00.894
gold and silver

01:14:00.894 --> 01:14:01.823
with them on their

01:14:01.833 --> 01:14:03.123
bodies, and you

01:14:03.123 --> 01:14:04.134
can understand

01:14:04.134 --> 01:14:05.813
that because if

01:14:05.814 --> 01:14:06.343
you walk around

01:14:06.344 --> 01:14:08.153
in central Milan

01:14:11.164 --> 01:14:11.843
at night, let's

01:14:11.844 --> 01:14:12.604
say, you wouldn't

01:14:12.604 --> 01:14:13.403
wanna have too

01:14:13.403 --> 01:14:14.873
much gold hanging

01:14:15.173 --> 01:14:16.333
on you or carried

01:14:17.244 --> 01:14:18.603
in, in, in bags.

01:14:18.993 --> 01:14:19.423
And the same is

01:14:19.423 --> 01:14:21.493
true of major cities

01:14:21.493 --> 01:14:22.434
in Europe today.

01:14:22.473 --> 01:14:24.193
London, everyone

01:14:24.193 --> 01:14:24.633
would advise you,

01:14:24.643 --> 01:14:26.024
"No  don't carry

01:14:26.033 --> 01:14:27.023
gold in central

01:14:27.024 --> 01:14:28.154
London."  it's

01:14:28.443 --> 01:14:29.333
not a good idea.

01:14:29.664 --> 01:14:30.723
Berlin  it's

01:14:30.723 --> 01:14:31.193
all the same.

01:14:31.383 --> 01:14:32.304
And this is 21st

01:14:32.323 --> 01:14:32.873
century, right?

01:14:32.873 --> 01:14:33.833
So imagine in the

01:14:33.833 --> 01:14:36.543
13th century  it must

01:14:36.543 --> 01:14:37.373
have been somewhat

01:14:37.373 --> 01:14:39.133
worse, or who knows?

01:14:40.193 --> 01:14:41.434
Anyway, people

01:14:41.443 --> 01:14:43.274
decided usually to

01:14:43.293 --> 01:14:44.263
keep the gold in a

01:14:44.263 --> 01:14:45.773
safe place, but where

01:14:45.783 --> 01:14:46.904
is the safe place?

01:14:47.203 --> 01:14:48.153
What is a safe place?

01:14:48.594 --> 01:14:49.363
A safe place is

01:14:49.363 --> 01:14:51.194
where somebody

01:14:51.274 --> 01:14:52.364
already has enough

01:14:52.364 --> 01:14:52.823
gold, they're not

01:14:52.824 --> 01:14:53.594
gonna steal it from

01:14:53.594 --> 01:14:54.423
you, and they have

01:14:54.723 --> 01:14:55.663
made precautions.

01:14:55.664 --> 01:14:57.054
They have  a little

01:14:57.054 --> 01:14:57.893
private army.

01:14:58.643 --> 01:14:59.653
They have a safe

01:15:00.324 --> 01:15:01.493
place for the

01:15:01.494 --> 01:15:03.063
gold, and they're

01:15:03.063 --> 01:15:03.853
gonna protect it.

01:15:03.863 --> 01:15:04.783
And these were people

01:15:04.783 --> 01:15:05.443
that worked with

01:15:05.443 --> 01:15:07.034
gold, that make gold

01:15:07.034 --> 01:15:08.213
jewelry for the rich,

01:15:08.223 --> 01:15:09.314
for the aristocrats

01:15:10.798 --> 01:15:11.808
So goldsmiths.

01:15:12.918 --> 01:15:13.987
So people came to

01:15:13.987 --> 01:15:14.858
deposit their gold

01:15:14.858 --> 01:15:15.628
with a goldsmith,

01:15:16.688 --> 01:15:17.518
and that's fine.

01:15:17.858 --> 01:15:18.788
Trustworthy.

01:15:19.577 --> 01:15:20.768
You pay a small fee,

01:15:21.477 --> 01:15:22.228
but of course, you do

01:15:22.228 --> 01:15:23.558
need a record, right?

01:15:23.958 --> 01:15:24.337
Because the

01:15:24.338 --> 01:15:26.058
goldsmith could die.

01:15:26.367 --> 01:15:27.148
His brother takes

01:15:27.148 --> 01:15:27.968
over, his son takes

01:15:27.968 --> 01:15:28.527
over, and they say,

01:15:28.718 --> 01:15:29.558
" we don't know anyb-

01:15:29.638 --> 01:15:30.318
anything about your

01:15:30.318 --> 01:15:31.768
deposits." That

01:15:31.768 --> 01:15:32.498
wouldn't be good,

01:15:32.747 --> 01:15:33.367
and of course, people

01:15:33.367 --> 01:15:33.928
were thinking about

01:15:33.928 --> 01:15:34.378
these possibilities,

01:15:34.388 --> 01:15:35.718
so you get a receipt,

01:15:36.337 --> 01:15:37.737
a deposit receipt,

01:15:38.558 --> 01:15:39.567
and this is where

01:15:41.686 --> 01:15:43.066
Our modern system

01:15:43.066 --> 01:15:44.005
really started.

01:15:44.635 --> 01:15:45.606
First, the goldsmiths

01:15:45.616 --> 01:15:47.166
realized  we've

01:15:47.166 --> 01:15:47.585
got all this

01:15:47.606 --> 01:15:48.465
gold, but people

01:15:49.366 --> 01:15:50.206
are not actually

01:15:50.356 --> 01:15:51.185
c- collecting it

01:15:51.196 --> 01:15:52.125
because they prefer

01:15:52.125 --> 01:15:53.045
to keep it there,

01:15:53.986 --> 01:15:54.775
and ultimately they

01:15:54.776 --> 01:15:55.906
prefer to pay in the

01:15:55.906 --> 01:15:57.076
deposit receipts.

01:15:57.785 --> 01:15:58.266
Because what's

01:15:58.266 --> 01:15:58.666
the point?

01:15:58.675 --> 01:15:59.255
Let's say we're

01:15:59.255 --> 01:16:00.235
neighbors, and I buy

01:16:00.236 --> 01:16:01.155
some land from you.

01:16:01.375 --> 01:16:02.446
We agree how

01:16:02.446 --> 01:16:03.016
much it is.

01:16:03.016 --> 01:16:04.316
Okay, now comes

01:16:04.316 --> 01:16:04.946
the payment.

01:16:05.435 --> 01:16:06.156
I've got my gold

01:16:06.156 --> 01:16:06.725
with the goldsmith

01:16:06.726 --> 01:16:07.385
in the city.

01:16:08.326 --> 01:16:08.865
Do you want me to

01:16:08.875 --> 01:16:09.745
go to the city?

01:16:09.745 --> 01:16:10.405
I get the gold.

01:16:10.406 --> 01:16:10.936
What are you gonna

01:16:10.945 --> 01:16:11.606
do with the gold?

01:16:11.606 --> 01:16:12.105
Are you gonna

01:16:12.175 --> 01:16:13.305
put it back with

01:16:13.306 --> 01:16:13.675
a goldsmith?

01:16:14.315 --> 01:16:15.456
We'd risk our lives

01:16:15.495 --> 01:16:16.375
twice, and the

01:16:16.375 --> 01:16:17.116
gold, obviously

01:16:17.896 --> 01:16:18.826
doing this.

01:16:19.635 --> 01:16:20.615
Why don't I give you

01:16:20.625 --> 01:16:22.065
my deposit receipt?

01:16:23.275 --> 01:16:24.215
I can even sign

01:16:24.215 --> 01:16:24.936
it if you want,

01:16:24.945 --> 01:16:25.375
you know that

01:16:25.375 --> 01:16:26.415
this is yours now.

01:16:27.155 --> 01:16:27.486
And this is

01:16:27.486 --> 01:16:27.975
what happens.

01:16:27.986 --> 01:16:28.645
So people use the

01:16:28.646 --> 01:16:29.655
deposit receipts

01:16:29.655 --> 01:16:30.425
as money, and the

01:16:30.996 --> 01:16:32.266
deposited gold stayed

01:16:32.266 --> 01:16:33.095
with the goldsmith.

01:16:34.815 --> 01:16:35.905
And the goldsmiths,

01:16:36.245 --> 01:16:37.305
they weren't dumb.

01:16:37.625 --> 01:16:38.666
Like any trade, they

01:16:38.685 --> 01:16:40.525
had their regular

01:16:40.525 --> 01:16:42.596
meeting, maybe on

01:16:42.596 --> 01:16:44.285
Sundays after church.

01:16:45.556 --> 01:16:46.515
All the trades would

01:16:46.515 --> 01:16:48.385
meet and talk shop.

01:16:50.006 --> 01:16:50.665
And the goldsmiths

01:16:50.665 --> 01:16:51.045
would discover

01:16:51.146 --> 01:16:51.746
nobody's picking

01:16:51.746 --> 01:16:52.605
up this gold.

01:16:53.805 --> 01:16:54.596
While at the same

01:16:54.596 --> 01:16:55.045
time, everyone

01:16:55.046 --> 01:16:55.565
knows they've

01:16:55.565 --> 01:16:56.375
got all the gold.

01:16:56.375 --> 01:16:56.966
Where's the money?

01:16:56.966 --> 01:16:57.325
It's with the

01:16:57.665 --> 01:16:58.085
goldsmiths.

01:16:58.565 --> 01:16:59.275
I need some money.

01:16:59.425 --> 01:16:59.926
I'm gonna ask

01:17:00.445 --> 01:17:00.545
the goldsmith to

01:17:00.546 --> 01:17:01.436
borrow some money.

01:17:02.465 --> 01:17:03.285
So they got a lot of

01:17:03.285 --> 01:17:04.476
requests from people

01:17:05.125 --> 01:17:06.565
to lend them money.

01:17:07.955 --> 01:17:08.246
Now, there

01:17:08.246 --> 01:17:09.275
was a catch.

01:17:09.756 --> 01:17:10.965
In Europe until

01:17:11.055 --> 01:17:12.006
three hundred and

01:17:13.135 --> 01:17:14.236
eighty years ago,

01:17:14.705 --> 01:17:15.515
everywhere in Europe,

01:17:15.535 --> 01:17:16.395
it was illegal to

01:17:16.396 --> 01:17:17.415
charge interest.

01:17:17.855 --> 01:17:18.495
It was illegal

01:17:18.495 --> 01:17:19.055
everywhere.

01:17:20.205 --> 01:17:20.575
Why?

01:17:20.635 --> 01:17:21.016
Because the

01:17:21.016 --> 01:17:21.835
Bible says so

01:17:23.928 --> 01:17:24.768
And the church

01:17:26.748 --> 01:17:27.588
mostly saw it

01:17:27.598 --> 01:17:28.438
the same way

01:17:29.388 --> 01:17:30.117
at that time.

01:17:31.987 --> 01:17:33.718
So well, these people

01:17:33.718 --> 01:17:35.117
were saying, " okay

01:17:35.947 --> 01:17:37.007
we know that it's

01:17:37.008 --> 01:17:37.797
not allowed, but

01:17:38.767 --> 01:17:39.938
I'm happy to pay

01:17:39.938 --> 01:17:41.188
you interest, and

01:17:41.188 --> 01:17:42.367
we keep it secret."

01:17:43.348 --> 01:17:43.987
This is-- These are

01:17:43.987 --> 01:17:44.977
the offers that the

01:17:44.977 --> 01:17:45.598
goldsmiths received,

01:17:47.338 --> 01:17:48.268
and so they started

01:17:48.268 --> 01:17:49.587
to lend out some

01:17:49.588 --> 01:17:50.588
of their gold.

01:17:51.758 --> 01:17:52.717
It was very tempting,

01:17:52.717 --> 01:17:53.537
but human nature

01:17:53.547 --> 01:17:56.117
is usually  people-

01:17:56.208 --> 01:17:57.727
very few people  can

01:17:57.727 --> 01:18:00.297
handle temptations,

01:18:01.438 --> 01:18:02.038
particularly when

01:18:02.038 --> 01:18:02.557
you think you can

01:18:02.557 --> 01:18:03.197
get away with it.

01:18:03.208 --> 01:18:04.538
This is agreed to

01:18:04.538 --> 01:18:05.817
be kept secret.

01:18:07.418 --> 01:18:07.947
And some of the

01:18:07.947 --> 01:18:08.807
gold was really

01:18:08.817 --> 01:18:10.238
standardized bullion,

01:18:11.168 --> 01:18:12.747
so it didn't matter

01:18:12.747 --> 01:18:13.967
whether  if somebody

01:18:14.067 --> 01:18:14.748
wanted their gold

01:18:14.767 --> 01:18:16.157
back, exactly what

01:18:16.237 --> 01:18:17.057
gold you return,

01:18:17.057 --> 01:18:17.537
as long as it was

01:18:17.577 --> 01:18:19.488
the same purity and

01:18:19.488 --> 01:18:20.337
weight and looked

01:18:20.337 --> 01:18:21.867
like  similar shape

01:18:21.867 --> 01:18:22.727
or the same shape.

01:18:23.447 --> 01:18:24.168
It was fine.

01:18:25.887 --> 01:18:27.047
So it was practically

01:18:27.057 --> 01:18:28.008
possible, and the

01:18:28.008 --> 01:18:28.797
temptation was

01:18:28.797 --> 01:18:29.267
there, so they

01:18:29.267 --> 01:18:30.468
started to do this.

01:18:31.958 --> 01:18:32.457
But that was, of

01:18:32.458 --> 01:18:32.947
course, a breach

01:18:32.947 --> 01:18:33.457
of contract.

01:18:33.458 --> 01:18:33.708
It's supposed

01:18:33.708 --> 01:18:34.337
to be deposited

01:18:34.337 --> 01:18:35.228
with a goldsmith.

01:18:35.967 --> 01:18:37.167
Secondly  it's a

01:18:37.168 --> 01:18:37.897
new business model.

01:18:37.897 --> 01:18:38.327
The goldsmiths

01:18:38.337 --> 01:18:39.037
realized, "Wow,

01:18:39.037 --> 01:18:39.637
this is actually

01:18:39.638 --> 01:18:40.207
quite an attractive

01:18:40.248 --> 01:18:40.777
business model.

01:18:40.778 --> 01:18:41.727
This interest

01:18:42.757 --> 01:18:43.958
is compounding

01:18:43.987 --> 01:18:44.857
over time.

01:18:44.857 --> 01:18:45.277
We don't even

01:18:45.297 --> 01:18:46.137
have to work.

01:18:46.627 --> 01:18:47.528
We just sit back,

01:18:47.568 --> 01:18:48.557
twiddle our thumbs,

01:18:49.017 --> 01:18:50.407
and as time passes,

01:18:50.557 --> 01:18:51.207
we get more.

01:18:51.208 --> 01:18:51.948
We get interest.

01:18:51.948 --> 01:18:52.707
We get interest on

01:18:52.708 --> 01:18:54.277
interest." Amazing.

01:18:55.598 --> 01:18:56.058
It's pretty hard

01:18:56.058 --> 01:18:56.558
for any other

01:18:56.558 --> 01:18:57.157
business model to

01:18:57.157 --> 01:18:57.897
compete with that.

01:18:59.447 --> 01:19:00.067
Particularly if the

01:19:00.068 --> 01:19:01.827
interest was not

01:19:01.907 --> 01:19:05.307
very low, soon the

01:19:05.307 --> 01:19:06.107
interest on interest

01:19:06.107 --> 01:19:07.397
would be enormous.

01:19:08.467 --> 01:19:09.497
And for the whole

01:19:09.497 --> 01:19:10.958
economy, this meant

01:19:10.958 --> 01:19:12.117
that new money was

01:19:12.117 --> 01:19:13.327
now being created.

01:19:14.107 --> 01:19:14.537
Why?

01:19:15.028 --> 01:19:17.637
Because the deposit

01:19:17.638 --> 01:19:18.307
receipts were being

01:19:18.307 --> 01:19:19.667
used as money, but

01:19:19.668 --> 01:19:21.407
now some of the gold,

01:19:21.427 --> 01:19:22.137
the underlying gold,

01:19:22.137 --> 01:19:23.627
was also extracted

01:19:23.987 --> 01:19:26.197
from the safe place

01:19:26.297 --> 01:19:27.537
and was circulating.

01:19:29.247 --> 01:19:29.967
So you expand

01:19:29.967 --> 01:19:30.567
the money supply.

01:19:30.717 --> 01:19:31.187
But this is just

01:19:31.187 --> 01:19:31.827
the beginning and

01:19:31.827 --> 01:19:32.837
potentially is

01:19:32.867 --> 01:19:34.347
only a theoretical

01:19:34.367 --> 01:19:36.097
story because quite

01:19:36.097 --> 01:19:36.927
immediately, the

01:19:37.237 --> 01:19:37.617
goldsmiths would

01:19:37.617 --> 01:19:38.047
realize, "Oh,

01:19:38.047 --> 01:19:38.578
there's a better

01:19:38.578 --> 01:19:39.568
way of doing this."

01:19:43.630 --> 01:19:44.510
So one of the

01:19:44.520 --> 01:19:45.230
goldsmiths at some

01:19:45.230 --> 01:19:45.680
stage will have

01:19:45.680 --> 01:19:46.580
said to us, "Listen,

01:19:46.580 --> 01:19:47.400
guys, we're missing

01:19:47.950 --> 01:19:48.730
a trick here.

01:19:49.100 --> 01:19:49.820
The next guy who

01:19:49.830 --> 01:19:51.130
comes to borrow

01:19:51.130 --> 01:19:51.680
money, I'll show

01:19:51.680 --> 01:19:52.490
you  what we need

01:19:52.490 --> 01:19:53.170
to do." "Okay,

01:19:53.170 --> 01:19:53.740
we'll stay here.

01:19:53.740 --> 01:19:54.210
We'll hang around

01:19:54.210 --> 01:19:54.660
in your shop."

01:19:54.660 --> 01:19:55.160
"Yeah, he always

01:19:55.160 --> 01:19:56.410
comes around at this

01:19:56.410 --> 01:19:57.719
time every week.

01:19:57.939 --> 01:19:58.630
I always turn him

01:19:58.630 --> 01:19:59.080
down, but I'll

01:19:59.080 --> 01:19:59.740
give him a small

01:19:59.740 --> 01:20:00.339
loan today."

01:20:00.999 --> 01:20:02.459
"Oh, dear goldsmith,

01:20:03.400 --> 01:20:04.080
here he is.

01:20:04.839 --> 01:20:05.960
I need this money.

01:20:05.960 --> 01:20:06.290
I'm, I've,

01:20:06.360 --> 01:20:07.130
I'm desperate.

01:20:07.620 --> 01:20:08.570
I need this money.

01:20:08.909 --> 01:20:09.479
Please give it to

01:20:09.479 --> 01:20:11.299
me now."  Okay.

01:20:11.480 --> 01:20:11.790
I've looked

01:20:11.790 --> 01:20:12.549
at your case.

01:20:12.599 --> 01:20:13.339
I've looked at the

01:20:13.630 --> 01:20:14.769
collateral you have,

01:20:14.769 --> 01:20:16.820
and  and yeah  some

01:20:16.820 --> 01:20:17.500
of your daughters

01:20:17.519 --> 01:20:18.249
are quite beautiful.

01:20:19.220 --> 01:20:20.420
Here's the contract,

01:20:20.490 --> 01:20:21.159
it's the usual

01:20:21.170 --> 01:20:21.990
clauses, small

01:20:21.990 --> 01:20:23.679
print,  obviously,

01:20:23.679 --> 01:20:24.489
the interest when you

01:20:24.490 --> 01:20:25.969
have to repay it  and

01:20:26.849 --> 01:20:27.609
your family will be

01:20:27.610 --> 01:20:28.509
sold into slavery if

01:20:28.509 --> 01:20:29.399
you can't pay  just

01:20:29.450 --> 01:20:31.159
minor small print.

01:20:31.619 --> 01:20:32.359
Just sign here.

01:20:32.549 --> 01:20:33.060
Oh, wait, and just

01:20:33.060 --> 01:20:33.679
one more thing,

01:20:33.700 --> 01:20:34.309
one more thing,

01:20:34.779 --> 01:20:35.709
and that is,

01:20:38.924 --> 01:20:39.994
I want you to deposit

01:20:39.994 --> 01:20:41.064
the money with me.

01:20:42.314 --> 01:20:42.974
I need the money.

01:20:42.974 --> 01:20:43.774
I need to pay.

01:20:44.584 --> 01:20:45.224
But you get the p-

01:20:45.454 --> 01:20:46.504
deposit receipt.

01:20:47.154 --> 01:20:47.974
Oh, yes, of course.

01:20:47.974 --> 01:20:49.073
Yeah  I can pay.

01:20:49.554 --> 01:20:50.844
I can pay anyone with

01:20:50.844 --> 01:20:51.444
a deposit receipt.

01:20:51.444 --> 01:20:51.973
That's fine.

01:20:51.974 --> 01:20:52.673
Yeah, I'll deposit

01:20:52.674 --> 01:20:53.183
it with you.

01:20:54.224 --> 01:20:56.364
So when this

01:20:56.364 --> 01:20:57.734
happened, four

01:20:57.734 --> 01:20:58.504
things happened.

01:20:58.513 --> 01:20:59.604
First of all, the

01:20:59.604 --> 01:21:00.643
breach of contract

01:21:00.644 --> 01:21:01.783
becomes fraud

01:21:01.824 --> 01:21:03.124
because a fictitious

01:21:03.124 --> 01:21:04.043
deposit receipt

01:21:04.044 --> 01:21:05.783
is issued, because

01:21:05.783 --> 01:21:07.114
no new deposit

01:21:07.173 --> 01:21:08.094
actually happened.

01:21:10.404 --> 01:21:10.933
So the goldsmith

01:21:10.934 --> 01:21:11.314
says, "You're

01:21:11.314 --> 01:21:12.104
borrowing the gold.

01:21:12.104 --> 01:21:12.723
Here's the gold.

01:21:12.723 --> 01:21:13.534
Now you see it.

01:21:13.673 --> 01:21:14.483
Now you deposit

01:21:14.484 --> 01:21:15.073
it, so now you

01:21:15.074 --> 01:21:15.653
don't see it.

01:21:15.953 --> 01:21:16.273
Here's your

01:21:16.274 --> 01:21:17.163
deposit receipt

01:21:20.462 --> 01:21:21.362
That is fraud.

01:21:21.452 --> 01:21:22.222
It's fraudulent.

01:21:22.382 --> 01:21:22.982
How do we know

01:21:22.982 --> 01:21:23.492
it's fraud?

01:21:23.702 --> 01:21:24.472
There's two ways to

01:21:24.532 --> 01:21:25.602
quickly prove this.

01:21:26.482 --> 01:21:27.352
Here's a man going

01:21:27.352 --> 01:21:28.262
to the goldsmith,

01:21:28.332 --> 01:21:29.551
no gold on him

01:21:29.561 --> 01:21:30.342
on the way.

01:21:30.862 --> 01:21:31.332
Okay?

01:21:33.720 --> 01:21:34.550
and leaves the

01:21:34.550 --> 01:21:34.940
goldsmith with a

01:21:34.940 --> 01:21:35.640
deposit receipt

01:21:35.640 --> 01:21:36.180
claiming he's

01:21:36.180 --> 01:21:36.990
deposited gold.

01:21:37.000 --> 01:21:38.080
How is that possible?

01:21:39.050 --> 01:21:39.510
It's a physical

01:21:39.510 --> 01:21:40.130
impossibility, so

01:21:40.140 --> 01:21:40.690
therefore, this is a

01:21:40.690 --> 01:21:41.710
fraudulent document.

01:21:42.059 --> 01:21:42.380
Of course, the

01:21:42.400 --> 01:21:43.260
other way to check

01:21:43.269 --> 01:21:44.320
it is just check

01:21:44.340 --> 01:21:45.229
the reserves, the

01:21:45.230 --> 01:21:46.080
gold reserves,

01:21:47.139 --> 01:21:47.449
the gold pile at

01:21:47.450 --> 01:21:47.579
the goldsmith.

01:21:47.590 --> 01:21:48.330
Did it increase?

01:21:48.360 --> 01:21:48.910
No.

01:21:49.500 --> 01:21:49.980
There's no net

01:21:49.980 --> 01:21:51.510
increase, so

01:21:51.510 --> 01:21:52.110
it is fraud.

01:21:54.169 --> 01:21:56.460
Secondly, the

01:21:56.470 --> 01:21:57.159
business model

01:21:57.159 --> 01:21:57.740
now got really

01:21:57.740 --> 01:21:58.379
attractive.

01:21:58.409 --> 01:22:00.329
You can just generate

01:22:00.349 --> 01:22:01.430
exponential revenue

01:22:01.440 --> 01:22:02.330
growth, interest,

01:22:02.339 --> 01:22:03.240
compound interest.

01:22:04.899 --> 01:22:05.219
And what are

01:22:05.220 --> 01:22:05.539
you doing?

01:22:05.540 --> 01:22:07.700
You're just writing

01:22:08.009 --> 01:22:09.090
on pieces of paper,

01:22:09.750 --> 01:22:12.199
issuing fictitious

01:22:12.199 --> 01:22:13.219
deposit receipts.

01:22:13.390 --> 01:22:14.140
That is a very

01:22:14.140 --> 01:22:14.540
attractive

01:22:14.550 --> 01:22:15.309
business model.

01:22:16.969 --> 01:22:18.180
Thirdly, now you

01:22:18.180 --> 01:22:19.079
can really expand

01:22:19.079 --> 01:22:19.999
the money supply.

01:22:21.969 --> 01:22:23.810
And fourthly, and

01:22:23.879 --> 01:22:25.249
very momentously,

01:22:27.210 --> 01:22:28.480
banking was born.

01:22:28.699 --> 01:22:29.759
This is banking.

01:22:31.449 --> 01:22:32.019
This is what

01:22:32.030 --> 01:22:32.869
happened in Europe

01:22:35.734 --> 01:22:36.634
And very sadly

01:22:36.634 --> 01:22:37.424
for all of us

01:22:39.726 --> 01:22:40.196
This was so

01:22:40.196 --> 01:22:40.955
well hidden.

01:22:42.246 --> 01:22:44.455
Now we need  the

01:22:44.455 --> 01:22:45.635
more useful for

01:22:45.635 --> 01:22:46.316
this sort of thing,

01:22:46.326 --> 01:22:46.996
the more useful

01:22:47.005 --> 01:22:48.016
type of accounting.

01:22:48.346 --> 01:22:49.516
Single entry cash

01:22:49.516 --> 01:22:50.185
flow accounting

01:22:50.186 --> 01:22:50.965
won't do it.

01:22:51.075 --> 01:22:51.875
It's obvious there's

01:22:51.875 --> 01:22:53.395
no cash flow here.

01:22:55.235 --> 01:22:58.106
So we need double

01:22:58.106 --> 01:22:59.186
entry accounting,

01:22:59.945 --> 01:23:01.446
the misleading

01:23:01.476 --> 01:23:04.025
type which was born

01:23:07.515 --> 01:23:08.755
thanks to the need

01:23:08.775 --> 01:23:10.145
of the bankers, the

01:23:10.146 --> 01:23:11.205
goldsmith bankers,

01:23:11.525 --> 01:23:12.345
to hide what they

01:23:12.356 --> 01:23:13.685
were doing and

01:23:13.685 --> 01:23:14.705
keep it covered up.

01:23:15.275 --> 01:23:16.025
And at the same

01:23:16.025 --> 01:23:16.726
time, the problem

01:23:16.726 --> 01:23:18.585
was that, of course,

01:23:18.595 --> 01:23:20.135
even governments were

01:23:20.156 --> 01:23:21.495
borrowing money from

01:23:21.496 --> 01:23:22.906
goldsmith bankers.

01:23:24.705 --> 01:23:25.505
And as it's written

01:23:25.505 --> 01:23:27.896
in Proverbs 22:7,

01:23:28.246 --> 01:23:29.365
"The borrower is

01:23:29.365 --> 01:23:30.196
servant to the

01:23:30.196 --> 01:23:30.696
lender." That's

01:23:30.696 --> 01:23:31.505
why Kublai Khan

01:23:31.505 --> 01:23:32.455
would never borrow.

01:23:33.015 --> 01:23:33.515
He doesn't wanna

01:23:33.525 --> 01:23:34.085
be servant.

01:23:34.095 --> 01:23:34.946
He's a ruler.

01:23:35.755 --> 01:23:37.056
He did not want to

01:23:37.066 --> 01:23:38.445
be and would not be

01:23:38.835 --> 01:23:40.275
a servant to anyone

01:23:44.174 --> 01:23:45.014
The borrower

01:23:45.224 --> 01:23:46.124
is servant to

01:23:46.124 --> 01:23:46.674
the lender.

01:23:46.674 --> 01:23:47.764
So governments,

01:23:47.794 --> 01:23:49.384
kings, monarchs

01:23:50.124 --> 01:23:50.964
borrowed from

01:23:50.964 --> 01:23:51.624
the bankers.

01:23:51.644 --> 01:23:52.774
They thought, " we

01:23:52.774 --> 01:23:53.314
need money.

01:23:53.624 --> 01:23:54.424
They have the money.

01:23:54.454 --> 01:23:54.784
We're gonna

01:23:54.794 --> 01:23:55.134
borrow it.

01:23:55.134 --> 01:23:55.934
Yes, we pay interest.

01:23:55.934 --> 01:23:56.754
Yes, we agree to

01:23:56.754 --> 01:23:57.944
all these clauses,

01:23:58.264 --> 01:23:59.234
and yes, they become

01:23:59.244 --> 01:24:00.364
lords, and we'll make

01:24:00.364 --> 01:24:01.544
them aristocrats and

01:24:01.553 --> 01:24:02.813
everything, and we'll

01:24:02.813 --> 01:24:04.634
introduce new  legal

01:24:04.634 --> 01:24:05.433
frameworks as they

01:24:05.434 --> 01:24:06.734
advise us to do.

01:24:07.953 --> 01:24:08.404
Yes, we'll

01:24:08.404 --> 01:24:09.214
do all that.

01:24:09.443 --> 01:24:10.464
We have no choice,"

01:24:10.523 --> 01:24:11.474
is what they thought.

01:24:13.014 --> 01:24:13.903
They didn't realize

01:24:13.924 --> 01:24:15.043
they could issue

01:24:15.053 --> 01:24:16.444
money just like the

01:24:16.554 --> 01:24:17.523
Goldsmith bankers

01:24:17.523 --> 01:24:18.754
were actually doing.

01:24:19.253 --> 01:24:19.894
But of course, that

01:24:19.894 --> 01:24:20.953
was very well-hidden

01:24:23.352 --> 01:24:24.501
And so our

01:24:24.512 --> 01:24:25.982
governments since

01:24:25.982 --> 01:24:26.991
then have become

01:24:28.102 --> 01:24:30.932
servants to the

01:24:30.932 --> 01:24:31.811
lenders that they

01:24:31.812 --> 01:24:32.451
borrowed from.

01:24:32.862 --> 01:24:33.701
So the first paper

01:24:33.701 --> 01:24:34.262
money in Europe

01:24:34.271 --> 01:24:35.041
was, of course,

01:24:35.081 --> 01:24:36.011
deposit receipts.

01:24:36.012 --> 01:24:36.511
This is from

01:24:36.521 --> 01:24:38.641
Stockholm's Banco

01:24:38.641 --> 01:24:39.831
credit settle

01:24:41.852 --> 01:24:43.321
confirming deposit

01:24:43.331 --> 01:24:44.501
of paper money.

01:24:45.861 --> 01:24:46.982
You may not realize,

01:24:47.001 --> 01:24:47.842
but until the

01:24:47.842 --> 01:24:48.491
introduction of

01:24:48.491 --> 01:24:49.241
central banks, and

01:24:49.241 --> 01:24:49.932
central banks are

01:24:49.941 --> 01:24:50.962
a recent thing,

01:24:51.012 --> 01:24:52.352
mostly 20th century

01:24:52.361 --> 01:24:54.382
thing, all the paper

01:24:54.382 --> 01:24:56.751
money was bank money

01:24:57.691 --> 01:24:59.921
issued  by banks.

01:25:04.238 --> 01:25:04.908
It's only when the

01:25:04.908 --> 01:25:05.738
central banks then

01:25:05.738 --> 01:25:06.428
were introduced,

01:25:06.428 --> 01:25:07.618
usually privately

01:25:07.618 --> 01:25:08.548
owned originally

01:25:09.498 --> 01:25:10.168
by the big

01:25:10.178 --> 01:25:11.448
banking dynasties,

01:25:12.468 --> 01:25:12.978
they managed to

01:25:12.988 --> 01:25:14.687
hide this fact.

01:25:14.688 --> 01:25:15.238
Because it's of

01:25:15.238 --> 01:25:16.087
course more obvious

01:25:16.108 --> 01:25:16.868
if you've got

01:25:19.268 --> 01:25:20.138
paper money issued

01:25:20.148 --> 01:25:21.758
by commercial banks,

01:25:21.777 --> 01:25:22.498
you start to think,

01:25:22.648 --> 01:25:23.328
" how is that possible

01:25:23.328 --> 01:25:24.137
that commercial banks

01:25:24.158 --> 01:25:24.967
issue paper money?

01:25:25.617 --> 01:25:26.687
Maybe banks create

01:25:26.687 --> 01:25:29.108
money."  so this came

01:25:29.108 --> 01:25:30.147
to be well-hidden,

01:25:30.457 --> 01:25:32.807
except in the United

01:25:32.808 --> 01:25:36.738
Kingdom  in Scotland

01:25:36.797 --> 01:25:38.608
and Northern Ireland,

01:25:38.677 --> 01:25:39.497
because  they're

01:25:39.497 --> 01:25:41.177
not England, and

01:25:41.188 --> 01:25:42.728
laws  the English

01:25:42.728 --> 01:25:43.717
laws are England and

01:25:43.718 --> 01:25:46.217
Wales, but Scotland

01:25:46.218 --> 01:25:47.737
has separate laws,

01:25:47.787 --> 01:25:48.537
and Northern Ireland

01:25:48.537 --> 01:25:49.238
has separate laws.

01:25:49.238 --> 01:25:50.347
So when the Bank

01:25:50.348 --> 01:25:51.897
of England Act was

01:25:53.067 --> 01:25:55.737
introduced  since

01:25:55.738 --> 01:25:56.818
then it's …  It's,

01:25:57.127 --> 01:25:59.118
it was only valid in

01:25:59.118 --> 01:25:59.738
England and Wales,

01:25:59.738 --> 01:26:00.508
not in Scotland and

01:26:00.508 --> 01:26:01.048
Northern Ireland.

01:26:01.048 --> 01:26:03.307
So the banks, the

01:26:03.328 --> 01:26:04.337
commercial ordinary

01:26:04.347 --> 01:26:05.778
banks there, until

01:26:05.778 --> 01:26:07.257
this day kept

01:26:07.258 --> 01:26:08.108
their privilege of

01:26:08.148 --> 01:26:09.467
issuing paper money.

01:26:09.778 --> 01:26:10.998
Clydesdale Bank in

01:26:10.998 --> 01:26:14.257
Scotland, Royal  Bank

01:26:14.257 --> 01:26:15.587
of Scotland, which is

01:26:15.598 --> 01:26:16.388
separate from Royal

01:26:16.418 --> 01:26:17.227
Bank of Scotland.

01:26:18.907 --> 01:26:19.337
Then of course

01:26:19.337 --> 01:26:20.067
Northern Bank,

01:26:20.077 --> 01:26:21.347
First Trust, Bank

01:26:21.357 --> 01:26:22.297
of Ireland, Bank of

01:26:22.308 --> 01:26:23.438
Ulster, and so on.

01:26:23.787 --> 01:26:24.988
I've got two here,

01:26:26.168 --> 01:26:27.417
Bank of Scotland,

01:26:27.517 --> 01:26:29.097
just to sh- to

01:26:29.098 --> 01:26:30.297
circulate and show

01:26:30.297 --> 01:26:31.798
that it's not a

01:26:31.798 --> 01:26:32.858
made-up story.

01:26:33.037 --> 01:26:33.548
You can still

01:26:33.548 --> 01:26:34.038
get them.

01:26:34.857 --> 01:26:35.567
Royal Bank

01:26:35.567 --> 01:26:36.397
of Scotland.

01:26:36.458 --> 01:26:37.097
Bank of Scotland,

01:26:37.098 --> 01:26:37.567
Royal Bank of

01:26:37.567 --> 01:26:39.328
Scotland, if

01:26:39.328 --> 01:26:40.007
you return them

01:26:40.028 --> 01:26:40.458
afterwards.

01:26:43.337 --> 01:26:44.077
And of course in Hong

01:26:44.077 --> 01:26:44.948
Kong we see this too,

01:26:44.948 --> 01:26:46.357
because the Chinese

01:26:46.357 --> 01:26:47.367
government agreed for

01:26:47.387 --> 01:26:48.637
50 years to preserve

01:26:48.668 --> 01:26:50.247
the system in place,

01:26:50.297 --> 01:26:50.957
and that includes

01:26:50.958 --> 01:26:52.067
the monetary system,

01:26:52.357 --> 01:26:52.938
and that was the

01:26:52.967 --> 01:26:54.558
old British system,

01:26:54.587 --> 01:26:56.168
which similar to

01:26:56.168 --> 01:26:56.937
Scotland, Northern

01:26:56.937 --> 01:26:58.047
Ireland, the banks

01:26:58.077 --> 01:26:58.917
issue paper money.

01:26:58.918 --> 01:27:00.077
So the paper money

01:27:00.087 --> 01:27:00.977
in Hong Kong today

01:27:00.997 --> 01:27:03.127
is  either issued

01:27:03.127 --> 01:27:05.507
by HSBC or Standard

01:27:05.507 --> 01:27:07.617
Chartered or the Bank

01:27:07.617 --> 01:27:08.878
of China, which is

01:27:08.878 --> 01:27:10.827
a Hong Kong bank.

01:27:11.687 --> 01:27:12.207
But it's not the

01:27:12.207 --> 01:27:12.847
People's Bank of

01:27:12.848 --> 01:27:14.827
China, so it's   it's

01:27:14.827 --> 01:27:15.697
a commercial bank.

01:27:15.697 --> 01:27:16.998
Happens to have  a

01:27:16.998 --> 01:27:17.977
large government

01:27:17.988 --> 01:27:19.407
stake in it, but it's

01:27:19.407 --> 01:27:20.257
not the central bank.

01:27:20.258 --> 01:27:21.588
So banks issue

01:27:21.588 --> 01:27:21.938
paper money.

01:27:22.917 --> 01:27:23.877
The banks stopped

01:27:23.887 --> 01:27:24.878
issuing 10 Hong

01:27:24.878 --> 01:27:25.377
Kong dollar

01:27:25.377 --> 01:27:26.587
notes, which is

01:27:29.387 --> 01:27:30.268
which is less than

01:27:30.377 --> 01:27:32.858
$2, US dollars worth

01:27:32.858 --> 01:27:33.487
of money, because

01:27:33.488 --> 01:27:33.967
they thought it's

01:27:33.967 --> 01:27:34.898
not worth it, but

01:27:34.898 --> 01:27:35.528
the population

01:27:35.538 --> 01:27:36.618
likes those notes.

01:27:36.657 --> 01:27:39.427
They  were unhappy,

01:27:39.428 --> 01:27:40.197
and so that's the

01:27:40.197 --> 01:27:40.808
first time the

01:27:40.808 --> 01:27:41.617
Hong Kong Monetary

01:27:41.617 --> 01:27:42.297
Authority actually

01:27:42.307 --> 01:27:43.227
issued paper money,

01:27:43.738 --> 01:27:44.597
is because the

01:27:44.807 --> 01:27:45.408
commercial banks

01:27:45.408 --> 01:27:46.467
refused to issue

01:27:47.027 --> 01:27:48.277
$10 notes, so then

01:27:48.288 --> 01:27:49.167
we also have the

01:27:49.167 --> 01:27:50.047
Hong Kong Monetary

01:27:50.047 --> 01:27:50.987
Authority issuing

01:27:51.747 --> 01:27:53.627
only the $10 notes.

01:27:55.417 --> 01:27:56.347
So now it's time to

01:27:56.348 --> 01:27:57.557
come back to my quiz

01:27:57.557 --> 01:27:58.627
question for you

01:28:00.694 --> 01:28:01.454
Why does this

01:28:01.474 --> 01:28:03.874
clay tablet exist?

01:28:05.494 --> 01:28:07.814
Why did King

01:28:07.824 --> 01:28:09.314
Nebuchadnezzar II and

01:28:09.314 --> 01:28:10.304
his prime minister,

01:28:10.304 --> 01:28:13.034
Nebusarsekim, why

01:28:13.034 --> 01:28:13.564
did they think it's

01:28:13.564 --> 01:28:14.843
a good idea to have

01:28:14.904 --> 01:28:16.134
a deposit receipt?

01:28:17.603 --> 01:28:18.443
So they could

01:28:18.443 --> 01:28:19.143
sell it.

01:28:19.143 --> 01:28:20.823
So they could use it.

01:28:20.834 --> 01:28:22.313
So they can use it.

01:28:22.404 --> 01:28:23.053
So they can use

01:28:23.054 --> 01:28:24.114
it, and how can

01:28:24.114 --> 01:28:24.543
they use it?

01:28:24.724 --> 01:28:25.303
They can only use

01:28:25.304 --> 01:28:26.463
it if it's accepted

01:28:26.523 --> 01:28:27.383
by everyone.

01:28:28.013 --> 01:28:28.724
And how can it be

01:28:28.724 --> 01:28:31.034
accepted by everyone?

01:28:31.734 --> 01:28:33.213
If people believe

01:28:33.854 --> 01:28:34.943
they've deposited

01:28:34.953 --> 01:28:37.093
gold at the temple.

01:28:38.733 --> 01:28:39.333
Did they actually

01:28:39.334 --> 01:28:40.004
deposit gold

01:28:40.004 --> 01:28:40.694
at the temple?

01:28:41.683 --> 01:28:42.263
We can't be

01:28:42.264 --> 01:28:44.644
100% sure, but

01:28:46.674 --> 01:28:47.853
it stands to reason

01:28:47.854 --> 01:28:49.484
that whenever you

01:28:49.484 --> 01:28:50.533
have a system where

01:28:50.564 --> 01:28:51.793
deposits receipts

01:28:51.793 --> 01:28:53.943
are issued, that in

01:28:53.943 --> 01:28:55.213
themselves intrinsic

01:28:55.213 --> 01:28:56.903
value, paper, clay

01:28:57.793 --> 01:29:00.083
is  very low, but

01:29:00.084 --> 01:29:01.283
the monetary value

01:29:01.283 --> 01:29:02.893
described in them as

01:29:02.904 --> 01:29:03.893
having been deposited

01:29:03.904 --> 01:29:05.294
is very high.

01:29:05.703 --> 01:29:06.313
And when the gap

01:29:06.334 --> 01:29:07.573
is very large,

01:29:07.914 --> 01:29:08.863
human nature being

01:29:08.863 --> 01:29:11.214
what it is, we can

01:29:11.214 --> 01:29:13.203
infer that the fake

01:29:13.213 --> 01:29:14.123
deposit receipts.

01:29:16.194 --> 01:29:17.163
Now, this little pie-

01:29:17.544 --> 01:29:18.354
look how small it is.

01:29:18.354 --> 01:29:20.113
This is like this,

01:29:20.584 --> 01:29:21.423
and the edges are

01:29:21.433 --> 01:29:22.363
somewhat round

01:29:22.363 --> 01:29:23.053
as if it's been

01:29:23.054 --> 01:29:24.044
circulating.

01:29:24.904 --> 01:29:26.073
It's a very clever

01:29:26.173 --> 01:29:27.233
piece of monetary

01:29:27.243 --> 01:29:28.213
infrastructure.

01:29:29.283 --> 01:29:30.343
A deposit receipt

01:29:30.353 --> 01:29:30.973
that says the

01:29:30.974 --> 01:29:31.873
king and his prime

01:29:31.874 --> 01:29:32.323
minister have

01:29:32.323 --> 01:29:33.403
deposited 750

01:29:33.404 --> 01:29:35.463
grams of gold was

01:29:35.474 --> 01:29:37.774
likely worth 750

01:29:37.774 --> 01:29:38.743
grams of gold.

01:29:38.983 --> 01:29:39.453
That's almost

01:29:39.453 --> 01:29:40.573
a kilo of gold.

01:29:40.584 --> 01:29:41.333
What's a kilo of

01:29:41.334 --> 01:29:42.443
gold worth today?

01:29:42.923 --> 01:29:46.013
Talking about  60,

01:29:46.013 --> 01:29:46.613
70,000 euros.

01:29:47.783 --> 01:29:48.763
That's a lot of money

01:29:49.043 --> 01:29:49.853
for this tiny piece

01:29:49.853 --> 01:29:51.054
of earth, turning

01:29:51.303 --> 01:29:52.203
earth into gold.

01:29:52.233 --> 01:29:53.033
That's alchemy

01:29:56.526 --> 01:29:57.385
So likely what

01:29:57.396 --> 01:29:59.666
happened is that the,

01:30:00.916 --> 01:30:01.786
the government got a

01:30:01.786 --> 01:30:03.106
loan from the temple

01:30:05.334 --> 01:30:06.824
And the temple issued

01:30:06.824 --> 01:30:10.314
the loan by  the

01:30:10.314 --> 01:30:11.634
government depositing

01:30:11.634 --> 01:30:12.684
the loaned money

01:30:13.273 --> 01:30:14.114
immediately with the

01:30:14.114 --> 01:30:16.554
temple and receiving

01:30:16.554 --> 01:30:17.644
the deposit receipt,

01:30:19.414 --> 01:30:20.864
which you can hide

01:30:20.864 --> 01:30:22.173
very well in double

01:30:22.173 --> 01:30:23.164
entry accounting

01:30:26.892 --> 01:30:27.542
We know also the

01:30:27.542 --> 01:30:28.362
first paper money

01:30:28.362 --> 01:30:29.262
in Japan was

01:30:29.262 --> 01:30:30.372
again similarly

01:30:33.152 --> 01:30:33.922
it was silver

01:30:33.952 --> 01:30:35.982
deposited at shrines.

01:30:35.992 --> 01:30:36.731
Shrines like

01:30:36.732 --> 01:30:38.441
temples  this is

01:30:38.541 --> 01:30:40.481
shrines of the  the

01:30:40.482 --> 01:30:42.691
Shinto  faith,

01:30:43.712 --> 01:30:44.701
and the highest

01:30:45.302 --> 01:30:46.552
ranked shrine is

01:30:46.552 --> 01:30:47.971
the Ise Shrine in,

01:30:47.991 --> 01:30:49.341
in middle Japan

01:30:49.641 --> 01:30:50.832
on Honshu Island.

01:30:51.772 --> 01:30:52.431
And we know that

01:30:52.432 --> 01:30:53.171
this is the first

01:30:53.171 --> 01:30:53.691
paper money.

01:30:53.692 --> 01:30:54.522
They're deposit

01:30:54.532 --> 01:30:56.491
receipts for silver

01:30:56.671 --> 01:30:58.911
and likely, likewise,

01:30:59.202 --> 01:31:00.712
fake deposit receipts

01:31:01.161 --> 01:31:01.992
because that's how

01:31:02.001 --> 01:31:02.882
loans were given

01:31:02.882 --> 01:31:03.912
out by the temple.

01:31:05.281 --> 01:31:06.662
So that's how

01:31:06.671 --> 01:31:07.411
double-entry

01:31:07.411 --> 01:31:08.841
accounting emerged.

01:31:10.121 --> 01:31:11.281
Interest was

01:31:11.281 --> 01:31:13.332
forbidden, therefore

01:31:13.351 --> 01:31:14.771
charging interest and

01:31:16.831 --> 01:31:18.292
receiving interest

01:31:18.292 --> 01:31:19.361
payments was

01:31:19.362 --> 01:31:20.341
kept secret, both

01:31:20.342 --> 01:31:21.361
parties happy to

01:31:21.362 --> 01:31:22.031
keep it secret.

01:31:22.042 --> 01:31:23.491
That allowed the

01:31:23.551 --> 01:31:24.681
goldsmith bankers

01:31:24.711 --> 01:31:25.791
to commit fraud

01:31:25.842 --> 01:31:26.711
and keep the fraud

01:31:26.711 --> 01:31:27.931
secret because they

01:31:27.932 --> 01:31:28.712
wanted to keep the

01:31:28.712 --> 01:31:29.851
secret, not just

01:31:29.871 --> 01:31:30.141
because of the

01:31:30.141 --> 01:31:30.912
interest, but also

01:31:30.921 --> 01:31:32.402
the whole process of

01:31:32.421 --> 01:31:33.541
money creation, and

01:31:33.542 --> 01:31:34.722
therefore empowering

01:31:35.031 --> 01:31:35.731
private sector

01:31:35.731 --> 01:31:37.042
commercial operators,

01:31:37.301 --> 01:31:37.991
giving them more

01:31:37.991 --> 01:31:38.792
power than the

01:31:38.792 --> 01:31:40.142
government, therefore

01:31:40.142 --> 01:31:41.011
giving them power

01:31:41.061 --> 01:31:42.172
over the government.

01:31:42.692 --> 01:31:43.361
As the government

01:31:43.371 --> 01:31:44.101
borrows from

01:31:44.101 --> 01:31:45.661
them, they became

01:31:45.671 --> 01:31:46.561
the government.

01:31:47.491 --> 01:31:47.901
And of course,

01:31:47.902 --> 01:31:49.492
that was to change

01:31:49.711 --> 01:31:51.381
world history as

01:31:51.381 --> 01:31:52.541
they rose to power.

01:31:54.371 --> 01:31:54.982
Now, as we

01:31:54.982 --> 01:31:55.991
said, impossible

01:31:56.001 --> 01:31:56.631
single-entry

01:31:56.631 --> 01:31:57.291
accounting.

01:31:57.821 --> 01:31:59.161
But if you have

01:31:59.161 --> 01:32:00.232
the right clever

01:32:00.262 --> 01:32:02.381
type of accounting,

01:32:03.351 --> 01:32:04.312
you can hide this

01:32:04.312 --> 01:32:05.491
fact from the eyes

01:32:05.521 --> 01:32:06.561
of the public.

01:32:07.061 --> 01:32:07.612
They can see

01:32:07.612 --> 01:32:08.481
the numbers.

01:32:08.862 --> 01:32:09.861
They have eyes,

01:32:10.231 --> 01:32:11.231
but they don't see.

01:32:12.011 --> 01:32:13.062
They hear, if you

01:32:13.062 --> 01:32:14.181
read them out, as in

01:32:14.182 --> 01:32:14.991
the Court of Audit

01:32:14.991 --> 01:32:16.741
of the Exchequer, of

01:32:16.741 --> 01:32:17.622
the Norman Exchequer.

01:32:18.042 --> 01:32:19.092
They can hear, but

01:32:19.092 --> 01:32:20.762
they don't hear

01:32:20.832 --> 01:32:21.811
what is being said.

01:32:21.862 --> 01:32:22.541
They see, but

01:32:22.542 --> 01:32:23.221
they don't see.

01:32:25.661 --> 01:32:26.721
Now the evidence, the

01:32:26.721 --> 01:32:27.201
empirical evidence,

01:32:27.231 --> 01:32:27.821
this has just been

01:32:27.821 --> 01:32:28.681
published last

01:32:28.691 --> 01:32:30.231
year, is that the

01:32:30.231 --> 01:32:31.381
first double-entry

01:32:31.381 --> 01:32:32.691
accounting was

01:32:32.902 --> 01:32:34.491
used predictably,

01:32:34.912 --> 01:32:35.581
as I've been

01:32:35.711 --> 01:32:37.811
saying, by a bank.

01:32:38.761 --> 01:32:39.841
We're not surprised.

01:32:41.112 --> 01:32:42.081
In twelve hundred

01:32:42.081 --> 01:32:42.371
and eleven--

01:32:42.371 --> 01:32:43.442
Obv-obviously  there

01:32:43.442 --> 01:32:45.181
may be older cases.

01:32:45.181 --> 01:32:45.711
We just don't

01:32:45.711 --> 01:32:46.321
have the record.

01:32:46.371 --> 01:32:47.241
So the first record

01:32:47.241 --> 01:32:47.931
we have, and that

01:32:47.931 --> 01:32:48.922
has been identified,

01:32:48.922 --> 01:32:49.972
was from twelve

01:32:49.972 --> 01:32:52.162
hundred eleven from

01:32:52.162 --> 01:32:53.571
Florence, not too

01:32:53.571 --> 01:32:54.571
far away from here,

01:32:55.011 --> 01:32:55.531
where, of course, the

01:32:55.531 --> 01:32:57.281
Medici banking family

01:32:57.281 --> 01:32:59.181
became so dominant.

01:32:59.391 --> 01:33:01.531
Popes were Medici

01:33:01.531 --> 01:33:02.682
popes, and therefore,

01:33:02.682 --> 01:33:03.672
they were anointing

01:33:03.741 --> 01:33:04.541
emperors of the

01:33:04.541 --> 01:33:05.501
Holy Roman Empires.

01:33:05.501 --> 01:33:06.322
You can imagine

01:33:06.332 --> 01:33:07.541
the scale of power

01:33:08.692 --> 01:33:09.731
of the bankers

01:33:12.518 --> 01:33:13.138
so I've been

01:33:13.138 --> 01:33:13.758
maintaining that

01:33:13.758 --> 01:33:14.288
double-entry

01:33:14.288 --> 01:33:14.918
accounting was

01:33:14.918 --> 01:33:16.078
invented to help

01:33:16.088 --> 01:33:17.628
banks hide their

01:33:17.728 --> 01:33:19.088
standard MO,

01:33:19.128 --> 01:33:20.398
modus operandi.

01:33:23.258 --> 01:33:23.918
And how do

01:33:23.918 --> 01:33:25.737
we know that

01:33:27.968 --> 01:33:28.498
this has been a

01:33:28.498 --> 01:33:29.277
successful way

01:33:29.277 --> 01:33:30.257
to hide this?

01:33:30.998 --> 01:33:31.768
Because it was-- it

01:33:31.768 --> 01:33:32.898
remained disputed

01:33:32.937 --> 01:33:34.818
until 2014 whether

01:33:34.828 --> 01:33:35.607
banks actually

01:33:35.607 --> 01:33:36.458
create money.

01:33:38.598 --> 01:33:39.227
I had to do the

01:33:39.228 --> 01:33:40.088
first empirical

01:33:40.088 --> 01:33:41.737
test, published in

01:33:41.738 --> 01:33:44.807
2014, proving for the

01:33:44.808 --> 01:33:46.067
first time that, yes,

01:33:46.078 --> 01:33:46.937
banks create money.

01:33:46.938 --> 01:33:47.808
Whenever a bank

01:33:47.817 --> 01:33:48.648
gives a loan, it

01:33:48.657 --> 01:33:50.037
newly creates money

01:33:50.078 --> 01:33:50.868
out of nothing.

01:33:52.137 --> 01:33:52.788
Until then, that

01:33:52.788 --> 01:33:53.647
was considered a

01:33:53.648 --> 01:33:55.888
conspiracy theory and

01:33:55.898 --> 01:33:58.377
was highly disputed.

01:33:58.817 --> 01:33:59.618
Even today, the

01:33:59.618 --> 01:34:00.917
textbooks still

01:34:01.127 --> 01:34:02.037
ignore this.

01:34:03.137 --> 01:34:03.607
They-- So they

01:34:03.607 --> 01:34:04.248
ignore this

01:34:04.248 --> 01:34:05.748
empirical scientific

01:34:05.748 --> 01:34:06.477
finding published

01:34:06.477 --> 01:34:07.067
in peer-reviewed

01:34:07.067 --> 01:34:07.577
journals.

01:34:08.877 --> 01:34:09.577
But it cannot be

01:34:09.578 --> 01:34:10.518
disputed anymore

01:34:12.622 --> 01:34:13.582
So this is how

01:34:13.582 --> 01:34:14.342
this truth has

01:34:14.352 --> 01:34:16.372
been  hidden.

01:34:16.372 --> 01:34:16.912
And of course,

01:34:17.362 --> 01:34:17.942
double-entry

01:34:17.942 --> 01:34:18.312
accounting,

01:34:18.312 --> 01:34:19.572
therefore  is useful

01:34:19.622 --> 01:34:20.462
to have a look at.

01:34:22.542 --> 01:34:24.002
Warren Buffett says

01:34:24.522 --> 01:34:25.592
you gotta understand

01:34:25.592 --> 01:34:26.251
accounting.

01:34:26.292 --> 01:34:26.931
It's the, it's

01:34:26.931 --> 01:34:27.692
a language.

01:34:28.332 --> 01:34:28.662
You gotta

01:34:28.662 --> 01:34:29.551
understand it.

01:34:30.032 --> 01:34:30.472
And I would

01:34:30.472 --> 01:34:31.522
go deeper.

01:34:31.552 --> 01:34:31.911
You've gotta

01:34:31.911 --> 01:34:32.762
understand also the

01:34:32.772 --> 01:34:34.132
logic of double-entry

01:34:34.132 --> 01:34:36.531
accounting  and

01:34:36.532 --> 01:34:37.552
see the trick.

01:34:38.161 --> 01:34:38.781
Then you really

01:34:38.782 --> 01:34:39.262
understand

01:34:39.262 --> 01:34:40.032
what's going on.

01:34:40.321 --> 01:34:40.921
Obviously, whether

01:34:40.921 --> 01:34:41.671
you want to invest

01:34:41.681 --> 01:34:43.051
money and by

01:34:43.831 --> 01:34:45.082
analyzing stocks,

01:34:45.111 --> 01:34:46.362
analyzing companies,

01:34:46.721 --> 01:34:47.681
financial statements,

01:34:47.681 --> 01:34:49.102
or whatever, nowadays

01:34:49.102 --> 01:34:49.862
it is double-entry

01:34:49.862 --> 01:34:50.422
accounting, so

01:34:50.442 --> 01:34:50.891
you gotta be

01:34:50.892 --> 01:34:51.571
familiar with it.

01:34:51.602 --> 01:34:52.881
Assets, liabilities.

01:34:54.011 --> 01:34:54.751
On the liability

01:34:54.751 --> 01:34:55.462
side, we've got

01:34:56.912 --> 01:34:57.612
what's called below

01:34:57.612 --> 01:34:58.921
the line equity,

01:34:58.951 --> 01:35:01.231
owned capital, a

01:35:01.241 --> 01:35:02.161
liability to the

01:35:02.192 --> 01:35:03.422
owner, so to speak.

01:35:04.541 --> 01:35:05.501
So really, what

01:35:05.501 --> 01:35:06.122
the double-entry

01:35:06.122 --> 01:35:07.131
accounting shows is

01:35:07.131 --> 01:35:08.012
on liability side,

01:35:08.012 --> 01:35:08.832
where the money

01:35:08.832 --> 01:35:11.181
has come from, and

01:35:11.181 --> 01:35:11.891
on the asset side,

01:35:11.892 --> 01:35:13.041
where it has gone.

01:35:13.741 --> 01:35:14.181
And this is what a

01:35:14.181 --> 01:35:15.571
lot of people still

01:35:15.571 --> 01:35:16.571
today misunderstand,

01:35:16.571 --> 01:35:17.501
a lot of experts

01:35:17.501 --> 01:35:18.242
misunderstand when

01:35:18.242 --> 01:35:18.711
they look at the

01:35:18.721 --> 01:35:19.941
bank balance sheet.

01:35:20.842 --> 01:35:21.501
And they say things

01:35:21.501 --> 01:35:22.172
like, "Oh  banks

01:35:22.181 --> 01:35:22.912
should have more

01:35:22.912 --> 01:35:23.981
reserves, more

01:35:23.982 --> 01:35:24.842
capital. Have

01:35:24.842 --> 01:35:25.601
more capital, more

01:35:25.601 --> 01:35:27.072
equity, then they're

01:35:27.072 --> 01:35:29.112
safer." At the

01:35:29.112 --> 01:35:30.921
moment, most bank

01:35:31.001 --> 01:35:32.661
equity is only 10%.

01:35:34.581 --> 01:35:35.181
Oh, we need to

01:35:35.181 --> 01:35:35.921
increase it to

01:35:35.921 --> 01:35:38.041
20%, 30%, whatever

01:35:38.041 --> 01:35:38.661
it may be.

01:35:39.651 --> 01:35:40.322
Then the banks

01:35:40.322 --> 01:35:40.981
are safer.

01:35:41.552 --> 01:35:42.051
It is a

01:35:42.061 --> 01:35:42.901
misunderstanding.

01:35:44.052 --> 01:35:45.042
For some reason,

01:35:45.131 --> 01:35:47.031
people still think

01:35:47.041 --> 01:35:49.001
that equity is

01:35:49.031 --> 01:35:50.461
money that's somehow

01:35:50.471 --> 01:35:51.671
there in the company

01:35:51.671 --> 01:35:52.601
or in the bank.

01:35:54.391 --> 01:35:55.912
Remember, liability

01:35:55.912 --> 01:35:56.631
side tells you

01:35:56.631 --> 01:35:57.311
where the money

01:35:57.321 --> 01:35:59.032
has come from.

01:35:59.141 --> 01:35:59.741
That's all.

01:36:00.092 --> 01:36:00.941
It's a record for

01:36:00.942 --> 01:36:02.231
where it came from.

01:36:02.241 --> 01:36:03.751
If you wanna know

01:36:03.751 --> 01:36:05.801
where it is  look

01:36:05.802 --> 01:36:06.681
at where it has

01:36:06.721 --> 01:36:08.591
gone to, which is

01:36:08.592 --> 01:36:09.432
also past tense.

01:36:09.442 --> 01:36:11.412
It has gone to

01:36:11.412 --> 01:36:12.272
the asset side.

01:36:12.552 --> 01:36:13.031
So even if you

01:36:13.031 --> 01:36:14.301
increase bank equity

01:36:14.302 --> 01:36:16.552
from 10% to, say,

01:36:16.552 --> 01:36:17.831
30%  that just

01:36:17.831 --> 01:36:19.462
tells you, okay, so

01:36:19.521 --> 01:36:20.761
30% of the balance

01:36:20.761 --> 01:36:22.412
sheet  was raised

01:36:22.412 --> 01:36:23.322
through equity.

01:36:23.511 --> 01:36:23.862
That's where

01:36:23.862 --> 01:36:24.651
it came from.

01:36:25.071 --> 01:36:25.371
And where

01:36:25.372 --> 01:36:26.331
has it gone?

01:36:26.802 --> 01:36:28.131
It's gone, and

01:36:28.131 --> 01:36:28.702
you look at the

01:36:28.711 --> 01:36:29.571
asset side where

01:36:29.581 --> 01:36:30.921
it has gone to.

01:36:36.686 --> 01:36:37.866
Yes, m- a lot of

01:36:37.875 --> 01:36:38.476
people are just

01:36:38.545 --> 01:36:40.596
not really familiar

01:36:40.596 --> 01:36:41.596
with how one has to

01:36:41.596 --> 01:36:42.826
read balance sheets.

01:36:43.366 --> 01:36:44.266
So keep that in mind.

01:36:44.266 --> 01:36:45.066
Very simply,

01:36:45.316 --> 01:36:46.096
liabilities, where

01:36:46.096 --> 01:36:47.206
money has come from,

01:36:47.316 --> 01:36:48.896
assets, where money

01:36:48.905 --> 01:36:51.736
has gone to, and it's

01:36:51.755 --> 01:36:52.706
always past tense and

01:36:52.706 --> 01:36:53.925
the money is gone.

01:36:54.596 --> 01:36:55.056
You have these

01:36:55.056 --> 01:36:56.816
assets, okay, but

01:36:56.816 --> 01:36:57.645
the money is gone.

01:36:58.715 --> 01:36:59.165
Of course, we

01:36:59.165 --> 01:36:59.615
have different

01:36:59.625 --> 01:37:00.575
types of financial

01:37:00.585 --> 01:37:01.535
statements, the

01:37:01.545 --> 01:37:02.545
balance sheet, which

01:37:02.545 --> 01:37:03.496
we just looked at.

01:37:04.135 --> 01:37:04.665
There's also the

01:37:04.665 --> 01:37:05.226
income statement,

01:37:05.226 --> 01:37:05.946
which is the flow.

01:37:05.955 --> 01:37:06.625
Balance sheet is

01:37:06.635 --> 01:37:08.885
stock, and the

01:37:08.886 --> 01:37:09.415
income statement

01:37:09.415 --> 01:37:10.645
or P&L, profit and

01:37:10.645 --> 01:37:11.665
loss statement, is

01:37:11.886 --> 01:37:13.175
the flow statement

01:37:14.075 --> 01:37:15.055
that tells you

01:37:17.235 --> 01:37:18.715
revenues minus

01:37:18.715 --> 01:37:20.125
costs is profit.

01:37:21.995 --> 01:37:22.605
And then we have a

01:37:22.605 --> 01:37:23.896
cash flow statement,

01:37:25.075 --> 01:37:26.085
and so that is really

01:37:26.116 --> 01:37:27.446
what the old single

01:37:27.446 --> 01:37:28.705
entry accounting used

01:37:28.715 --> 01:37:29.706
to be based on, the

01:37:29.875 --> 01:37:31.005
cash flow statement.

01:37:31.655 --> 01:37:32.495
But now it's just

01:37:32.505 --> 01:37:33.805
one of four types

01:37:33.805 --> 01:37:35.076
of statements, and

01:37:35.076 --> 01:37:35.665
then statement of

01:37:35.675 --> 01:37:37.115
stockholders' equity

01:37:38.645 --> 01:37:40.286
are the, the four

01:37:40.286 --> 01:37:41.146
major statements.

01:37:41.146 --> 01:37:42.205
But mostly the first

01:37:42.226 --> 01:37:43.685
two are what analysts

01:37:43.686 --> 01:37:44.325
are looking at,

01:37:44.336 --> 01:37:45.295
and there's a few

01:37:45.296 --> 01:37:46.395
more details there.

01:37:46.395 --> 01:37:46.986
We can share

01:37:46.986 --> 01:37:47.875
the slides.

01:37:48.446 --> 01:37:50.096
So you may wonder

01:37:52.152 --> 01:37:53.312
How is it possible

01:37:53.312 --> 01:37:55.952
that this momentous

01:37:55.972 --> 01:37:56.962
truth, how

01:37:57.282 --> 01:37:59.342
essentially the

01:37:59.342 --> 01:38:02.592
world's wealth,

01:38:02.682 --> 01:38:04.202
assets, resources,

01:38:04.212 --> 01:38:05.362
financial system

01:38:05.972 --> 01:38:07.412
has been captured

01:38:07.491 --> 01:38:09.271
by a small group

01:38:09.271 --> 01:38:10.451
of entrepreneurs

01:38:12.630 --> 01:38:14.600
And until recently,

01:38:14.630 --> 01:38:15.320
they've managed to

01:38:15.320 --> 01:38:17.260
keep it pretty quiet.

01:38:18.070 --> 01:38:18.790
Most people had

01:38:18.790 --> 01:38:19.720
not realized what's

01:38:19.720 --> 01:38:20.650
been going on.

01:38:23.930 --> 01:38:24.760
What are the tools

01:38:24.760 --> 01:38:25.250
and techniques?

01:38:25.250 --> 01:38:25.970
And we saw one.

01:38:25.970 --> 01:38:26.660
It's double entry

01:38:26.660 --> 01:38:29.139
accounting, which

01:38:29.149 --> 01:38:30.640
is a clever way to

01:38:31.529 --> 01:38:33.790
misrepresent  or

01:38:33.830 --> 01:38:35.450
represent in its   in

01:38:35.450 --> 01:38:37.050
a, in such a way that

01:38:37.050 --> 01:38:37.650
most people don't

01:38:37.650 --> 01:38:38.119
understand what's

01:38:38.129 --> 01:38:38.669
going… Maybe I

01:38:38.670 --> 01:38:39.990
should just add here.

01:38:40.389 --> 01:38:41.359
So okay, let's talk

01:38:41.369 --> 01:38:42.349
about a bank loan.

01:38:44.250 --> 01:38:44.870
What happens

01:38:44.870 --> 01:38:45.909
with a bank loan?

01:38:50.335 --> 01:38:50.826
And of course, the

01:38:50.835 --> 01:38:51.656
other important

01:38:52.375 --> 01:38:53.316
activity of a bank is

01:38:53.316 --> 01:38:54.375
to receive deposits.

01:38:54.385 --> 01:38:55.205
So if you receive a

01:38:55.205 --> 01:38:56.455
deposit at a bank,

01:38:57.056 --> 01:38:58.056
that's a liability,

01:38:58.056 --> 01:38:59.026
so it's recorded

01:38:59.365 --> 01:39:00.356
as a liability.

01:39:00.715 --> 01:39:01.556
And if a bank then

01:39:01.556 --> 01:39:02.335
lends money, it's

01:39:02.335 --> 01:39:04.806
recorded as an asset.

01:39:05.056 --> 01:39:05.335
Why?

01:39:05.335 --> 01:39:06.865
Because the loan

01:39:06.865 --> 01:39:08.255
contract is an asset.

01:39:08.255 --> 01:39:09.146
It's a claim on

01:39:09.146 --> 01:39:10.445
somebody that

01:39:10.505 --> 01:39:11.295
certain amounts will

01:39:11.306 --> 01:39:12.355
be repaid in the

01:39:12.355 --> 01:39:13.545
future, and also

01:39:13.825 --> 01:39:15.245
claim on the interest

01:39:17.678 --> 01:39:18.498
And so deposits

01:39:18.498 --> 01:39:19.188
on liability

01:39:19.188 --> 01:39:20.918
side and loans on

01:39:20.918 --> 01:39:22.048
the asset side.

01:39:25.178 --> 01:39:26.038
And then you see

01:39:26.038 --> 01:39:26.657
the balance sheet

01:39:26.668 --> 01:39:27.827
balances, and

01:39:27.827 --> 01:39:28.708
you don't see the

01:39:28.718 --> 01:39:29.748
money creation.

01:39:30.647 --> 01:39:31.607
What you do see

01:39:31.607 --> 01:39:32.897
is balance sheets

01:39:33.308 --> 01:39:34.117
lengthening,

01:39:34.297 --> 01:39:35.327
and that is the

01:39:35.327 --> 01:39:36.218
money creation.

01:39:36.918 --> 01:39:38.317
So the--  we'll talk

01:39:38.317 --> 01:39:39.367
more about the, the

01:39:39.367 --> 01:39:40.867
mechanics tomorrow.

01:39:44.037 --> 01:39:45.237
But already  I think

01:39:45.237 --> 01:39:45.987
it helps to know

01:39:45.987 --> 01:39:47.268
that overall, the

01:39:47.268 --> 01:39:49.318
principle is that the

01:39:49.318 --> 01:39:50.127
lengthening of the

01:39:50.137 --> 01:39:51.028
balance sheet is how

01:39:51.028 --> 01:39:51.878
the money creation

01:39:51.878 --> 01:39:52.798
is being expressed.

01:39:52.798 --> 01:39:53.588
And because both

01:39:53.588 --> 01:39:55.598
sides are expanding,

01:39:55.598 --> 01:39:56.227
they're always…

01:39:56.667 --> 01:39:57.657
It's a balance sheet.

01:39:57.657 --> 01:39:59.038
It always balances.

01:39:59.347 --> 01:40:00.617
It looks okay.

01:40:00.617 --> 01:40:01.608
What's the problem?

01:40:04.137 --> 01:40:05.287
Liabilities go up,

01:40:05.297 --> 01:40:06.398
yes, but assets go

01:40:06.398 --> 01:40:07.228
up, so everything

01:40:07.228 --> 01:40:07.787
is balanced.

01:40:07.807 --> 01:40:08.267
There's nothing

01:40:08.277 --> 01:40:09.137
to see here.

01:40:09.428 --> 01:40:10.007
Move on.

01:40:10.018 --> 01:40:11.087
Look somewhere else.

01:40:11.657 --> 01:40:12.237
And so the money

01:40:12.237 --> 01:40:13.038
creation process

01:40:14.137 --> 01:40:14.958
is not seen.

01:40:15.007 --> 01:40:17.227
We will focus on that

01:40:18.707 --> 01:40:19.737
and explain that in

01:40:19.737 --> 01:40:21.367
detail tomorrow when

01:40:21.367 --> 01:40:23.528
we discuss the three

01:40:23.538 --> 01:40:25.348
theories of banking

01:40:28.910 --> 01:40:29.410
You probably

01:40:29.410 --> 01:40:30.670
think that in

01:40:30.670 --> 01:40:32.130
the 21st century,

01:40:32.849 --> 01:40:34.050
understanding of

01:40:34.269 --> 01:40:35.309
we've got AI and

01:40:35.309 --> 01:40:36.130
we've got all these

01:40:36.490 --> 01:40:38.019
tools, information

01:40:38.019 --> 01:40:40.429
sources, surely

01:40:40.430 --> 01:40:41.550
the banking process

01:40:41.550 --> 01:40:42.820
is well understood

01:40:45.526 --> 01:40:46.696
a theme tomorrow

01:40:46.706 --> 01:40:48.236
will be deception

01:40:52.270 --> 01:40:53.430
If the goal is to

01:40:53.460 --> 01:40:54.740
hide certain things,

01:40:54.790 --> 01:40:56.200
then certain tools of

01:40:56.200 --> 01:40:57.060
deception are being

01:40:57.060 --> 01:40:58.150
de-deployed, and that

01:40:58.150 --> 01:40:59.490
explains why certain

01:40:59.500 --> 01:41:00.609
truths have not been

01:41:00.619 --> 01:41:01.680
seen for a long time.

01:41:03.230 --> 01:41:04.080
When you look at how

01:41:04.090 --> 01:41:05.670
banks work, actually

01:41:05.680 --> 01:41:06.290
it turns out there's

01:41:06.290 --> 01:41:07.470
three theories that

01:41:07.470 --> 01:41:08.410
exist and have been

01:41:08.420 --> 01:41:09.160
around for more

01:41:09.160 --> 01:41:10.009
than a century.

01:41:11.690 --> 01:41:13.280
The textbooks and

01:41:13.280 --> 01:41:14.149
the, the leading

01:41:14.149 --> 01:41:16.440
journals essentially

01:41:16.610 --> 01:41:17.830
use the first one of

01:41:17.830 --> 01:41:18.879
these, the financial

01:41:18.899 --> 01:41:19.819
intermediation

01:41:19.819 --> 01:41:20.909
theory of banking.

01:41:22.010 --> 01:41:22.610
But there are

01:41:22.639 --> 01:41:25.010
two others, older

01:41:25.040 --> 01:41:26.369
theories, the

01:41:26.369 --> 01:41:27.080
fractional reserve

01:41:27.080 --> 01:41:28.589
theory of banking and

01:41:28.590 --> 01:41:29.659
the credit creation

01:41:29.659 --> 01:41:30.540
theory of banking.

01:41:31.169 --> 01:41:32.299
But they're basically

01:41:32.329 --> 01:41:33.700
being dismissed as

01:41:34.659 --> 01:41:35.659
old theories which

01:41:35.659 --> 01:41:36.779
are not correct

01:41:37.159 --> 01:41:37.960
and have been

01:41:40.110 --> 01:41:41.209
improved on by the

01:41:41.209 --> 01:41:42.259
current dominant

01:41:42.259 --> 01:41:42.879
theory, the financial

01:41:42.880 --> 01:41:43.490
intermediation

01:41:43.490 --> 01:41:43.839
theory.

01:41:44.619 --> 01:41:44.919
What does

01:41:44.919 --> 01:41:45.649
this financial

01:41:45.649 --> 01:41:46.089
intermediation

01:41:46.090 --> 01:41:46.809
theory say?

01:41:48.110 --> 01:41:48.839
It says essentially

01:41:48.840 --> 01:41:51.349
that banks gather

01:41:51.349 --> 01:41:54.019
deposits, so they

01:41:54.020 --> 01:41:54.820
gather money, and

01:41:55.459 --> 01:41:56.829
then they analyze

01:41:56.850 --> 01:41:58.250
loan applications,

01:41:58.709 --> 01:41:59.880
and then selectively

01:41:59.880 --> 01:42:01.000
lend the money to

01:42:01.000 --> 01:42:02.280
where  it's efficient

01:42:02.280 --> 01:42:03.539
and effective and

01:42:03.539 --> 01:42:05.110
safe to lend it to

01:42:05.130 --> 01:42:06.060
receive interest.

01:42:07.009 --> 01:42:07.289
So they're

01:42:07.289 --> 01:42:08.029
intermediaries in

01:42:08.039 --> 01:42:08.650
the sense that they

01:42:08.659 --> 01:42:10.050
receive money, and

01:42:10.050 --> 01:42:10.810
then they lend out

01:42:10.810 --> 01:42:11.999
the money, doing

01:42:11.999 --> 01:42:13.259
their banking work

01:42:13.569 --> 01:42:14.470
in the process.

01:42:15.259 --> 01:42:16.139
That is the financial

01:42:16.139 --> 01:42:16.469
intermediation

01:42:16.469 --> 01:42:16.749
theory.

01:42:16.749 --> 01:42:17.159
And again,

01:42:17.459 --> 01:42:18.509
it's logical.

01:42:19.620 --> 01:42:20.599
There's great logic

01:42:20.600 --> 01:42:21.480
in it and lots of

01:42:21.490 --> 01:42:23.740
details  credit

01:42:23.740 --> 01:42:26.079
analysis, and lots of

01:42:26.099 --> 01:42:27.629
data available on it.

01:42:28.429 --> 01:42:29.170
So most people think,

01:42:29.490 --> 01:42:30.529
" it's logical, so

01:42:30.529 --> 01:42:31.479
it must be true."

01:42:31.569 --> 01:42:33.240
But remember, just

01:42:33.249 --> 01:42:33.889
because something

01:42:33.889 --> 01:42:34.889
is logical does

01:42:34.889 --> 01:42:36.119
not mean it's true.

01:42:37.009 --> 01:42:38.130
This is the single

01:42:38.139 --> 01:42:38.910
biggest tool of

01:42:38.929 --> 01:42:39.780
deception that's

01:42:39.780 --> 01:42:42.199
used in not just

01:42:42.200 --> 01:42:42.809
economics, but

01:42:42.849 --> 01:42:43.480
actually also

01:42:43.490 --> 01:42:44.270
other disciplines.

01:42:44.270 --> 01:42:44.680
It's been so

01:42:44.680 --> 01:42:45.159
successful in

01:42:45.159 --> 01:42:46.139
economics that now

01:42:46.179 --> 01:42:47.209
other disciplines

01:42:47.729 --> 01:42:48.469
suffer from the

01:42:48.469 --> 01:42:49.819
same distortion,

01:42:51.049 --> 01:42:53.110
that logic is

01:42:53.119 --> 01:42:55.169
used and seen as

01:42:55.529 --> 01:42:56.930
substitute for truth,

01:42:57.479 --> 01:42:58.429
which it's not.

01:42:59.770 --> 01:43:00.419
We'll look at that

01:43:00.430 --> 01:43:01.419
in greater detail.

01:43:02.820 --> 01:43:03.619
Can I ask you, what

01:43:03.639 --> 01:43:05.109
is the scientific

01:43:05.130 --> 01:43:07.339
way of finding out

01:43:08.579 --> 01:43:09.769
how banks work?

01:43:10.109 --> 01:43:10.979
We're being presented

01:43:10.979 --> 01:43:11.729
with three theories.

01:43:11.729 --> 01:43:12.529
I haven't explained

01:43:12.529 --> 01:43:13.240
the other two.

01:43:13.579 --> 01:43:14.309
There's-- each

01:43:14.309 --> 01:43:15.099
has some great

01:43:15.109 --> 01:43:16.089
logic to it.

01:43:16.409 --> 01:43:16.949
Okay?

01:43:17.669 --> 01:43:18.310
But how do we know

01:43:18.310 --> 01:43:19.159
which one is true?

01:43:20.972 --> 01:43:21.932
What's the scientific

01:43:21.952 --> 01:43:23.472
way of finding out?

01:43:24.102 --> 01:43:24.192
Test.

01:43:25.362 --> 01:43:26.732
A test, yes.

01:43:26.772 --> 01:43:27.462
Did you say that?

01:43:27.842 --> 01:43:28.282
Empirical

01:43:28.282 --> 01:43:29.182
test, exactly.

01:43:29.692 --> 01:43:30.122
Yes.

01:43:30.692 --> 01:43:31.162
We need an

01:43:31.162 --> 01:43:32.162
empirical test.

01:43:32.472 --> 01:43:33.112
In fact, it's a good

01:43:33.112 --> 01:43:34.242
example where we

01:43:34.242 --> 01:43:35.562
have three different

01:43:35.562 --> 01:43:36.732
types of logic,

01:43:37.501 --> 01:43:38.732
and each is more

01:43:38.732 --> 01:43:40.332
or less convincing.

01:43:40.342 --> 01:43:41.082
Maybe the middle

01:43:41.082 --> 01:43:44.321
one is  challenging

01:43:45.151 --> 01:43:46.692
to, to f- to follow

01:43:48.752 --> 01:43:49.642
and also see its

01:43:49.672 --> 01:43:50.841
logical consistency

01:43:50.842 --> 01:43:51.752
entirely.

01:43:52.782 --> 01:43:53.291
But anyway, so

01:43:53.291 --> 01:43:53.752
we've got three

01:43:53.752 --> 01:43:54.382
different theories.

01:43:54.382 --> 01:43:55.381
They're all logical,

01:43:56.091 --> 01:43:56.831
so all of them

01:43:56.892 --> 01:43:57.942
could be true,

01:43:58.771 --> 01:43:59.452
and that's all

01:43:59.452 --> 01:44:00.521
logic can ever do.

01:44:00.561 --> 01:44:02.842
It can  present

01:44:03.021 --> 01:44:04.391
possible theoretical

01:44:04.392 --> 01:44:06.202
worlds, but logic

01:44:06.212 --> 01:44:07.112
can never tell

01:44:07.112 --> 01:44:08.731
you which of those

01:44:08.762 --> 01:44:09.222
possibilities

01:44:09.222 --> 01:44:09.531
is true.

01:44:09.731 --> 01:44:10.422
So what usually

01:44:10.422 --> 01:44:12.261
happens is that only

01:44:12.262 --> 01:44:13.691
one logic will be

01:44:13.692 --> 01:44:14.861
presented and will

01:44:14.861 --> 01:44:15.862
be presented as

01:44:15.862 --> 01:44:17.621
the truth because

01:44:17.881 --> 01:44:18.802
it's logical, it's

01:44:18.811 --> 01:44:19.321
convincing, it's

01:44:19.321 --> 01:44:21.261
consistent, it's

01:44:21.282 --> 01:44:22.151
gotta be true.

01:44:22.241 --> 01:44:22.951
No, that one

01:44:22.951 --> 01:44:24.751
doesn't follow, and

01:44:24.762 --> 01:44:25.641
that's the trick.

01:44:27.571 --> 01:44:28.422
So actually, you

01:44:28.422 --> 01:44:29.131
will find there's

01:44:29.162 --> 01:44:30.362
alternative

01:44:31.461 --> 01:44:32.541
explanations,

01:44:32.662 --> 01:44:33.811
different logics

01:44:33.821 --> 01:44:35.122
which are equally

01:44:35.122 --> 01:44:36.821
consistent and could

01:44:36.821 --> 01:44:38.041
be true, and the only

01:44:38.041 --> 01:44:39.231
way to find out is to

01:44:39.232 --> 01:44:40.561
do an empirical test.

01:44:41.001 --> 01:44:41.731
And we'll-- I'll

01:44:41.732 --> 01:44:42.341
show you one.

01:44:42.342 --> 01:44:43.012
So I ran this

01:44:43.012 --> 01:44:44.041
empirical test

01:44:46.991 --> 01:44:47.661
at a bank

01:44:49.998 --> 01:44:50.538
I thought the only

01:44:50.538 --> 01:44:51.388
way to find out is

01:44:51.388 --> 01:44:52.577
to actually take out

01:44:52.577 --> 01:44:54.577
a loan and record

01:44:54.598 --> 01:44:55.508
exactly what is

01:44:55.508 --> 01:44:56.788
going on inside the

01:44:56.788 --> 01:44:59.077
bank as I borrow.

01:44:59.077 --> 01:44:59.548
And I borrowed

01:44:59.588 --> 01:44:59.918
two hundred

01:44:59.918 --> 01:45:00.958
thousand euros.

01:45:03.687 --> 01:45:04.598
The biggest challenge

01:45:04.598 --> 01:45:05.148
was to find a

01:45:05.148 --> 01:45:05.628
bank that would

01:45:05.628 --> 01:45:06.758
agree to do this.

01:45:08.637 --> 01:45:09.392
Initially, they were

01:45:09.392 --> 01:45:10.138
like, "Of course,

01:45:10.138 --> 01:45:11.607
we support research

01:45:11.627 --> 01:45:12.277
and financial

01:45:12.277 --> 01:45:13.108
research, of course.

01:45:13.108 --> 01:45:13.697
And you wanna do

01:45:13.697 --> 01:45:14.657
a test on banking?

01:45:14.668 --> 01:45:16.227
Of course." Yes.

01:45:16.227 --> 01:45:16.447
Yes.

01:45:16.447 --> 01:45:16.787
Yes.

01:45:16.807 --> 01:45:17.707
It's all yes.

01:45:18.137 --> 01:45:19.297
But then as you get

01:45:20.547 --> 01:45:21.638
close to the point

01:45:21.957 --> 01:45:22.588
and, okay, now we

01:45:22.588 --> 01:45:23.798
need  to do it,

01:45:23.827 --> 01:45:24.688
we need to do the

01:45:24.688 --> 01:45:25.527
test, and I need

01:45:25.527 --> 01:45:26.297
to borrow money.

01:45:26.297 --> 01:45:27.167
I need to s- look

01:45:27.187 --> 01:45:28.367
inside your system,

01:45:29.897 --> 01:45:30.527
see your accounting,

01:45:30.527 --> 01:45:31.447
see your IT, and see

01:45:31.448 --> 01:45:32.877
exactly what happens.

01:45:34.108 --> 01:45:34.957
All the big banks,

01:45:34.957 --> 01:45:35.697
one after another,

01:45:35.727 --> 01:45:36.277
dropped out.

01:45:36.277 --> 01:45:36.847
They say, " no,

01:45:36.847 --> 01:45:37.577
we can't do that.

01:45:37.577 --> 01:45:38.858
There's…" And  the

01:45:38.858 --> 01:45:40.357
list of reasons

01:45:40.358 --> 01:45:41.237
and excuses is

01:45:41.237 --> 01:45:42.497
long, from, of

01:45:42.498 --> 01:45:43.157
course, client

01:45:43.167 --> 01:45:43.977
confidentiality,

01:45:43.977 --> 01:45:44.537
which you usually,

01:45:44.537 --> 01:45:46.018
as researcher, you

01:45:46.018 --> 01:45:46.588
know, university

01:45:46.588 --> 01:45:47.447
academic, you can get

01:45:47.448 --> 01:45:48.207
an exemption from.

01:45:48.207 --> 01:45:49.287
But no  there's

01:45:49.287 --> 01:45:50.338
that sensitivity.

01:45:50.338 --> 01:45:51.197
There's regulatory

01:45:52.317 --> 01:45:53.148
concerns.

01:45:53.148 --> 01:45:53.767
There's this, that,

01:45:53.777 --> 01:45:54.128
and the other.

01:45:54.137 --> 01:45:55.337
All this IT, nobody

01:45:55.338 --> 01:45:55.997
is allowed to look

01:45:56.727 --> 01:45:58.467
into this  and so on.

01:45:59.457 --> 01:46:00.407
But I found a small

01:46:00.418 --> 01:46:02.748
bank in Germany that

01:46:02.748 --> 01:46:04.527
was willing to do it.

01:46:06.027 --> 01:46:07.717
And it's a

01:46:07.717 --> 01:46:08.637
cooperative bank,

01:46:08.637 --> 01:46:09.187
and it's actually

01:46:09.187 --> 01:46:10.617
the part of the

01:46:10.617 --> 01:46:12.177
largest group of

01:46:12.507 --> 01:46:13.468
this type of banks,

01:46:13.477 --> 01:46:14.448
cooperative banks.

01:46:14.867 --> 01:46:15.688
The largest

01:46:17.808 --> 01:46:19.257
number of banks

01:46:19.327 --> 01:46:20.027
in Europe are

01:46:20.047 --> 01:46:21.227
cooperative banks,

01:46:21.857 --> 01:46:22.857
and the, the country

01:46:22.857 --> 01:46:23.317
with the largest

01:46:23.317 --> 01:46:23.757
number of banks

01:46:23.757 --> 01:46:24.438
is Germany, and

01:46:24.438 --> 01:46:25.247
this was a German

01:46:25.247 --> 01:46:26.107
cooperative bank.

01:46:26.407 --> 01:46:27.117
And they all use

01:46:27.117 --> 01:46:28.267
the same IT and the

01:46:28.268 --> 01:46:29.938
same software and

01:46:29.948 --> 01:46:30.897
obviously follow the

01:46:30.897 --> 01:46:31.867
same accounting and

01:46:31.867 --> 01:46:33.058
the same regulatory

01:46:34.687 --> 01:46:35.397
framework.

01:46:36.387 --> 01:46:37.027
Therefore, it is

01:46:37.027 --> 01:46:37.977
representative.

01:46:39.558 --> 01:46:40.407
And I'll present

01:46:40.407 --> 01:46:41.127
it tomorrow

01:46:43.786 --> 01:46:45.125
The, the question

01:46:45.406 --> 01:46:46.596
that the test focused

01:46:46.606 --> 01:46:47.856
on was the question

01:46:47.856 --> 01:46:49.446
of when a bank gives

01:46:49.446 --> 01:46:51.866
a loan, where does

01:46:51.866 --> 01:46:52.846
the money come from?

01:46:54.075 --> 01:46:55.175
That is the crux,

01:46:57.016 --> 01:46:57.556
and that's also

01:46:57.556 --> 01:46:58.146
where these three

01:46:58.155 --> 01:46:59.476
theories of banking

01:46:59.485 --> 01:47:00.315
are different.

01:47:01.025 --> 01:47:01.615
They have different

01:47:01.615 --> 01:47:02.616
explanations of where

01:47:02.616 --> 01:47:03.665
the money comes from

01:47:06.710 --> 01:47:07.420
And with this

01:47:07.470 --> 01:47:10.200
empirical test  I was

01:47:10.200 --> 01:47:11.240
able to confirm where

01:47:11.240 --> 01:47:11.660
the money came from.

01:47:11.760 --> 01:47:12.140
There's actually

01:47:12.140 --> 01:47:12.760
two tests.

01:47:12.760 --> 01:47:13.920
One was  the

01:47:13.920 --> 01:47:15.280
real live test.

01:47:17.019 --> 01:47:17.900
The tricky bit is

01:47:17.900 --> 01:47:19.579
that nowadays banks,

01:47:19.620 --> 01:47:20.240
through online

01:47:20.250 --> 01:47:21.789
banking  everything

01:47:21.790 --> 01:47:22.850
is constantly moving.

01:47:22.860 --> 01:47:23.559
All the parts

01:47:23.559 --> 01:47:24.049
are moving.

01:47:24.049 --> 01:47:25.139
There's always money

01:47:25.139 --> 01:47:26.180
flows, transactions

01:47:26.180 --> 01:47:26.580
happening.

01:47:26.580 --> 01:47:27.230
Even when the bank

01:47:27.230 --> 01:47:28.009
is closed, you

01:47:28.010 --> 01:47:28.809
still have online

01:47:28.820 --> 01:47:29.770
banking happening.

01:47:31.449 --> 01:47:32.369
So it made it

01:47:32.369 --> 01:47:32.760
slightly more

01:47:32.760 --> 01:47:33.930
complicated because

01:47:33.930 --> 01:47:35.149
we want to isolate

01:47:36.109 --> 01:47:38.040
the experimental

01:47:38.279 --> 01:47:39.600
test transaction,

01:47:39.600 --> 01:47:40.060
the two hundred

01:47:40.060 --> 01:47:41.630
thousand euros, and

01:47:41.630 --> 01:47:42.510
keep everything else

01:47:42.510 --> 01:47:43.599
constant, and that's

01:47:43.600 --> 01:47:44.540
not possible if you

01:47:44.540 --> 01:47:45.460
do a live experiment.

01:47:45.469 --> 01:47:46.369
So that's the first

01:47:46.479 --> 01:47:48.639
paper, where we then

01:47:48.650 --> 01:47:49.399
have to also look

01:47:49.400 --> 01:47:50.719
at the various live,

01:47:51.069 --> 01:47:51.800
you know, other

01:47:51.839 --> 01:47:52.580
things going on.

01:47:52.889 --> 01:47:53.790
And the second one

01:47:55.100 --> 01:47:55.839
was a procedure

01:47:55.839 --> 01:47:57.130
that banks use when

01:47:58.089 --> 01:48:00.349
when they-- when

01:48:00.350 --> 01:48:03.199
the annual record

01:48:03.479 --> 01:48:05.620
ends, but there's

01:48:06.199 --> 01:48:06.850
a small number

01:48:06.850 --> 01:48:07.600
of transactions,

01:48:07.619 --> 01:48:08.369
loan transactions,

01:48:08.379 --> 01:48:09.190
that still need

01:48:09.190 --> 01:48:09.879
to be for various

01:48:09.879 --> 01:48:10.689
reasons, including

01:48:10.689 --> 01:48:11.379
regulatory reasons,

01:48:11.379 --> 01:48:12.479
need to be in that

01:48:12.490 --> 01:48:13.690
year, but didn't

01:48:13.690 --> 01:48:15.110
quite make it with

01:48:15.259 --> 01:48:16.609
all the bureaucracy

01:48:16.609 --> 01:48:17.919
and compliance.

01:48:18.460 --> 01:48:19.239
And so they're adding

01:48:19.240 --> 01:48:21.529
it a few days  after

01:48:21.530 --> 01:48:22.270
the end of the year,

01:48:22.270 --> 01:48:23.520
say in, in early

01:48:23.530 --> 01:48:24.579
January, they add it

01:48:24.579 --> 01:48:25.929
to the previous year.

01:48:26.969 --> 01:48:28.109
And they use their

01:48:28.119 --> 01:48:29.550
main accounting

01:48:29.550 --> 01:48:30.620
system, online

01:48:30.620 --> 01:48:32.699
system, to do that.

01:48:32.710 --> 01:48:33.289
And when they do

01:48:33.289 --> 01:48:33.610
that, of course,

01:48:33.629 --> 01:48:34.110
everything else

01:48:34.149 --> 01:48:36.370
is frozen, and you

01:48:36.629 --> 01:48:37.399
can single out,

01:48:37.399 --> 01:48:38.250
you're just adding

01:48:38.250 --> 01:48:39.100
this transaction.

01:48:39.109 --> 01:48:39.650
So that was the

01:48:39.650 --> 01:48:40.409
second test.

01:48:40.920 --> 01:48:41.739
And of course, both

01:48:41.740 --> 01:48:42.420
were consistent,

01:48:42.429 --> 01:48:43.490
gave the same result

01:48:44.519 --> 01:48:45.279
and  we'll look

01:48:45.280 --> 01:48:46.079
at that tomorrow.

01:48:46.089 --> 01:48:47.429
I think overall

01:48:47.729 --> 01:48:48.819
we've covered as

01:48:48.820 --> 01:48:49.440
much as I wanted

01:48:49.449 --> 01:48:50.560
to cover today.

01:48:52.600 --> 01:48:53.509
Just get you

01:48:53.949 --> 01:48:55.379
sensitized to some

01:48:55.379 --> 01:48:57.049
of the core issues in

01:48:57.640 --> 01:48:59.259
our monetary system

01:48:59.929 --> 01:49:01.649
and  some lessons

01:49:01.649 --> 01:49:02.670
from history and how

01:49:02.670 --> 01:49:03.499
to look at things

01:49:03.499 --> 01:49:04.439
and also some of the,

01:49:04.439 --> 01:49:07.550
the concerns  that

01:49:07.559 --> 01:49:08.789
arise from that.

01:49:09.369 --> 01:49:09.829
Now we've got

01:49:09.829 --> 01:49:10.669
a discussion

01:49:10.960 --> 01:49:11.919
session later,

01:49:12.100 --> 01:49:12.639
so don't forget

01:49:12.649 --> 01:49:13.119
your questions.

01:49:13.119 --> 01:49:13.349
Thank

01:49:13.350 --> 01:49:14.000
you very much.

